When the tire companies decide they don't like big profits. Even though they didn't lower tire prices when oil went down, they will raise them AGAIN when oil goes up.
Not defending anything here. Just wanted to add that ALL raw materials for tires have increased dramatically over the last few years, not just oil. It is true that prices are raised before a company gets in the position of actually losing money on a product, and are lowered more in response to competitor's prices, rather than when the raw materials drop in price. Just human nature.
To John's point about "big profits", in the tire industry, 10% return on investment is admirable performance. Okay, that might have been a bit defensive....but compare that to jewelry, electronics, etc.