I have used TurboTax for years. In the early years, the IRS required use of IRS forms. You had to manually copy the TurboTax output onto the proper forms. Now it is almost impossible to get the IRS to even send you the forms. They expect you to print them on your PC, or even (gasp!) file electronically!
After using TurboTax for many years (at least back to 1990), I thought I would try one of the other packages to see if I was missing anything by using the same one year after year. So I tried TaxCut (I think in 2002). I never had so much trouble doing my taxes. Horribly buggy software. I nearly chucked it and started over with TurboTax. At the time, they had a package deal with TaxCut and another package that would have been useful. The other package NEVER DID RUN on my computer. I heard from others that had the same experience with both packages. I hope the H&R Block offices use better software than they sell. I switched back to TurboTax the next year and I'll never use H&R's again.
I've been using TurboTax Basic for several years. I don't need a state package and haven't found a need for the bells and whistles of the Deluxe etc. versions. Depending on your specific situation, the fancier versins may be worthwhile.