Tuneup cost!!!

Hengy

501 Club
WOW... I just about choked today when I got the the estimate for a tune up on my wife's Dodge Grand Caravan. I just about choked when she called me today with the estimated cost for the repair!!! To replace the spark plugs, fuel filter and change the oil, the cost was going to be $370.00 plus tax!! :shock: :shock: :big what:

I know that changing the plugs on the van means the back three plugs in the bank are a PITA to get to, and I know that the fuel filter is in the gas tank, but that repair is just a little abusive in cost to my way of thinking. Needless to say, we brought the van home without having a tune-up.

Mike in La Crosse, WI
 
The fuel filter replacement alone would be about $110 to $130 parts and labor. At $65 an hour it ads up quick. Depending on plugs used it is a crap shoot. My Tahoe plugs cost me about $80 and that was not including labor (supposed to be high milage plugs). After figuring it all up your mechanic was probably in the ball park. None of it is cheap anymore when you pay some one to do it.
 
Mike:

We had one of our local Dodge Chrysler dealers do a tuneup on our 2000 Grand Caravan about 2 years ago. We had already had a tune up at 150,000km and then again at around 250,000 kms. Each time it cost us about $400.00. Plugs, fuel filter, air filter were supposedly changed. We have gotten oil changes every 5,000kms since we bought it back in 2002 when it only had 70,000 on it. It now has 320,000kms on it plus. So I guess we have put 250,000 ourselves in the 7 years that we have owned it. That makes about 50 oil changes at $29.95 each or $1,497.50Cdn. Really it doesn't owe us a penny, but I can tell you my dealer sure does. When Em had problems on the road a couple months ago, we ended up having to do the top end - heads -- one of em was cracked. This meant we had to shell out some major coin that wasn't in the plan nor the budget. What really got us was what we found when doing the work.

Boy were we ever upset when my mechanic (we went to Troy after our extended warranty ended two years ago) showed us what hadn't been done during the previous 2 tuneups and as well as the timing chain and water pump we apparently paid for three years ago. Seems that we still were running the original plugs, rotor, caps and plug wires that were installed in the factory. We had been charged for 2 complete tune-ups which actually were not done. We were charged for a timing belt and a water pump which never had been changed. Still factory. Needless to say we were and still are very unhappy with our dealer and we will never ever darken his doorstep again, nor will anyone in our family... so it is his loss. But what I am impressed with is how well the original products performed and lasted.

You really should get the work done. The filter is accessible from the hoist.. and the back plugs are not difficult when the van is on the hoist either. Where the expense comes in is because they use a Flat Rate for this work. Whatever the book says is what you pay, even if they can do the work in half the time. And a good mechanic can change those plugs/rotor/cap/wires and the fuel/air filters in about 40 minutes. I watched Carl do it..... so I know it can be done. Do yourself the favour and get it done, cause it will pay for itself in fuel costs that you will save. We were having a fair amount of problems with the engine light coming on and we had a rather hefty corresponding loss in mileage to boot. Once we actually got new plugs/wires/rotor/cap and filters... we are getting far better mileage and the associated savings in fuel costs.

Oh, it only cost me $200.00 to get this stuff replaced compared to the $400.00 at the dealer.....
 
I've got an F-350 dually with a V-10. I've never replaced plugs yet but a friend of mine has. He said the plugs are $16.00 each!! :roll: Do the math on that!! And that doesn't include labor, that's just the price of the plugs. :big crying:

I'd shop around a bit. I've had repairs done to my wifes car and the prices really vary quite a lot. Kind of depends on who wants the work and who doesn't.
 
Seeing how I'm a ex ford partsman,there are good dealers and bad.Reason why I work on stuff myself most of the time.I have always worked for good dealers.I know people that don't.It is a fine line on some of the techs.Once again,I know some great ones and bad ones.Sometimes the service dept does not know what the techs really did.But they should back their work.Rudi,I hope you told the dealer why.They can go back and check to see who did the work.Most ofthe guys help me at their "home shops"if its something that I don't have tools for.Been real lucky to have a good bunch of guys here that I know.Dealers lose a lot of real good customers cause somebody cutting corners!!! :shock: :shock: Kevin
 
Kevin:

Too many issues with the dealer. Although he is a chum sort of.. he is a real slippery one. Makes the classic used car salesman look prim and proper. Won't deal with him again. The tune up was just one in a long line of problems that have never been resolved satisfactorily. They are one of the lesser quality dealers.. on a scale of 1 to 10.. about a -2 or so. Great guy to have a brew with but don't do business with :(

I will go to the other dealer in town if I ever buy a Chrysler again. At this point we are not happy at all with the new Grand Caravan or the Town & Country. Although ours has been a real good vehicle, the new 2010 we had for two days did not make us happy campers at all. Em has more bruises from the sills and the door frames than we can shake a stick at. Getting into the rear passenger seats is a royal PITA and they are about as comfortable as an orange crate. Those Stow-n-Go seats are nice.. but not to sit on. For the price they want, I think we will be looking at the other majors.. Either GM or Ford. As much as I don't much like it.. we found the F-150's nice trucks.. my brother-in-l;aw has a Lariat super cab 4x4 -- heated/AC leather seats, everything but the GPS.. Gord has a nice F-150 - very comfortable. They are just hard on gas. I also liked Cecil's Chevy Silverado 2500. Nice truck :!: :D So we will be looking at the other brands.

If I win the Lotto 649.. well Mercedes will be the obvious choice :lol: :roll: :wink: :!:
 
Today's tune-up's are a far cry from yesterdays for sure!

I checked with the Ford dealer I use (which is the cheapest, and they do differ!) and was told the tune-up only, for my '06 F-150 was over $425.... IF they didn't break any plugs. I had never heard this before, IF they didn't break something! :?: An old family friend in NE runs a repair shop in a small town and said he wouldn't do my F-150 because they were "a real pain" and aparently breaking plugs is a fairly common thing. I went to the CarX I use (more than fair prices vs. dealer, dealer parts and good guarantees) and the plugs were over $65 EACH! He discounted it some and I was still around $300, and no broken plugs. I later searched the net and found some, and recommended replacements, for significantly less, under $20 I think. But with the potential of breaking some I left it for the experts!

So, don't think they are far off for paying someone for their efforts.

Good luck,
 
2003 Chevy Suburban - tune-up (plugs, wires, computer software upgrade), fluid flush and change with thermostat, hoses, new brakes all around, including new emergency brakes (4 wheel disc, so parking brake on driveshaft), and I was out just under $2000. But the car hasn't run that well in a long time, 135,000 and looking to pass 250,000 before we replace it. so halfway through a $30,000 vehicle's life, we paid two more to keep it running tip top. It hurt, but it won't ever be any cheaper again. Your tune-up doesn't sound out of line to me. I don't think you could get anything done by a legit mechanic for less than $100, most shops are at $85 per hour now.
 
dgrapes59":1r3q9xvd said:
Today's tune-up's are a far cry from yesterdays for sure!

I checked with the Ford dealer I use (which is the cheapest, and they do differ!) and was told the tune-up only, for my '06 F-150 was over $425.... IF they didn't break any plugs. I had never heard this before,
The 5.4 engine had some problems with plus seizing and breaking off. May have been some others also. Due to the length of time before plugs are changed, it was a while before the problem surfaced, and it has supposedly been solved in about 04 or 05. Solution consists of a special anti seize on the threads and a slight change in the holes.
 
Yes the 5.4L and the 6.8L are bad on taking out the threads when you pull the plugs.Exhaust manifolds break all the time also.It is a no win problem with any vechile anymore.The ol'days just are not in the automotive field anymore.Thisis part of the problem the country is having[just a small part].Kevin
 
I've been going across the street and helping a mechanic friend of mine. I can't believe some of the engineering many of the newer cars have. He gets vehicles in all the time where you must pull the intake to even see the plugs and wires. Land Rover v-8's you have to pull the intake to replace the coils, mounted on the backside under the intake. The biggest thing that gets me is the replacement parts quality. There's a big difference in Auto Zone type store quality and Advance Auto quality. Now when you get a mechanic that charges their double markup based on better parts prices and buys Autozone type cheap parts, they make a killing. One thing my eyes have been opened up to, the bigger the business, the more overhead, they have to charge alot to pay the bills(building/workers/tools/insurance/electric/accountants/etc, it all adds up. Do the job yourself, you'll see why things cost so much, cars today are a royal pain to work on.

Rick
 
John *.?-!.* cub owner":15yhg9rc said:
dgrapes59":15yhg9rc said:
Today's tune-up's are a far cry from yesterdays for sure!

I checked with the Ford dealer I use (which is the cheapest, and they do differ!) and was told the tune-up only, for my '06 F-150 was over $425.... IF they didn't break any plugs. I had never heard this before,
The 5.4 engine had some problems with plus seizing and breaking off. May have been some others also. Due to the length of time before plugs are changed, it was a while before the problem surfaced, and it has supposedly been solved in about 04 or 05. Solution consists of a special anti seize on the threads and a slight change in the holes.

They must still be afraid of it.. Or didn't change their rates, mine is a '06. :D

In my mind, I also attributed it partly to the length of time between tune-ups, 100K! (... and I went over)

Side note… my last vehicle (Ford Sport Trac) also piled on the miles, and I had this idea I would get it tuned up (plugs replaced) earlier than recommended as an old time mechanic recommended not taking to the high miles they now allow. Well, it ran worse… found out the plug wires used at that time, were susceptible to breaking internally when moved around (guess age, heat and twisting??). They luckily just charged for the wires and ran like new until I bid it farewell at 220K in about 5 years! (So Mike, don’t be surprised if there are some “related” expenses when they dig in)

When I figure that as a one-time expense on a vehicle I will put over 200K on it in about 5 years, I am OK with it. I do the basic stuff (i.e. oil changes) but would rather turn a wrench on my Cub’s than risk messing something up much more complicated on my primary mode of transportation.

Mike, you must also factor in having your wife disabled on the side of the road… that will cost you MUCH MORE! :P :P
 
How about over $1000 for a fuel filter??? I had one that leaked on my old F250, couldn't get the fitting out of the inlet, neither could the dealer. The line was $300 and you had to drop one of the tanks to install the line..... 8 hours labor at dealer rates to install the line and filter. Rust never sleeps!

Just remember that in the old days cars didn't last as long or run the miles that they do today. I just installed a set of Michelin tires with a 70,000 mile warranty on a truck (diesel) with 223K on it. But, I guess I am an optimist!
 
My two year old subaru went to the dealer to have the tranny oil changed. They came up with a $75 inspection bill that i never approved. My two year old car needed $750 worth of work so they said. I told them if a two year old car needs that much work i better look for a new car. I met a subie mechanic that works at home and he charged me $85 for an hours work. I gladly gave him $150 and i been with him ever since. With my health not that great i can't do some of the stuff i once did. This guy does all my repairs that we can't do now. Plus he has his own shop now and i sent him a lot of business too. My car now has 200k on it and its due for headgaskets soon. I'm hoping to get 300k out of it and maybe more.

After being a mechanic at the dealer for so many years, i really don't trust any mechanic's nor car salesmans. But i got lucky when i found this guy.

I just put a set of 80,000 mile tires on it too.
 
Been there done that....my 2003 Dakota tuneup was very exspensive too....I stop by alot when my trucks at the dealer and request old parts for inspection...you got to pay out alot for maint....but man its better than monthly payments...
Robert (has spent over $3500.00 in maint last year) (but driving a sweet ride) Miller
 
Back
Top