T-8

DanR

501 Club
I've been doing a lot of reading about T-8 and T-12. There seems to be agreement that converting a fixture from T-12 to T-8 is possible but no one will actually say how to do it. Has anyone here have actual experience doing this conversion?
 
For the one who might not know, the lamp designations T-12 and T-8 mean Tubular (T) and the number is the diameter in eights of an inch. So T-8 is a tube 1" diameter.
In some instances, simply installing a T-8 tube in T-12 fixture might work after a fashion for a limited time. But it will not work well. The ballast and the tube must be matched. In almost all cases, the same lamp holder will work for both tubes.
Often a new complete fixture is lower cost than buying just a ballast. But changing out the existing fixture might be quite tedious, so swapping ballasts might be the better approach.
The T-8 has lower light output than does the T-12. But the T-8 produces more light per watt of power input and thus is more efficient. A given area might require more T-8 lamps for a given lumen level than would be required if using T-12.
So to retrofit to T-8, a new T-8 ballast and new tubes are required. Be sure to follow the wiring diagram on the new ballast. It might be different from the T-12.
 
Brent. you weren't the only one -- first thought popped to mind was the gas version T-8 instead of the TD7/8 that I am accustomed to. Then I realized that they were actually talking fluorescents .. My new pole barn currently has 4 double T-8 fixtures (soon to be 6) and there are 6 T-8 fixtures and 4 T-12 fixtures in my cabinet shop. I much prefer the T-8 fixtures.
 
I put T-8's in my shop about 5-6 years ago. The ballasts are starting to go on them. A new fixture from the big box store is about $25, while the new ballast is $19. Last time, I did one of each to see if the new ballasts are superior to the ones that came in the fixture (China vs. Mexico). The new ballasts come with a wiring diagram. I wasn't aware that the pins for a T-8 and T-12 had the same spacing.

Bob
 
I Have eight T-12 eight foot fixtures in the shop. They are take downs from old school buildings, purchased for $1 each. Also have a stack of extra tubes. Already changed one ballast, spare (used). Should have picked more ballast from fixtures I did not want. Don't know when everything will be NLA. T-8 fixtures are probably alot cheaper to run, but these were very cheap going in. BTW the outfit I worked for in 2006 swapped 4' T-12's forT-8's when remodeling their C-stores.
wonder how that worked out. They were a cheap outfit, LOL.
 
T8's are cheaper to operate but working life is much shorter for both tubes and ballasts. This may be enough to offset the cheaper operating expenses. It will be a moot point soon as T12's will eventually disappear.
 
The T-8 has lower light output than does the T-12. But the T-8 produces more light per watt of power input and thus is more efficient. A given area might require more T-8 lamps for a given lumen level than would be required if using T-12.


Bus Driver
Cub Pro

This is the more correct version, remember the watt hour meter reads watt usage so a 40 watt bulb uses the same amount of energy, weather a T-8 or a T-12. What we have is an issue of efficency. So as Bus Driver stated you may have a more efficient bulb but may have to use more energy to illuminate the same area of coverage. We have over a quarter million lights we maintain here at this facility and we have noticed also that with some of the new bulbs out of china they are about a hair to long to fit in to some of the fixtures. we've actually seen them break while trying to be forced into a fixture.I guess there was a problem in converting our inch system to metrics. In the old days it seemed that ballast would last for ever, being prone to read in to conspiracies , I wonder if the manufactures decided they were not making enough money? :shock:
 
DanR":24kmuxs6 said:
So, I guess that the ballast must be changed. Right?
Yep! Unless a new fixture is cheaper. In our case, we had to retrofit over 1,000 fixtures but it was cheaper to replace the ballast than the fixture.
 
Time to eat a little crow, On further discussion with my energy manager, the fact that there is a slight reduction in energy usage at the actual ballast , came to light. The bulb and the ballast have too be looked at separately as far as consumption......So there is a savings in changing out to the T-8 ballast. weather or not it is negated by the amount of fixtures needed to illuminate the same area would still be open to scrutiny. :shock:
 
Dan, I had a few ballasts going out in my shop, so I thought the easiest thing was to just change out the old style ballasts to the newer electronic ballasts, then install T-8's as the pins are the same.

Went and got a couple of ballasts and bulbs at the local Home Depot, but I ended up returning them before I opened them up as a Menards flyer was in the paper that day and they had a sale for new fixtures with bulbs, and I was able to get a whole new fixture cheaper than swapping everything else. Of course, these fxitures are the 2'X4' fixtures for drop ceiling.

Took less time for me to disconnect the wiring and swap out the fixtures than it would have taken to change the bulbs & ballasts.
 
Mine are surface mount. Easier to clip 4 wires and loosen one or two screws, add 4 wirenuts than hang and rewire new fixture That may change when NLA. Some times I change wires at clips to make it look original, but alot of time and aggravation.
 
I went to Lowe's to check out the T-8 ballasts. They were $20 something. Checked out the T-8 lamps and the cheapest was about $6 each. They had a close out on 10 packs of T-12 lamps for $11. Looks like the T-12's are here to stay a while. I have 9 fixtures now. New ones were $14 at Lowe's and $10 at Ace Hardware. Go figger'.
 
I thought that my previous post covered the subject for home and shop purposes but subsequent questions and comments show that not to be the case. A T8 lamp produces more light (lumens) per watt of input power than does a T12. The end result is that to achieve a certain specified lighting level, using a T8 system achieves that level using fewer watts of power. But it typically requires more T8 fixtures and lamps than is required for the same lighting level with T12. Converting a specific number of existing T12 fixtures to T8 will reduce both the light output and the wattage usage, with wattage dropping more than does the light output. As far as I know, all T8 ballasts are electronic, as are all the presently manufactured T12 ballasts. The ballast uses power and the tubes use power. The older magnetic ballasts, still in use by the millions, use more power than do the electronic ballasts. To compare overall luminous efficiency (lm/W), a T12 with magnetic ballast is about 60% compared to a T8 electronic which may be 80-100%. A T12 with electronic ballast would be more than 60% but less than 80%.
 
Single pin flourescents are "series" ballasts. The bi-pin (two pin) tubes are not series. Ballasts are not interchangeable for the two types.
 
It's been mentioned that T-12 items will be discontinued, does anyone know how soon that is likely to happen? I have quite a few T-12 fixtures, mostly 2X4 but also several 1X4 and a couple 2X8's. If they're going to disappear soon, I better stock up on tubes. I replaced most of mine about a month ago, as they were getting dim, so I'm in decent shape for a couple years, but having a couple cases of tubes on hand might be a good idea.
 
Back
Top