Water heating element question

Pony Master

501 Club
Okay, I have a fairly new electric water heater (2 years or so). In the last month it is making me wonder about it. It has good hot water, but it does not last real long. It is a 40 gallon heater, but if one person takes a warm shower, the next gets a rather quick and rude surprise not to far into their shower. It never used to be like that. I have heard of being able to check the elements before, but my old water heaters have always started leaking and had to be thrown out, so no need to test elements. How would I go about testing them? Yes I have a nice voltmeter, and I understand electricity. I have just never done this before and do not want to fry my voltmeter (seen that happen, it sucks)
 
Chad,

I would think that removing power from the elements, and then testing both for continuity (quick and dirty to see if element burned through), followed by resistance, would be the way to diagnose this. There is at least some chance that one of the two elements (typical of electric heaters) is fried.

Perhaps the schematic or owner's manual gives the resistance level expected of each coil.
 
Chad - cut the power to the unit, remove the leads from the heating element and using an ohmmeter check for continuity through each element and also check from the element to ground. A defective thermostat is almost as likely as a bad element.
 
Also if you have hard water trouble in your area try turning off the power and drain water heater thru lower drain. Hot water heaters act like a big sediment trap. Ive seen them quarter full of sediments no room left for water capacity hense short showers.
 
Search the web for "water heater element". Several sites with photos and explaination on testing elements. Also several sites provide suggested prices for replacements.

Elements are not expensive. You just need to obtain the correct replacement(s). Any well stocked hardware store should have the correct replacements on the shelf.

Since you are getting some hot water - guessing one element is faulty - probably the lower element. I would replace both elements.

You will need the correct wrench to replace the elements.
 
Sounds to me as if the top element is defective. This one makes hot water while you are using it. The old heat rises trick. I had a top go bad a number of years ago and that is how it acted. The drain out the sediment thing is a good thing too.
 
At one time Bradford White water heaters had a recall on dip tubes . The dip tube broke off so the cold water would mix with the hot water then lowering the overall temperature of the water . This caused a short supply of hot water. Just a thought .


Russ
 
You may have a bad element, but it could also be a bad thermostat or even a loose wire on one of the thermostats or wiring. Proper operation of a water heater, the top element comes on and warms the water in the top of the tank to give you hot water quick. Once the water in top of heater is hot the thermostat shuts off top element and applies power to the lower thermostat and element. when the water in bottom gets hot that one also shuts off and the heater waits for you to use enough water to cool the temp and the cycle begins again. The 5 year warranty is normally on the tank only, not the elements and thermostats
 
Also check and see if your cold water fill pipe is plastic. If so, it may be that the pipe broke off inside the tank near the top. You can replace the pipe without removing the broken peice from the tank. Let us know what you found. John is right about the warranty. Grump
 
If your water is like mine Chad, my bottom filament will burn out in about 12-18 months, if that. Then i will have to replace it, if i want a large supply of hot water. Over the years i have gotten tired of dealing with it. So i just let it go. I would leave the top filament alone, as the replacement filaments in teh stores are not as good as orginal. I have purchased orginal equipment filaments as well, paid 4 times the cost of the cheap in store filament, and they didnt last any longer. I used teh cheap replacement (store ones) to replace the top one, and had less hot water. I will be getting a new hot water heater from lowes next month, it has stainless elements, lifetime guantee. I will also be putting an in-line self cleaning filter systerm, to cut down on the sediment. When you do replace that bottome sediment, use your big sockets, 1 1/4 i think, and dig as much of the sediment out you can. what you cant, shove away from where the new element goes in. and be sure to use plumb tape.
 
My first guess is that the bottom element is not heating. The second guess is that the dip tube has failed. Little else could cause the described problem. John has it right. The elements are interlocked so that both cannot be ON at the same time. The usual 30 amp supply is not sufficient to power both at the same time. When cold, the top THERMOSTAT supplies power to the top ELEMENT and shuts off the power supply to the bottom THERMOSTAT. The top element heats about 1/3 of the water in the tank, giving a small supply of heated water quickly. When the top thermostat is satisfied, it switches OFF the top element and switches on the power to the bottom thermostat. The bottom thermostat switches on and off as necessary supplying power to the bottom element to maintain the set temperature in the tank. If the tank is cold at the top and the top element is not heating, the heater will not heat at all since no power will get to the bottom thermostat.
Suppose the tank is fully heated and both thermostats are satisfied. Someone draws out 5 gallons of hot water. The bottom thermostat is chilled and switches on the bottom element which brings the temperature back up to the thermostat setting, then switches off. With many water usage patterns, it is possible that the top element might operate only when the heater is started from cold.
 
Most likely the bottom element. My tank was less than 1 year old when the story you describe happened to me. I took the element out and it was shot. Completely destroyed. Being a contractor, I could deal with a plumbing supply house to order the oem replacement. Guess what? In one year the element had mysteriously changed from copper to stainless steel. Even the design was completely different. Without naming names, the brand starts with an A.
 
Back
Top