George Willer":tov3sujg said:
I hope I can be of comfort to you. Your decision to vote for him was the right one! Tom Ridge brought a little sanity to a broken system. On balance, his decision brought life to those otherwise victims who would have been murdered by "prisoners who got away with their crime because we were too timid"
The scales of justice can tip either way, of course, but we are better served when they tip in favor of innocent people.
Tom Ridge isn't evil... He was merely enforcing our collective will against evil. I agree with the collective will, and I imagine you really do too.
Given a choice I would very much prefer to live among moral law abiding citizens than convicted murderers who got away with it.
George,
I do not oppose the principal behind the concept of the death penalty. Not at all. Of course, in a world where the truth is self evident, we could be sure of a person's deeds and intentions, and those who are beyond redemption, and pose a danger to his fellow creature could be euthanized for the benefit of all living beings.
Of course, we do not live in a world where the truth is self-evident. Judges and juries convict according to many factors, not the least of which is personal charisma and appearance.
A good example might be, George, if there were two suspects for the same murder, say, Donny and Myself, and we were both indicted, but there were no witnesses, Donny's charm and charisma would certainly be of help to him, while my lack of both would surely lead to my conviction.
It is statistically accurate to say that at least 10% of those convicted are wrongly so, and 5% of those executed are killed in error.
Whatever else we do to prisoners is reversible, repairable, remediable......
Execution is not.
This is my principle argument, for therefore in 100 executions, we have done justice 95 times, but have committed murder 5 times. That makes us not much better than the criminals themselves.
I support life imprisonment without any chance of parole, but it seems that option no longer exists. Perhaps a new "death sentence" of "imprisoned until you are dead" might fit the bill, but I am not a lawyer, or a legislator.
It always seems incomprehensible to me that the same people who oppose abortion (a view that I, in principal, share) because of the loss of innocent life, are usually the death penalty's staunchest supporters.
But isn't all life sacred? Should we not kill only when absolutely necessary? Selectively supporting murder in some cases, but not in others, and letting God sort out our motivation sounds a little risky to me.
Sorry....didn't mean to get preachy again..... :shock: