I have one of the Harbor Freight benders, and it does the job sufficiently for me, though I have never tried the others, so I cannot speak to the comparison. One thing I have learned is that there is a difference in how easy the brake tubing from different companies bends. the brake lines from NAPA,and Carquest are harder to bend,but at the same time, I suspect they are probably better lines for the high pressures used in brake lines. The ones I get from Autozone are quite a bit easier to bend.