As most probably know, I am not a huge fan of fossil or electric heat. I like wood heat, but I also realize that it just is not a viable option for most people. So I think I am pretty fortunate and I don't have to worry about cost increases. I know others do, so I do try to pay attention and keep reasonably current on available systems. I used to have Propane as my backup system, now I have electric forced air as a backup, but we never use it. I have friends who have gone from heat to propane, to natural gas and wish they had never converted. I have neighbours who have electric and wish they never converted. Em's aunt and uncle have a heat pump which they like and they also have a HRVS system as part of their overall heating solution. Been hearing the pro's and con's for years. Without getting into specifics etc., I think that when it comes to efficient and financially viable options, I gotta agree with George, the only really viable electric system would be a heat pump or a HRVS setup.
RH rates are not a given or something that won't change, so if you make a decison to go to electric, don't make it based on rh rate differences cause that is not a guarantee. We have here in NB historically low Residential Heating rates.. first 900Kw are at about $0.08/kwh and after the first 900 it goes down to around $0.05/kwh. However, that appears to be a previous system. They just announced that NB Power would realign its Residential Heating rate to reflect other jurisdications similar to ours in the NE US and across Canada. Apparently it RH is now going to be an across the board $0.09/kwh with no reductions based on usage, so that will probably mean even higher utility bills for our electric heat neighbours.
Yup, I really like wood heat :!:
I really have no idea what to say to you about your dilemma, but I think a lot of research into year over year averages for your area over say a 10 or 20 year period would be useful to see what historically is actually viable for your area.