DANGIT...
Yesterday, my wife called me distraught. Seems the City Forestry Department (isn't that an oxymoron?) came by to "prune" our Norway Maple Tree in front of our house (on the "boulevard" between the sidewalk and the street...city property). There were several dead branches on the tree that were dead because the City cut a large root to the tree when it heaved a section of sidewalk in front of our house 3 years ago. The city required that the section be replaced, and when they replaced it, they cut the root...leaving a whole section of tree to starve to death over the next year or two.
They didn't stop at the dead branch, though. They continued to butcher the tree such that it no longer provides shade to my front porch and master bedroom in the house. The tree now looks like a giant piece of broccoli...one long stem with a bunch of branches only at the top. The shape of the Norway Maple is ruined!
I called to lodge a complaint with the Forestry Department and got this reply:
To me... this shows his incompetence and apathy. As the forester, he should, in my opinion be concerned with saving as many trees as possible in order to beautify the city and not with cutting them down. At this point, what is done is done, and nothing can be done about it. What once was something to beautify my property and provide shade for my house now is more of an eyesore than it was before. Further, in the "historical" district (aka High rent district), they don't just disfigure trees...they take care to shape them and make them look presentable when they are done... I think that this bugs me more than anything.
Thanks for listening to my rant... living out of town sounds better and better every day...
Mike in La Crosse, WI (AKA no-tree-ville)
Yesterday, my wife called me distraught. Seems the City Forestry Department (isn't that an oxymoron?) came by to "prune" our Norway Maple Tree in front of our house (on the "boulevard" between the sidewalk and the street...city property). There were several dead branches on the tree that were dead because the City cut a large root to the tree when it heaved a section of sidewalk in front of our house 3 years ago. The city required that the section be replaced, and when they replaced it, they cut the root...leaving a whole section of tree to starve to death over the next year or two.
They didn't stop at the dead branch, though. They continued to butcher the tree such that it no longer provides shade to my front porch and master bedroom in the house. The tree now looks like a giant piece of broccoli...one long stem with a bunch of branches only at the top. The shape of the Norway Maple is ruined!
I called to lodge a complaint with the Forestry Department and got this reply:
City Forester of La Crosse said:I do agree with you about the disfiguration of the tree. Some of the trees we pruned along Jackson St are disfigured but we are pruning following the conditions the tree presents us. Removal is the other option instead of disfiguring the tree. In this case we are trying to limp the tree along for a few more years.
I received a call on Tuesday August 26 from your house on this and talked to a lady about the pruning practice. I stand behind our pruning along Jackson St. The maple trees along Jackson St, according to my research we planted in late 60â€s early 70’s and many of the trees were lost over the years due to the harsh condition of the growing site. There is a lot of deadwood in the trees and a couple of them are to the point where they will be removed; 615 Jackson St and 1304 Jackson St. It would be way too expensive for forestry to prune a tree every year. We are lucky to get to a tree every 6 years.
To me... this shows his incompetence and apathy. As the forester, he should, in my opinion be concerned with saving as many trees as possible in order to beautify the city and not with cutting them down. At this point, what is done is done, and nothing can be done about it. What once was something to beautify my property and provide shade for my house now is more of an eyesore than it was before. Further, in the "historical" district (aka High rent district), they don't just disfigure trees...they take care to shape them and make them look presentable when they are done... I think that this bugs me more than anything.
Thanks for listening to my rant... living out of town sounds better and better every day...
Mike in La Crosse, WI (AKA no-tree-ville)