Whoa Nelly!

Harold R

501 Club
I find this video suprising in as much as there is plenty of technolgy available at the pilots finger tips to know the field conditions prior to landing. The aircraft has limitations. Why you would want to test new ones with paying passengers aboard is beyond me. "There are old pilots, and Bold pilots........but no old bold pilots." :?

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=ddb_1204404185
 
No matter how great the technology, it's still an airplane, subject to the whims of nature. That was a tough crosswind landing, and the pilot did the right thing by "going around" (aborting the landing).
 
It's an advanced aircraft. The pilot would have known the weather conditions prior to the approach. It made no sense to me to put passengers and crew in jeopardy. They were within inches of being front page news. :(
 
Pucker Factor on that one would have been what an 18 on a scale of 1 - 10 :big say what:

Close... glad I wasn't on that bird :big shy:
 
I saw that else where earlier. He was really crabbing coming in I thought. There are times to abort and times for an alternate airport.
 
He looked good at the beginning of his approach. His crab looked under control. I have landed a Cessna 172 like that. He hit another major unexpected gust near touching down. Looks like the left wing just scraped the ground, another foot or two and the wing might have ripped off.

The pilot did a good job. I would like to hear what he has to say :roll:
 
I'd rather hear what his boss said........or the German version of the FAA. Because I know what my boss would have said. :twisted: :twisted: :twisted:
 
Wrong runway. It was his choice to accept it. The mystery is why he went so deep into the situation before deciding to abort??? :roll:
 
When I was in the Military I seen veteran pilots do the same thing. Age and experience can still be overcome by confidence. I have climbed out my Phrog several times and kissed the ground, even went back and picked up the tools and tool box that fell out of the back hatch.
 
Those weren't really trees in the background. It was the ocean. And that was Maverick doing a touch and go because he missed his trip wire! I feel the need, the need for speed! 8)
 
I had an extremely familiar experience once, flying into Philidelphia from Bridgeport, CT, on a Beechcraft 1000 back in 1995. We were coming in for a landing, in a huge thunderstorm. I was on the port side of the aircraft, about mid way back just over the wing, and could see the runway lights directly out the side window. I assumed originally that we were circling the airport to come in on another runway. As I continued to watch the runway marker lights, I realized that he was crabbing, and we were actually landing on the runway that was outside my window. I continued to watch, and he brought the plane in perfectly, nose pointed into the wind until the last few feet above the runway, then pulled the nose around straight and landed perfectly.

It was quite an experience :shock:
 
Most aircraft pictures are taken with a pretty long lens. Since distance is severely compressed, it makes any of these situations look a lot worse than they really are. Something to keep in mind when viewing these videos.
 
Jim Becker":4ctvweqr said:
Most aircraft pictures are taken with a pretty long lens. Since distance is severely compressed, it makes any of these situations look a lot worse than they really are. Something to keep in mind when viewing these videos.

That's true, but his transition from a crab to a slip indicated he was in over his head. I wouldn't want to be aboard an aircraft with this same pilot as pilot in command. We've seen videos of what a good pilot can do with an aircraft with severe damage. We'll have to assume this one was in good condition except for weather.
 
The aircraft sustained damage............which creates a paper trail........which a blame needs to be laid. The crew might try the "whim of nature", or "looked worse because of telephoto lens", excuse......but I doubt it will work. I can't speak to how things work in Germany...........but here........that's a rug dance for sure.
 
A few pilots at work here tonight were saying that they thought nothing was done wrong there and after a short hold the pilot made a nice landing on the same runway same heading. They were saying the crab on final wasn't any big deal but he got caught in a wind gust at touchdown that wasn't his fault.
 
More to the story......2 runways were in use that day. Rwy 23, and rwy 33. Rwy 23 has a ILS, or precision approach......rwy 33 has a non-precision app. (ILS is an easier app.) Reported winds were 300 degrees at 35kts with gust to 55kts. The ceiling 1600ft. and visiblity better than 5 miles. Prior to the Lufthansa fiasco, KLM declined a departure clearance on 23 due to limitation exceedance. Emirates attempted a landing on 23 but rejected the landing at about 1000 ft......then opted for rwy 33. On short final for 33......the landing was still in question, so they bugged out and went to Frankfurt. Next was the Lufthansa arrival on rwy 23.....which was filmed. THEN...they opted for rwy 33......not rwy 23.
I can't speak for Lufthansa's operation, but when we figure cross winds...we figure the gust as steady state for safety margins. (I really doubt any commercial carrier doesn't). Therefore, they were faced with a 55kt crosswind......and at a 70 degree angle....I'd have to guess without a whiz wheel in front of me, but probably about 40 to 45 kt direct crosswind. The limitation for the A 320 is around 33 or 35 kts.( About the same for the B737).
I'm relatively certain the PIC will have to explain his decision making that led up to damaging the aircraft.

These British Airways passengers first inkling of a windy day was when they were standing curbside waiting on a taxi. LOL Smooth x-wind landing........but then again it was a Boeing.

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=766_1196775900
 
Back
Top