City Tree Hack

Hengy

501 Club
DANGIT...

Yesterday, my wife called me distraught. Seems the City Forestry Department (isn't that an oxymoron?) came by to "prune" our Norway Maple Tree in front of our house (on the "boulevard" between the sidewalk and the street...city property). There were several dead branches on the tree that were dead because the City cut a large root to the tree when it heaved a section of sidewalk in front of our house 3 years ago. The city required that the section be replaced, and when they replaced it, they cut the root...leaving a whole section of tree to starve to death over the next year or two.

They didn't stop at the dead branch, though. They continued to butcher the tree such that it no longer provides shade to my front porch and master bedroom in the house. The tree now looks like a giant piece of broccoli...one long stem with a bunch of branches only at the top. The shape of the Norway Maple is ruined!

I called to lodge a complaint with the Forestry Department and got this reply:

City Forester of La Crosse said:
I do agree with you about the disfiguration of the tree. Some of the trees we pruned along Jackson St are disfigured but we are pruning following the conditions the tree presents us. Removal is the other option instead of disfiguring the tree. In this case we are trying to limp the tree along for a few more years.

I received a call on Tuesday August 26 from your house on this and talked to a lady about the pruning practice. I stand behind our pruning along Jackson St. The maple trees along Jackson St, according to my research we planted in late 60”s early 70’s and many of the trees were lost over the years due to the harsh condition of the growing site. There is a lot of deadwood in the trees and a couple of them are to the point where they will be removed; 615 Jackson St and 1304 Jackson St. It would be way too expensive for forestry to prune a tree every year. We are lucky to get to a tree every 6 years.

To me... this shows his incompetence and apathy. As the forester, he should, in my opinion be concerned with saving as many trees as possible in order to beautify the city and not with cutting them down. At this point, what is done is done, and nothing can be done about it. What once was something to beautify my property and provide shade for my house now is more of an eyesore than it was before. Further, in the "historical" district (aka High rent district), they don't just disfigure trees...they take care to shape them and make them look presentable when they are done... I think that this bugs me more than anything.

Thanks for listening to my rant... living out of town sounds better and better every day...

Mike in La Crosse, WI (AKA no-tree-ville)
 
Mike,
We want pictures! :twisted: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Peter

I have a row of white pines along one edge of our property that fall within a conservation easement. We cannot do anything with them according to the rules of the easement. Several years ago I got tired of looking at all the dead branches running up the trunks and decided to clean up. Boy did that raise a ruckus. I asked the offended parties how much time they spent looking at the dead branches on a daily basis compared to what we spent looking at the eyesore. That solved the problem. Now the problem is that these trees are about 20 feet taller than what they were when we moved in. Our garden doesn't get sun until about 10:00am. When the power company came through a few years back to trim the branches away from the power lines my wife gladly gave them permission to trim the trees right down to the ground. Word of that comment got to the same previously offended parties and stuff hit the fan again. I asked them who was going to take care of cleaning up the trees when they flop over during a heavy wet snow due to their lopsidedness and they said we were responsible because they are on our property. :?
 
I will post some when I get home tonight... The files on my blackberry are too large to post without resizing them...

Mike in La Crosse, WI
 
Mike.

Check on line at your state forestry service. They should have photos, pamphlets and an explaination of how to trim trees.

If you still feel that you have a complaint, document everything including the communications with the City Forestry Department and file the complaint with the city council.

If you live in a historic district - you may want go get them involved.
 
Mike,

I understand your frustration. I have had to deal with homeowners who were trying to save trees that were dangerous to them and others because limbs, big limbs, were not healthy and were going to fall, on something or somebody.

A little tree biology may help:

Where do the roots grow? Probably 95+% of the roots grow in the top 4" to 6" of the soil. When a tree blows over and takes the root mass with it, it looks like a pancake setting on edge and, for the most part is 6" thick. Why? Because the roots are there.

How much area does a tree need to grow well? Normally a minimum of 900 square feet up to 1200 square feet, in a circular pattern around the tree. Hmmmmm. What shape is the tree boulevard? Rectangular, boardered on four sides by concrete (most often) at least 4" thick and more often thicker and less than 900 square feet per tree. Where do the roots want to grow? In that same 4". Roots that do grow under concrete will heave the concrete up and result in someone replacing concrete as happened in your case.

The bottom line is that no one is happy. The tree, the homeowner, and the city forester are all less than pleased. Trees are placed in situations where, long-term, they can not thrive. When is the last time you saw an unhappy tree just pick up its roots and hustle down the street looking for a better place to put down its roots?

I once advised a farmer to cut down the trees lining his lane. They were long past their prime and were in serious decline and showing it. Could they have been pruned? Yes. Would it have been effective in stopping the decline? No. They were dangerous and he understood and cut them down. Did he like cutting them down? No. To this day, he is one of my best friends and we each arrange to see each other when we happen to be traveling near.

Mike, just go out and work on Merlin. No one is lying on the floor bleeding to death. :) :)

Bill
 
Mike,

To add a little to what Bill has to say...

Norway maples are one of the worst trees to select for a street tree. They are very susceptible to disease and have an extremely shallow root system, many times protruding above the surface of the ground in the best of growing conditions. In other words, the stage was set for your frustration the day they were planted. Enjoy what's left of the tree for as long as it lasts, and replace it with a more suitable variety when the time comes (if you still live there). The City has done the best that they can with a bad situation. Feel lucky that you didn't have to replace the sidewalk. In most jurisdictions, you would have.

Don (Registered Landscape Architect) McCombs :D
 
Mike, I can sympathize with you. We went through the same thing years ago. Regardless of the reason or logic, you hate to see any tree butchered. When we moved to the Ozarks, we even had our electric utility put in underground so we wouldn't have to worry about our beautiful trees getting trimmed. Then along came the ice storm of 2009. Sometimes you can't win for loosing. :cry:
 
Sorry to hear that Mike, we just talked about how nice that tree was when I was just at your place last weekend.
My neighbor has a Norway Maple and it was pruned back a lotalso by our city 2 years ago. They recover FAST though
Doesn't even look like it was pruned now.
 
The best thng to do is "think" when planting trees.The guy who built this house put in some nice oaks.he also put in some junk maples.All the junk maples have been cut down now.I wish he would have got nice ones instead.[Hard maples]They would still be up.It is hard to have old trees in the city.The out grow their area,then are $$$$ to cut down.Sorry to hear,I love old trees in the city too!! Kevin :shock: :shock:
 
MIKE Norway maples are relatively short lived trees. Don gave you the right scoop on them. If the tree is healthy it will be back in a couple of years. If not replace it with something suitable for street planting. Sidewalk trees take a beating and with the street salt in the winter undergo torture.
 
Mike,

Not a tree problem but another example of our local government at work. My inconsiderate neighbor has five dogs, all healers, that bark and howl as a pack all night and run at will. My neighbor and I have talked to her several times to no avail. I filed a formal barking dog complaint with Animal Control and followed all the instructions on their web site. I was supposed to receive a notice from them within a week as to what actions were taken. Didn't hear anything from them, so after three weeks I called. I explained to the representative that I had filed a complaint following the instructions on their web site but have not received a responce from them as to what actions were taken. His answer was "we don't do everything it says on our web site". When I questioned him about what was going to happen he said "it will take awhile" It was like talking to a log. I couldn't get a straight answer out of him. I got so Pi_ _ed off I wrote a letter to my county supervisor. Within a couple of days the director of Animal Control called me assuring me that the problem would be resolved within the week and it was. Neighbor wound up paying license fees for all five dogs, had to bring shots up to date and chip all five and if she kept more than three dogs, had to get a kennel license. If she had just done something when we asked she would saved about $500.
 
Brent":bmex2tbg said:
Mike,

Not a tree problem but another example of our local government at work. My inconsiderate neighbor has five dogs, all healers, that bark and howl as a pack all night and run at will. My neighbor and I have talked to her several times to no avail. I filed a formal barking dog complaint with Animal Control and followed all the instructions on their web site. I was supposed to receive a notice from them within a week as to what actions were taken. Didn't hear anything from them, so after three weeks I called. I explained to the representative that I had filed a complaint following the instructions on their web site but have not received a response from them as to what actions were taken. His answer was "we don't do everything it says on our web site". When I questioned him about what was going to happen he said "it will take awhile" It was like talking to a log. I couldn't get a straight answer out of him. I got so Pi_ _ed off I wrote a letter to my county supervisor. Within a couple of days the director of Animal Control called me assuring me that the problem would be resolved within the week and it was. Neighbor wound up paying license fees for all five dogs, had to bring shots up to date and chip all five and if she kept more than three dogs, had to get a kennel license. If she had just done something when we asked she would saved about $500.

But have the dogs STOP BARKING or did she just move them into her house
 
Mike,

She keeps them in the garage at night and most of the day. They still bark but we're far enough away so I can't hear them unless I'm close. I can imagine what the garage and probably the house smells like. Hate to put it this way but she's pretty much a slob. Had to talk to her about her garbage blowing over into my place and I'm on two and a half acres.The dogs would get into it and carry it all over the place. Instead of getting trash service $20.00 a month, she was saving it for a month or so then loading it in her horse trailer and taking it to the dump. Minimum fee at the dump is $28.00. I told her to do the math. With her, wherever anything lands or is droped that's where it stays. It's dry here in so. cal in the summer so we all have to weed wack in late spring. She has crap lying all over the place, top to a dog carrier, dog matress, etc. Instead of picking the stuff up she weed wacked around it. It's still there. Now her boy friend took the engine out of his boat about two months ago and it's been hanging from a limb in the tree in front of her house. My wife says she thinks it's their idea of a wind chime. What's spooky is she's an emergency room nurse at our local hospital. Hope I never have to go there. Bet your sorry you asked!
 
Well, I may find out today. The water company has been installing a new line down the road all summer. They should be at my property today. I have two rows of Leland Cypress that I put in 3 years ago. There is about 12 feet between the trees and the county maintained drainage ditch. Plenty of room for a backhoe if they will do it. Trish talked to the crew about 2 weeks ago and they said they would go around the trees. I suppose they can say the trees are in an easement and wipe them out. That would not be good for us or them. I know Trish is serious about the shotgun. Lets hope everyone can work this one out.
 
Back
Top