Jim:
Years ago, my mother made the comment that members of her family had fought for the US in every war from the revolution through Viet Nam. I never went back to verify that comment but imagine I could. With the current political aversion to declaring war, it is getting harder to know what is a war and what isn't, but I know that I have had family members in every war since Viet Nam as well. So don't go claiming any moral superiority by participation.
Now this is just my opinion and is worth exactly zip! But:
No one is claiming moral superiority :!: How one arrives at that conclusion escapes me.. but then again, a lot does. I can tell you as a former serviceman and currently a Veteran.. I get real cranky when people who haven't a clue about combat or military service, turn around and pull the rug out from the very troops THEY put into harms way by their Political Decisions. And to clarify, that is generally the politicians.
I am reminded of a statement by a Member of the House of Commons during a debate on
The Standing Committee on National Defence and Veterans Affairs. Seeing as this is in the Public Domain, please feel free to read this testimony.
SCONDVA - Transcript - Thursday, May 7, 1998 The first is by the now widow of a good man and a good friend who served and died because of the first Gulf War. If Bush Sr had stayed the course, those who are dying now, would still be alive.. At approximately time stamp 1830 hrs, it is yours truly.
At approximately time stamp 1840 hrs:
Again, I would like to quote remarks made by a member of this committee on Tuesday, March 10, 1998, in Ottawa, Ontario, while Lieutenant-General Kinsman was presenting his brief:
I guess I'm a little bit uncomfortable trying to define the responsibilities of the government to the military, because we'd be telling them what we think our obligation is to them. We already define what their obligation is to us, and that's to act as defenders of our country at the risk of the loss of their life. Now we are to define what we owe them in return for that potential sacrifice.
Those were the words of Mr. Bob Wood.
I can tell you what every citizen of every free country owes their servicemen and women, and that is the guts and the courage to stand behind their servicepeople and provide a strong and unaterable and unfailing willingness to give them what they need to win... not cut them off at the knees as is so common in many conflicts in recent memory. Vietnam, Congo, Belise, Somalia, Gulf War series 1 are a few that come to mind. In war, even those at home must have a strong will and desire to win. If not, then all will be for nothing, and in the current circumstance, the media will be proved right... if we cut and run. The Rebels will win because we do not have the moral fibre to stay the course until the job is finished.
Winning IS Job #! There is no other choice.
Then when these brave people come home in bits, pieces and just shadows of their former selves, we -- yes those armchair quarterbacks OWE those wonderfully brave souls decent medical care, all the tools they need to re-integrate back into society, and to provide them with the recompense that they so justly deserve, instead of nickle and diming our veterans to death. Ask me.. Please.. Ask me.. BTDT.. and in this case YES, I claim a bit of moral difference. BTDT..
In the words of one of the most respected world statesmen ever:
Do not ask what your country can do for you, but, What can YOU do For Your Country? JFK
It is the soldier, not the reporter, who has given us freedom of the press.
It is the soldier, not the poet, who has given us freedom of speech.
It is the soldier, not the campus organizer, who has given us freedom to demonstrate.
It is the soldier, not the lawyer, who has given us the right to a fair trial.
It is the soldier who salutes the flag, who serves under the flag, and whose coffin is draped by the flag, who allows the protester to burn the flag.
* * *
by: Charles Province
And for those who think maybe censorship is the way to go.. ponder this line...
It is the soldier, not the poet, who has given us freedom of speech.
I guess that is all I have to say on the subject. Thread is closed as far as I am concerned.