Heating With Wood

Rudi

501 Club
The Buying a New Chainsaw by BigBill thread, is what has prompted this post. It originally was going to be just a reply, but as usual, I went off on a tangent, and this is what resulted. I do hope this helps some..

Much of this comes from many generations of family both on my side and Emilie's side. We have pretty much always heated with wood except for my Mom and Dad, who became somewhat citified and heated with Natural Gas. Grandpa and Grandma always heated with wood. So, this post consolidates experience I have gained from heating homes with wood from Northern Ontario to New Brunswick in some of the coldest parts of the continent. Yes, there was wood heat even in Inuvik but not in Alert...

So here goes nothing:

For those of us lucky enough to own a wood lot, heating our homes is not very costly at all. They are forecasting a return to yesteryear here with a very cold, and they say frigid winter with temps averaging -40C which is about -40F. That is the average. I usually stock 9 cords of mixed soft and hardwood from fir, spruce, pine through poplar, wire birch, white birch, golden birch, various species of maple and some beech when we can lay our hands on it. I will also burn much of my slash from willow to alder and other bushy stuff if the stock is large enough. I normally go through 4 to 5 cords per winter heating 36,000 cubic feet of house. Yes really... ask anyone who has seen my basement. You can play basket ball almost there the bottom of the beam is 10 foot neet and the joists are 2x12... so 11 foot of basement.

It costs me around $100.00 or so per year, that figures in the fuel, chains etc., for the saw, gas for the saw table and gas for Ellie or Granny or both. Probably would include the electricity for the blowers as well. So yes.. heating with wood is very economical and contrary to some of these so-called militant environmentalists who say any CO2 in the atmoshere must be penalized with a Carbon Tax. They fail to realize that trees need CO2 to breathe and produce the O2 waste gas that WE need to breathe.... :big give up:

Even here, wood is getting to be around $185.00/per cord round or $200.00+ split. That is for hardwood only. So having your own wood lot or access to a wood lot that you can maintain and utilize the thinnings is a great savings.

Here is another point. Burning mono-species or mon-types is BAD for a chimney. It doesn't allow for hot or normal fires but usually just allows medium or very slow fires. Hotter fires are used to ensure that there is no creosote buildup in the flue. Too many idling fires actually contributes to a huge chimney/flue fire because of semi warm temps that continue to cool as they rise up the chimney and then deposit creosote in clumps at various heights in the chimney. This is a catastrophe waiting to happen. Don't ask why I know this :( :roll: :(

Because of this and the amount of chimney fires we experienced the first oh 12 years or so that we had the house, I have learned that:
  • A Sentinel, GSW 2000 or other 2000 degree double walled stainless steel chimney is probably the safest chimney for new construction or even a retro-fit
  • Any of these double walled chimneys that are external, must be covered with a chimney surround to equalize the inner flue temperatures to prevent creosote buildup
  • A hot fire in the morning (fueled by softwood or poplar) plus moderate fires during the day with mixed woods and a nice overnight fire with hardwood, will go a long way to decreasing the risk of chimney fires from creosote buildup
  • Regular cleaning either by self or from a qualified and licensed chimney sweeping company is a must
  • Burning a mix of firewood is also a must
  • Whatever you choose to burn, ensure that it has properly seasoned.
  • Whichever method of heating you choose, be it furnace based forced air, radiant heat, pellet/wood stoves or fireplaces, always install and operate according to local state/provincial, municipal and fire marshall regulations.

  • Cut and let air dry one full season in 4 foot lengths. Minimum 3 months. Ideally cutting should be done between January and March.
  • Cut to stove, furnace, fireplace length (say 16") beginning of June and July - here is where your Cub comes in -- get a Brookfield Cub Sawyer saw or similar or even an old saw table such as the one I have, (pics to follow) . Power the saw with your Cub. Not only will you get a lot of enjoyment, it is also more economical than say an 8 or 10 hp B&S as a Cub will run twice as long on the same amount of gas as the B&S or Tecumseh. Yup.. I know that based on my years of cutting wood using the B&S. Cut safely.. do not take your mind off of the job at hand.
  • Split as required and then let dry at least one month.
  • Then stack your firewood indoors. (we have a basement wood room that is 12x14x10 foot. This allows 8 foot piles. We can easily stack 8 rows 12 foot long which makes 8 cords. The last 2 rows are 8 foot long which allows about 1.6 cords. We also have a kindling bin that is 4x4x8 foot high or 1 cord of kindling. So we actually have 10 cords. I can increase this to 12 or 13 if absolutley necessary by going another foot higher on the piles.
  • If you have no indoor storage, pile your firewood on used shipping pallets, cover the firewood to keep off the snow and rain. You can do this by utilizing tarps, snowmobile shipping container sides (they are covered in Tyvek/TyPar - housewwrap), or even those nice portable car garages -- just anchor them well.

Oh a couple of other tips.
  • If you have never used a chainsaw. Learn from the dealer. They will teach you how to properly use one and to care for it as well.
  • Always use safety pants -- these usually have some kind of chainmail (made from composites now) to prevent you accidentally cutting your leg off or burning a hole in your leg from the muffler. Again NO YOU CANNOT ASK! :oops:
  • When working alone, keep you mind on what you are doing. You can get hurt real fast if you do not pay attention.
  • Just have a lot of fun. Providing your own heat if you can is a very satisfying excercise. When done correctly it is not a long term job, each section only takes a few hours or a couple of days depending on your needs and schedule. This year we cut and split over 20 cords of wood.. about 14 for me and 8 or so for my Father-in-law in 3 days. We hauled most of it in and stacked it inside and outside in less than 1.5 days. Still have a bit left to do. The longest part is cutting the standing timber in the woodlot.
  • Oh, almost forgot.. if you are near a mill, some mills will sell you slabbing and mill ends very cheap. By the cord or by the bucket as in loader bucket. This is also a good way to get wood for heating.

Wheeww.. am I done :?: :?:
 
Rudi,

As I was growing up wood is the only source of heat we had. My mother also cooked on a wood cook stove until after I left home.
The house I now live in was built by my grandfather. He used wood until he passed away and mother and dad bought the house. They used wood until mother passed away and for some reason the insurance co. that dad had, canceled his insurance because he used wood. He finally found an insurance co. that would insure him. When he passed away Betty and I bought the house from my brother and sister. When I started shopping for insurance all the companies (Allstate, State Farm, Farm Berau, and many more) told me if I was going to use wood they would not insure us. No one could give me a good reason or at least to my satisfaction, because the house is brick and has a great fire place and flue but I still had to put in a new heating system.

I know what you are talking about using wood it sure is a savings especially when you have a lot of woods with many trees that are either down or damaged and needs to be removed. :x :x

Jim
 
Jim:

It is the same up here.. For some reason insurance companies love to cause headaches. They made my father-in-law remove and replace a perfectly good oil tank (it had been indoors all of it's life and was much thicker steel than the one that replaced it), cost him almost 1500.00 by the time it was all said and done. They did the same for the camp and they did the same for my old house. Made me take the wood stove out, even though it passed fire marshall saftety regs. I guess a lot of the insurance agents/employees are too young to remember wood stoves.

However, when I built my new one, I bought a Kerr Scotty II made by Parsboro Industries up here. It is CSA/UL approved and designed to work in conjunction with oil and electric furnaces side by side sharing the same plenums. The intake air is fed into the oil/electric and the outlet or forced air is from the wood furnace. They went ballistic when I plumbed in a Propane unit side by side. It took separate chimneys and other mods to keep em happy. Then, they went snaky when I removed the propane and went to electric. :big give up:

I just quote the National Building Code, the Provincial Fire Marshall's Guidelines, and the manufacturer's CSA/UL approval documents and then they gotta reevaluate.. usually when presented with the documentation even the most illogical and stubborn get with the program.

And I can tell you along with my favourite memories of Grandma cooking on the old McLary Easy Wood Stove.. I still can picture and smell it all, I can smell and taste the fresh home made bread that we used to toast over the open flame. Along with those memories are the memories of frozen laundry hanging on the outside clothes line in minus 30 and 40 F temps, hauling in the days firewood into the porch to thaw before burning and of course the mad dash in the middle of the night to the outhouse.. when the chamber pot just would not do :!:

I guess you can say,, yeah.. if your older than 50 you might remember this :idea: :wink: :!: :{_}: :{_}:
 
Rudi, although we use propane, a lot of folks here in the Ozarks heat with wood. I cut down a tree (red oak) behind the barn the other day, cut it into 16" lengths and stacked it by the road. Then I called the neighbor to come pick it up. I helped him load the last of it this morning. It will help him make it through the winter.
 
Rudi,

What do you think about the outside wood furnaces that heat circulating fluid that then routes into an existing lp gas furnace/plenum or floor radiators?

I am thinking about getting one, just so I can burn the several cords of wood my little place in the woods (7 acres) will produce each year. The place is covered with poplar, sweetgum and oak...mostly poplar.

Sounds like you've got a world of experience on this front...and as a city boy who has escaped to the woods, I need to get up to speed. Spent about three hours today dragging logs and cutting them into splitter size...and I'm pooped! This will get me into shape fast...or kill me I guess! :D

Thanks for additional feedback,

Corky
 
Corky:

You are not going to like this reply. Nope, not at all.

The mill next door has one of those outdoor furnaces that is supposed to preheat parts of the Hog Fuel Barn to keep the fuel from freezing or something. All I know is it makes one hell of a smell... the chimney is too short, it burns a lot of wood... and doesn't heat so hot from what I have been told by the guys who load it up.

faq_measure_table&diagram.gif


Courtesy of Central Boiler.com FAQ's

Also, I have heard from others that it just isn't efficient method of heating or an economical way to utilize wood. The one saving grace is that you load it up in the morning and again at night.

Personally, a good forced air or even passive system depending on how much floor space you have is sufficient. If this is going to be for your home, I would recommend that you look at something like:

It is currently available on Craigslist.. Wood Furnace-KERR "SCOTTY" DB102 - $400 (Concord)

011501011614010306200808072ac01b4c2a3c20448e00d9af.jpg
0104080116110103012008080763e14f260e853e76ab009a98.jpg
0115090116020104032008080758d8bebdcc7ede7053005669.jpg


It also happens to be the identical one to the unit that I heat my house with. Remember a good GSW2000 or Sentinel should be more than sufficient for code.

Now to be more specific. My father-in-law converted his Scotsman which is a 140,000 BTU unit into both a forced air and a circulating fluid system. This has worked well for him.

I am assuming that you have a basement? If not, then a forced air system can still be added but will be a tad bit more difficult.

Does this help in any way???
 
Rudi,

Thanks for the additional info. Unfortunately, I don't have much basement space for more equipment inside...the basement is finished with bedrooms, office space and a big playroom..(what can I say? I'm still a kid at heart!). And the house has no chimney! (I know, sounds pretty dumb, but I didn't build the house.)

I do have a slab driveway just outside the basement that is pretty well protected from winds, and might make a good location for an outside unit. There would have to be a pretty long outside flue to reach above the roofline, and I don't know how that affects the idea.

But I have some serious motivation...LP around here cost me about $7000 last year! So I'll keep looking at ideas, and am open to other suggestions.

Thanks again for the input, it's late and I'm hitting the sack.

Take care,

Corky
 
Be careful with the wood stoves , there are several house in my area that have burnt complete right to the ground from when things go wrong burning wood.
 
Jackman,

Yes, I have thought about that too...and think that's another vote in favor of an outside unit.....

Thanks,

Corky
 
It is a shame people have become so paranoid. When I was a child it was common to burn out the creosote by setting the chimney on fire on a snowy day when the roof was covered.
I am accumulating wood and have a neighbor with a bandsaw mill. My Cub and his slab pile have a date.
ukn_Cub_saw.jpg
 
Well, what can I say. There are homes that burn completely to the ground heated by electricity, propane, natural gas, pellets and other forms of heating. It isn't the heating plant that burns down houses. It is the owners - the people who burn down houses. Mostly because they either do not know (and do not read the owner's manuals), just do not bother or don't care about routine maintenance, safe burning practices or anything else.

There is also a huge difference between a wood burning stove and a wood burning furnace. Big difference. Wood stoves be they traditional or pellet or even sawdust stoves are safe provided the operation is carried out properly.

It is like a car falling apart due to no oil changes and poor to non-existent maintenance. Is it the car that is at fault or is it the human being that owns the car???

Yes, my granddad's house also burned to the ground. About 20 years after he sold it. It was on it's fourth owner and the idjit did not know how to burn wood properly.

The solution would have been for him to go to his local heating supply dealer and have them teach him the proper way to heat with wood. The cause of the fire was large creosote buildups in the flue. The solution..... ahhh duhhh.... cleaning the flue.

I have two favourite comments about computers I use that applies to just about any operation with any type of equipment.

"The computer is only as smart as the Human Interface operating it" and the second comes from my Farmallcub.com friends "you can't fix stupid".

Corky:

Thr unit you are contemplating would probably suffice, but be advised.. it is a huge waste of wood. They are not efficient. However with that said, they do what they are designed to do.

I am not sure how cold it gets where you are... average winter temps would be a big help... but

But a thought occured to me last night when I read your last post. Got busy with other stuff and didn't get around to posting. If you were to acquire something like the DB101 Scotty II... and you built an insulated and properly shielded enclosure, you could do with the scotty exactly what the outdoor unit does.. but in an enclosure that would probably look better and be much more economical. That way you could heat with what you needed to heat with. Plus, you could add another extension etc., to store wood. I will try to add my pics tonight at some point if I can.

Hope this helps.. however if you could let me know what the average winter temps are and the size of the pad you already have.. I am sure that we can design something that would be suitable for your situation.
 
Mike:

:applause: :big smile:

I agree wholeheartedly.

Virginia Mike":1wpzkwg7 said:
It is a shame people have become so paranoid. When I was a child it was common to burn out the creosote by setting the chimney on fire on a snowy day when the roof was covered.
I am accumulating wood and have a neighbor with a bandsaw mill. My Cub and his slab pile have a date.
ukn_Cub_saw.jpg
 
Thanks for the comments Mike...that's a cool looking saw!

I'm not sure I'm being paranoid, as much as just thinking through before I do anything. Ready, aim, fire sort of thing (excuse the bad pun) :D

Rudi,

Down here in sunny Georgia, we usually have fairly mild winters, with no more than a few days of snow or ice. Average winter lows in the high 20's, with dips into the teens occasionally, and to single digits once or twice in a decade. The lions share of our LP consumption comes from our furnace, a gas water heater, and my mother-in-law's cottage, which she likes to keep warm enough to cook a turkey in the winter (just kidding).

I'm also thinking about an on-demand water heater. As for the slab outside the basement, its got room for an 12-foot by 18-foot enclosure...big enough for both an auxiliary furnace, and maybe even a separate wood room.

Not sure whether the cost for all the above will justify itself given the relatively small amount of wood that comes from my place each year...but still thinking.

Corky
 
Mike,

When you talked about burning out the fireplace, it reminded me of what my Mother told about her Dad. He did the same thing before it got cold enough for a fire on a regular basis. If the house had wood shingles, he would send one of the kids up on the roof and the others would send water up to wet down the shingles before firing the fireplace. He would build a big fire of pineknots and dry oak to clean the fireplace and chimney out. She said he never had any damage done to the house. On a side note. If the chimney started leaning away from the house, Grandpa would send a kid under the house and dig a hole under the hearth area and keep water poured in the hole, wetting the ground. Eventualy, the chimney would start to return to an upright position.

Billy
 
Corky, several people in this area have the outdoor furnaces that circulate water to heat house and domestic hot water. Most people like them, but they do have 2 shortcomings, one is they take twice as much wood as other types of heat, and 2 when they first call for heat, the cloud of smoke is thick enough to create traffic problems if it happens to drift towards a road. Many communities are putting restrictions on them due to smoke. A second thing to think aobut is that all of them I have seen use water in the lines, not an antifreeze mix, and must be fired anytime weather is cold to prevent freeze ups.

What about a unit that sets only a few feet from house and has large ducts to blow heated air into house? If it is ducted into basement it will warm floors of house and drastically cut down on heating bills.
 
John,

After the feedback here and from talking with Ron Luebke, (who has a forced-air wood-burner), that's the direction I'm heading. I can get close enough to pump the hot air into the furnace, and circulate it that way.

I've enjoyed all the conversation. Brought back memories of my father-in-law prepping his fireplace each year. The first fire he'd build, would be the biggest of the year, with about 12 logs in a 6-log fireplace. Every year, I expected him to dig out his old anvil and start 'smithing! He'd get it so hot the log grate would sometimes get past red-hot, and one year when the fire was done, the grate was flat as a pancake on the floor of the firebox!

But look up into the flue...and no creosote buildup, no squirrels, no nothing!

Corky
 
Corky:

John *.?-!.* cub owner":200dizg7 said:
What about a unit that sets only a few feet from house and has large ducts to blow heated air into house? If it is ducted into basement it will warm floors of house and drastically cut down on heating bills.

What John said is what I was trying to say in the

Rudi":200dizg7 said:
But a thought occured to me last night when I read your last post. Got busy with other stuff and didn't get around to posting. If you were to acquire something like the DB101 Scotty II... and you built an insulated and properly shielded enclosure, you could do with the scotty exactly what the outdoor unit does.. but in an enclosure that would probably look better and be much more economical. That way you could heat with what you needed to heat with. Plus, you could add another extension etc., to store wood.

This would probably be ideal. If you could get a used unit such as the one above for $400.00, and it was close it would be economical. However, a good wood furnace that is plumbed for radiant hot water/or radiant fluid -- that will not freeze, is not all that dear. I would hazard a guess that a new one could be got for say about $1,500.00, add in another $500.00 for the chimney.. as it only need clear the peak of the house by 3 feet.. another $1,500.00 for the exterior addition and you would be set to go. Even at say at 4 cords of wood per year (a good well managed woodlot will produce a minimum of 1 cord of firewood per year just harvesting the thinnings and dead stuff without touching the trees that you want to mature into saleable logs) there would be a saving of anywhere from $800.00 to $1,200.00 per year. This would then make a 5 - 10 year payback very likely and provide a good environmentally positive solution. Plus it would save you a lot in LP. Also yes, the on-demand hot water would be an excellent choice. The savings there would probably make the payback in about 2 or 3 years. I am thinking of doing that when this tank needs replacing. Since there will only be Em and I on a fulltime basis, it makes sense.

Sure hope some of this has been helpful...

Keep us posted on what and how you do it.
 
Billy Fussell":29bl9fh5 said:
Mike,

When you talked about burning out the fireplace, it reminded me of what my Mother told about her Dad. He did the same thing before it got cold enough for a fire on a regular basis. If the house had wood shingles, he would send one of the kids up on the roof and the others would send water up to wet down the shingles before firing the fireplace. He would build a big fire of pineknots and dry oak to clean the fireplace and chimney out. She said he never had any damage done to the house. On a side note. If the chimney started leaning away from the house, Grandpa would send a kid under the house and dig a hole under the hearth area and keep water poured in the hole, wetting the ground. Eventualy, the chimney would start to return to an upright position.

Billy
Wow! Great story; kids nowadays have it too easy. :D
 
You guys are lucky with all of those set ups. We just have a wood burning stove at my house.... still cut wood with our log splitter and chain saw
:)
amanda
 
TractorChick":1yc12vhz said:
You guys are lucky with all of those set ups. We just have a wood burning stove at my house.... still cut wood with our log splitter and chain saw
:)
amanda

Amanda, same with me. And I admire the setup those guys have. That being said, the wood burning stove sure puts a dent in the amount of LP Gas I have to use. I usually let the central AC system warm the house when we crawl outta bed, but once the wood stove gets going, the central system is pretty much done for the day.

Roy
 
Back
Top