Six vs Twelve Pt. Sockets

Dan England

501 Club
While attempting to change out blades on my riding lawnmower, I managed to round off the head of a bolt. I was using a 12 pt socket because I didn't have a 6 pt of the size needed for bolt removal. I have purchased a 6 pt and expect to have better results using it. But I have wondered a number of times what advantage, if any, a 12 pt has over a six? There must be some reason for tool companies to make and sell the twelve pt unit. Dan
 
Dan, I don't know the reasoning behind the 12 point sockets, but the luck you had is what I always get with 12 point. I now only use 6 points in order not to round off the bolt head or the nut. Maybe someone else has a better explanation. Pete
 
Dan,
The only advantage I can see is using a 12 point is in tight spaces. The points will be every 30 degrees on the 12 point vs every 60 on the 6 point.
8)
 
Twelve point will also fit square heads. That still isn't enough to keep me from updating to six pointers. If the nut is tight you'll round of a square head real fast.
 
Don't forget that you really tighten mower blades so they don't slip. The friction of grass and dirt works against you too, The ability to round off square nuts as well as hex nuts is a consideration too.
 
Ratchets are much better than they used to be. Some of those old ratchets barely gave enough "click" for a 12 point socket to work.
 
I have both 6 and 12 point sockets in both SAE and Metric :big say what: Talk about a bit of overkill. But, it does have it's advantages. As Donny said, and I never stopped to figure it out mathematically as he has.. 8) .. 12 point has it's uses in cramped spaces. If a bolt or nut needs to be really reefed on, 6 point is the way to go. 12 point can and usually does ruin a bolt head.. but again, they have their place.

Much like a screw driver. Many shapes, many sizes many uses. One of the uses of a screw driver is NOT as a crow bar.. they tend to break... :big give up: btdttetaie :!:
 
beaconlight":hkq5yfmw said:
Don't forget that you really tighten mower blades so they don't slip. The friction of grass and dirt works against you too, The ability to round off square nuts as well as hex nuts is a consideration too.
Maybe I misunderstood your statement, but on most of the mowers I have dealt with that used just the friction method to hold the blade tight, as opposed to having a star or key to hold it, the blade tended to tighten the bolt as it beat against the grass, etc. not loosen it.
 
BD:

That's easy:

btdttetaie = Been There, Done That, Too Embarrassed To Admit It Earlier :big shy: :big smile:
 
12pt sockets are needed for 12pt hardware common in aviation and else where. Snap-On/Mac and others make all there sockets and wrenches in flank drive to help prevent slippage on corroded or just plain tight fasteners. With spline drive or flank drive the 12pt will actually grip better as it makes contact only on the flat area of the bolt or nut not on the corners. I have even have impacts sockets in 12pt and 12pt swivels. At work all my tools are 12pt as 6pt would be worthless since probably 60% of aviation hardware is 12pt.
 
I have both six and twelve point. I seem to use the six point more to keep from rounding the head off. I also love the deep well it sometimes keeps from using an extension or when the bolt sticks past the nut to far. :) :)

Jim
 
Barnyard":30qea3p5 said:
Twelve point will also fit square heads. That still isn't enough to keep me from updating to six pointers. If the nut is tight you'll round of a square head real fast.

To properly fit a square nut you need an eight point socket. they are rare these days, but still available from Snap-on tool company.
 
As a mechanic, one must have all the above, sometimes in multiple! Yes, you can use a 12 pt. on a square head, but it really doesn't work that well. Eight point sockets are not too popular these days, there are not a lot of square fasteners used any more. I have a few of these sockets, mostly smaller sizes. I have a few 4 pt. sockets as well.
 
I've got 8 and 4 pt sockets up to 1 1/4" here at work as most aviation filter bowls have a square on the bottom for removal. Sure an adjustable works but not convenient for all hard to reach places.
 
My eight point sockets get more use than the set of weatherhead sockets I purchaced many years ago. I just don't work on valve banks in tight spots anymore.
 
Being an ex-car/truck mechanic some of my socket sets are 12pt and 6pt. All of my impact sets are 6pt. My 3/4" drive set is 6pt too. I try to use 6pt sockets most of the time.
 
Back
Top