Washington DC Standoff

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bill Hudson

501 Club
Hey Folks,

One of my contacts has this to say about the current standoff between President Bush and the Democrats in congress.

“… Republicans want to end the war, but not on a date picked by Democrats. And Democrats don't want to wave a white flag unless a Republican is holding it.”

Enjoy!

Bill
 
Jim Becker":3ah1r00t said:
While the other is losing by not ending it.

I don't do this very often but this time I couldn't hold back :!: :!:

The other :?: :?: and which one would that be :?: :?: Never mind I know your answer.

It's high time we do what’s best for the country and vote each and every one of those self serving SOB’s out of Washington and replace them.
“They” should be doing what’s best for the country not what’s best for "their" party.

You think there's a mess in the Middle East now :?: :?: Wave the white flag as some propose and then see what a mess we'll have.

I've had the honor to send 2 son's and 1 son in law, all 3 Marines to serve their country in that God for saken place, they would surely serve again if called and so would I.

Why is doing what's right so hard :?: :?: :?:

We've become spoiled, we watch a war from one side and one side only. Then we ask why has this taken so long :?: We sit here in our air conditioned easy chairs (made in China) drinking mint julips or sipping our cheap wine and think we have it so bad. How long did it take us to see the light about Nazi Germany :?: :?:

What we're up against isn't just Iraq and leaving Iraq will not solve the problem. We should prepare ourselves for something much bigger :!: :!:


Sorry for my rant...not :!:
8)
 
Why is doing what's right so hard

Donny, "Ditto" here! Proud to hear you have family that serve. At times I think we should have a system in place that would entice more young folks to enlist, I think if more young folks saw how it is to serve in whatever branch of the military, and see things differently from another angle, they would have a better appreciation for things.
 
Bottom line is we need term limits on all national political offices, but it'll never happen. These SOB's long ago forget their mission and concentrate solely on doing what's best to keep getting re-elected. The perks are unbelieveable. Craig
 
What would have happened if we had some arbitrary "pull-out" date during WWII regardless of the situation on the ground? Wir würden alle deutsch jetzt gleich sprechen. The idea that you can simply end a war by setting a date for it to end is almost incomprehensibly naive.

Most Americans don't have the patience or stomach for a long war. During a single 6 week battle in WWII (the Battle of the Bulge) we lost nearly 20,000 KIA! 20,000 KIA in 6 weeks. We've lost just over 3,000 in 4 years of fighting in Iraq. Yet, the white flags are going up. Dems proclaim that the war is lost. Some wacko liberal Hollyweird types and rockers are calling for the execution of a sitting President during a time of war.

I'm not claiming to be a big Bush fan. I'm not claiming to support the reasons we went to war in Iraq. And I'm not claiming to know it all. But I was there the first go-around in '91. I have the blood of fallen comrades on my desert BDU's, and I do support our troops. And you don't support the troops with defeatist, white-flag attitudes.
 
Bigschuss
Yes My Dad was at the Battle of the Bulge and I believe that is where he was woulded . He never once said it was wrong to be there. That era of folks. 60-80's years have a better knowlege of commitment and perserverance than I of 47 have yet to attain. God bless you Folks over 50 yrs out there. They have forgtten more than I know.
Thanks to all my elders!
Phil
 
Donny M":2vyil0a0 said:
I don't do this very often but this time I couldn't hold back :!: :!:

The other :?: :?: and which one would that be :?: :?: Never mind I know your answer.

It's high time we do what’s best for the country and vote each and every one of those self serving SOB’s out of Washington and replace them.
“They” should be doing what’s best for the country not what’s best for "their" party.

You think there's a mess in the Middle East now :?: :?: Wave the white flag as some propose and then see what a mess we'll have.

I've had the honor to send 2 son's and 1 son in law, all 3 Marines to serve their country in that God for saken place, they would surely serve again if called and so would I.

Why is doing what's right so hard :?: :?: :?:

We've become spoiled, we watch a war from one side and one side only. Then we ask why has this taken so long :?: We sit here in our air conditioned easy chairs (made in China) drinking mint julips or sipping our cheap wine and think we have it so bad. How long did it take us to see the light about Nazi Germany :?: :?:

What we're up against isn't just Iraq and leaving Iraq will not solve the problem. We should prepare ourselves for something much bigger :!: :!:

Sorry for my rant...not :!:
8)

Donny:

ditto.gif
:!: As you already know, I feel as strongly as you do. Between my twin brother and I we have 36 years of combined service to Canada, and with our baby brother included there is over 45 years of service.. one generation. My family, both the French Canadian side and the German side have provided sons to stand in defence of the homeland for many, many generations.

They must stay the course. To abandon all of what has been accomplished and the good that has been done is not only stoopid, it is the rantings of a lunatic, and that fringe group seems to get a lot of airtime. Those who are more levelheaded don't seem to get heard much. To abandon the present course, whether it was right or wrongly instigated, is to cast a pall over the current loses and those to come which there will be many yet.

Yup, as was said above.. 3,000 soldiers lost is a hard pill to swallow and one's heart aches for the families.. but does anyone remember Dieppe? that was a small battle, over 3,000 Cdn soldiers died on that day in WW2. No one questioned the necessity. Even the media, although they were aghast at the losses, did not act as the modern media does and try to shape public opinion based on a skewed presentation.

That is just one battle. How many have our countries lost in 2 major world wars, the Korean War, Vietnam, the Belgian Congo, Mogadishu, Sierra Leone, Panama, Granada, Gulf War 1 and succeeding peace keeping missions, and countless other Peacekeeping and PeaceMaking missions around the world.

Politicians are politicians and by definition are essentially useless, selfserving, self agrandizing dolts who run the nations by poll numbers and what is cool at the moment. Politicians in the modern terminology do not have the stomach for what is euphemistically labelled bad polling numbers. These are the ones who not only send em off to war, but are the first to pull the rug out from under our troops.

We as citizens must also realize that the only reason we can sit back comfortably in our easy chairs and watch vicariously the events unfolding in Iraq and Afghanistan and then pronounce our considered judgements upon things many of us know nothing about first hand, is because and ONLY BECAUSE of the men and women in our Armed Forces who voluntarily risk their lives to allow us that privilege.

I for one believe that we must wholeheartedly, without reservation or judgement support our troops and NEVER, EVER make light or risk turning their ultimate sacrifice into something meaningless.

Winnie had it right, So did FDR and even Harry Truman.. So did McKenzie King... we must perservere at all costs, to do less is to dishonour those who have fought for our safety.

Animated%20US%20Flag.gif
Support%20Our%20Troops%20a.jpg
Animated%20Cdn%20Flag.gif
supportourtroopscdn.gif
 
Years ago, my mother made the comment that members of her family had fought for the US in every war from the revolution through Viet Nam. I never went back to verify that comment but imagine I could. With the current political aversion to declaring war, it is getting harder to know what is a war and what isn't, but I know that I have had family members in every war since Viet Nam as well. So don't go claiming any moral superiority by participation.

The Bushies got us into this war over claims of WMDs, not by claims of terrorist involvement by Iraq. The whole terrorist excust was used AFTER THE FACT to try to justify it when the WMD story came up empty.

To date, every time anybody other than the Bushie inner circle has made any comments or even suggestions concerning conduct of the war, they have come up with some dire prediction of what would happen if that suggestion was followed. For 4 years all of those suggestions have been ignored and the dire prediction has eventually come true anyway.

Examples:
- Terrorists would enter the country from neighboring countries.
- Various religious factions in the country would start attacking each other.
- The coalition government would be weakened if factions withdraw their support.

Now they claim that setting and time table (even a rather modest goal of starting some reductions in six months) will cause us to loose the war. Based on past performance, they will still loose it (if they haven't already) but do it on their own non-schedule.

If you want to draw comparisons with WWII, how about this one. We have been in Iran for over 4 years. WWII was done within 3 1/2 years from when we entered.

After 4 years, April was one of the highest for US and UK fatalities since the start. The Bushies have gotten over 3,600 troops killed already. I hardly think the best way to honor that sacrifice is to get another 1,000 killed.
 
Couple of comments and opinions.

1) The war in Iraq is just a small part of a world wide war against/being conducted by Muslim terrorists.

2) The solution is not to conduct a politically correct war. We don't phone the criminals telling them that the police are going to serve the warrant and kick in the door. As Jim states the war in Europe lasted 3 1/2 years. By current politically correct standards we could not have bombed Dresen, Darmstadt and Berlin into a pile of rubble.

3) WMB. They were in Iraq. There is some residual evidence such as the saran bomb found along one of the Iraqi highways. Where the WMD went? Several Iraqi Air Force generals have provided information that 70 civilian aircraft were stripped of their interior and the evidence shipped to another country.

4) My opinion. Leaving Iraq will not solve the problem. The solution will have to come from the more moderate Muslims. There is evidence that the more moderate Muslims are getting tired of the radicals activities. Such as the tribal leaders in western Pakistan fighting and killing outside radicals infiltrating the area.

Eugene
 
Jim:

Years ago, my mother made the comment that members of her family had fought for the US in every war from the revolution through Viet Nam. I never went back to verify that comment but imagine I could. With the current political aversion to declaring war, it is getting harder to know what is a war and what isn't, but I know that I have had family members in every war since Viet Nam as well. So don't go claiming any moral superiority by participation.

Now this is just my opinion and is worth exactly zip! But:

No one is claiming moral superiority :!: How one arrives at that conclusion escapes me.. but then again, a lot does. I can tell you as a former serviceman and currently a Veteran.. I get real cranky when people who haven't a clue about combat or military service, turn around and pull the rug out from the very troops THEY put into harms way by their Political Decisions. And to clarify, that is generally the politicians.

I am reminded of a statement by a Member of the House of Commons during a debate on The Standing Committee on National Defence and Veterans Affairs. Seeing as this is in the Public Domain, please feel free to read this testimony. SCONDVA - Transcript - Thursday, May 7, 1998 The first is by the now widow of a good man and a good friend who served and died because of the first Gulf War. If Bush Sr had stayed the course, those who are dying now, would still be alive.. At approximately time stamp 1830 hrs, it is yours truly.

At approximately time stamp 1840 hrs:

Again, I would like to quote remarks made by a member of this committee on Tuesday, March 10, 1998, in Ottawa, Ontario, while Lieutenant-General Kinsman was presenting his brief:

I guess I'm a little bit uncomfortable trying to define the responsibilities of the government to the military, because we'd be telling them what we think our obligation is to them. We already define what their obligation is to us, and that's to act as defenders of our country at the risk of the loss of their life. Now we are to define what we owe them in return for that potential sacrifice.

Those were the words of Mr. Bob Wood.

I can tell you what every citizen of every free country owes their servicemen and women, and that is the guts and the courage to stand behind their servicepeople and provide a strong and unaterable and unfailing willingness to give them what they need to win... not cut them off at the knees as is so common in many conflicts in recent memory. Vietnam, Congo, Belise, Somalia, Gulf War series 1 are a few that come to mind. In war, even those at home must have a strong will and desire to win. If not, then all will be for nothing, and in the current circumstance, the media will be proved right... if we cut and run. The Rebels will win because we do not have the moral fibre to stay the course until the job is finished.

Winning IS Job #! There is no other choice.

Then when these brave people come home in bits, pieces and just shadows of their former selves, we -- yes those armchair quarterbacks OWE those wonderfully brave souls decent medical care, all the tools they need to re-integrate back into society, and to provide them with the recompense that they so justly deserve, instead of nickle and diming our veterans to death. Ask me.. Please.. Ask me.. BTDT.. and in this case YES, I claim a bit of moral difference. BTDT..

In the words of one of the most respected world statesmen ever:

Do not ask what your country can do for you, but, What can YOU do For Your Country? JFK

It is the soldier, not the reporter, who has given us freedom of the press.
It is the soldier, not the poet, who has given us freedom of speech.
It is the soldier, not the campus organizer, who has given us freedom to demonstrate.
It is the soldier, not the lawyer, who has given us the right to a fair trial.
It is the soldier who salutes the flag, who serves under the flag, and whose coffin is draped by the flag, who allows the protester to burn the flag.

* * *
by: Charles Province

And for those who think maybe censorship is the way to go.. ponder this line...

It is the soldier, not the poet, who has given us freedom of speech.

I guess that is all I have to say on the subject. Thread is closed as far as I am concerned.
 
Rudi":i78rmqsf said:
No one is claiming moral superiority :!: How one arrives at that conclusion escapes me.. but then again, a lot does. I can tell you as a former serviceman and currently a Veteran.. I get real cranky when people who haven't a clue about combat or military service, turn around and pull the rug out from the very troops THEY put into harms way by their Political Decisions. And to clarify, that is generally the politicians.
Well maybe I am misinterpreting it. But it seems like every time there is a thread on anything political or war related, some individuals kick off with their veteran status, as if it has either some relevance to their point or lends some credence to their position. For example, the very first thing you said in this thread was:
As you already know, I feel as strongly as you do. Between my twin brother and I we have 36 years of combined service to Canada, and with our baby brother included there is over 45 years of service
I have not said anything (until just now) about my status as a former serviceman and current veteran because it isn't relevant to day's problem. By today's problem, I am refering to the Iraq war which was largely engineered by Dick Cheney, who is NOT a veteran but has split most of his career between politics and Halliburton, where his buddys are making buckets full of money with their no-bid contracts in Iraq. The whole thing just stinks.
 
I am not a veteran, nor are a great deal of my family. I have always been a staunch conservative and have always supported the "right-side" of the equation.

I originally supported the Iraq war completely, but that was because I felt strongly with the current administration that there was an imminent threat from that part of the world and Iraq specifically. Now, with hindsight being 20-20, I am sorry that we ever went in there.

We didn't like the atrocities that Saddam brought upon his own people, and we thought in our good-natured "American" way that we should topple him because he was a threat...oh and by the way...we will make all the people of Iraq FREE in the process. Well, I know that this is an unpopular opinion, but the way of ruling in that part of the world is completely different than in this part of the world, and I think that the COUNTRY of Iraq may have actually been better off with Saddam in power. There were NO uprisings in that country, and when there were, they were SQUASHED immediately by the strong dictator. Now, with Saddam being dead and long gone to the worms in the ground, look at all of the uprisings and power-clamoring in that country...everyone looking to fill the vacuum of power that was taken away when Saddam was ousted. Where can it end? Is it possible to end it?? I don't know!

My only other feeling on this subject is that now that we have started and gotten into this mess, we CANNOT just leave. We CANNOT. That is NOT good stewardship and is NOT fair to the people in Iraq.

Yes, I am upset with Bush and his people because we went there under false pretenses. Yes, I am upset that I now have to DEFEND the fact that I am a Republican because of what is going on. Yes, I am upset that my president from my party has singlehandedly changed many peoples opinion AWAY from what I feel is the correct way of thinking about economics and world politics simply by leading us where we should NEVER have gone in the first place.

NO, I don't think that we must now establish a timeline to exit Iraq...that would be foolhardy in my opinion and just give comfort to our enemy.

Yes, I am still firmly on the right-wing side of the equation on 99.999% of the issues...but I am NOT a warmonger...I want peace.

What we need to do is ACTUALLY COMMIT to winning this thing and making it right...if that is at all possible.

I do support our troops...they had NO choice in this battle... They can only do as they are told or be court-marshalled. They pay the price for our freedom, and I could NEVER do the job they are doing...I am too much of a wimp. I would just love to support them back at HOME rather than in an ill-conceived war...

I will don my flame-retardant pants now...

Mike in La Crosse, WI
 
I'm not a veteran either. I'm very proud of those who are. I was never asked to serve my county in any conflict, but I really do pay attention to the political scene and am very concerned with the present situation, with all the nonsense bias from the national media. They've diminished the thinking ability of the average citizen.

The most important question to ask, and I ask myself, is "what if?" What if we had ignored all the attacks on American citizens on 9-11, as the previous administration had in 1993? What if Jimmie Carter had served another term? What if algore had been in charge? What if John Kerry had been in charge (he served in Viet Nam, if you didn't know)? That if, for cryin out loud, someone like Pelosi, Ried, Schumer, or Hillary and others were in charge? How would we ever fix their mess? What if the Socialist ambulance chaser Edwards with the nice hair is taken seriously?

Those guys seem to think the route to go is a combination of Socialism and surrender to the followers of Mohammed.

Of course nothing goes just as we might have wished but this constant bickering merely to gain political advantage by the new leftists in charge will certainly be our downfall if we don't wake up. :( :evil: :( :shock:

Actions do indeed have consequences.
 
Jim Becker wrote
The Bushies got us into this war over claims of WMDs, not by claims of terrorist involvement by Iraq. The whole terrorist excust was used AFTER THE FACT to try to justify it when the WMD story came up empty.

First of all, I'm not a Bushie, I'm an American and I really resent that remark :!: :!: :!:

Maybe it's CRS, or just a convenient lose of memory but it's is also true that the Clinton administration and the US Congress felt the same way. Even President Clinton, while Monica was on her knees bombed a terrorist camp in Iraq. I wonder what that was doing there :?:
My memory is not too good but I remember many Democrats including the “anointed” one, talking about how Sadam was in possession of chemical WMD's and was aggressively pursuing nuclear weapons. It's seems to be a “convenient” truth that whoever is in power gets blamed for whatever is going on at the time.
The war in Iraq will not be won by the Bush administration since that would be a success for the Republicans. The Democrats will not allow it.

I have never spoken here of my military service nor do I clam a high moral ground because of it. It’s a personal thing that I share with only a few. I also have several tattoos of which not many people have seen. These things are my business, no one else’s :!:

Here’s the difference between this war and Vietnam, in my opinion. When I say “this war” it’s not just Iraq. In my opinion the real problem is Iran and has been, since the Shaw was overthrown.


1. Vietnam never calmed the US to be the great Satan.
2. Vietnam never clamed total destruction of the US and Israel.
3. Vietnam, if they had proclaimed those things did not have the means to carry them out.
4. Vietnam didn’t fly planes into the World Trade Center.
5. The Democrats got the US into the Vietnam War.
6. Democrats used to be conservative compared to today’s Democrats. President Johnson changed all that.

If we succeed in Iraq this will give us leverage against Iran. This to me is the most important thing we as a country could be doing. This is the Crusades’ in reverse, when will we wake up? When it’s too late, I’m sure :cry: :cry: :cry:
 
Mr. GW,

You and I agree on mostly everything including this issue. We need to get the job done that we started...not run. The only thing that I "kind-of" disagree with you about is the media. Yes, I agree that they are biased, but no less biased than they were when they were putting together the news reels in the 40's and showing only the gallant actions of our lads in uniform and not the other side like when we missed with a bomb or something like that. The news people print or show what they think will bring in ratings to their show...unfortunately.

Mr. Becker, I hope that you don't think any less of me because we don't share the same political views except the fact that we are now in an ill-conceived war.

Sheesh, I am sure glad that we all share a common love for this little Cub tractor... (especially my Merlincub! :lol: )

Mike in La Crosse, WI
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top