Question for the Computer Challenged

ricky racer

501 Club
It's time for me to upgrade my computer and I don't know anything about them. I am currently using and E-Machines that is way to slow and does not have enough memory. Stopped at a PC Direct store that was recommended to me by a more computer savvy co-worker. Money is tight and my budget is small. I have a monitor, keyboard and mouse, what I need is the CPU. I am currently using Windows XP but the new one that the salesman recommended comes with Windows Vista. I have not heard to much good about Vista but really don't know anything about it. Any thoughts???
Listed below is the unit I am looking at:

EMacnines ET1810-01 Desk top
Celeron 420 (1.6GHz) 2 GB, DDR2 RAM
160GB HDD, 10/100, 56K
Dual Layer DVD+/-RW
Vista Home Basic
NVIDIA 7050 Graphic on Board
6 Channel High Definition Audio
Multi-Card Reader
PS2 Keyboard & Mouse

I know discussions about computers is like spark plugs or motor oil everybody has opinions about what is best, but any input to help me know if what I am looking at is a good decision. The cost is $269.99 which is not to bad. A system with Windows 7 is about $100 more. Give me your thoughts on this unit, help me make up my mind.

Thanks, Rick
 
I'm not up on all the computer stuff, but I do know that vista is not friendly with most anything that connects to your computer. My camera and printer are useless with my vista computer but works fine with XP. Windows 7 is supposed to support these also. E-machines had a bad reputation years ago. I don't know if they are better now or not.

And then there are those who would want you to take a bite of the Apple.

Edit: Spelling
 
Barnyard":mpw2wwr1 said:
I'm not up on all the computer stuff, but I do know that vista is not friendly with most anything that connects to your computer. My camera and printer are useless with my vista computer but works fine with XP. Windows & is supposed to support these also. E-machines had a bad reputation years ago. I don't know if they are better now or not.

And then there are those who would want you to take a bite of the Apple.

The salesman said that early on things like printers and such that connected to Vista had problems. He said that had been fixed and that service packs were available to fix older Vista systems, but then, he's a salesman too. I've got a friend at Church that is an IT guy. I'll ask him about it tomorrow.
I'm just looking for feedback from you guys to get your feelings on what works and what to stay away from. I appreciate the feedback Bill.
 
I'll check on those service packs for mine. Maybe I can use my scanner after all. Thanks for your info.
 
Emachines is to computers about what Valu-Built is to Cub carburetor kits. My view of Dell is similar. Any other than those two are probably reasonably safe. I recently bought an Asus, which seems to currently have as good a reputation as any.

I never had Vista on my computers but the reputation has been poor. My recent Asus has Windows 7. I have run across a couple odd behaviors but no big deals. I would encourage going to a Windows 7 system (Easy to spend somebody else's money). If you have things you want to connect (like Barnyard's camera and printer), you may find it no longer works on a newer system. They may depend on specifc drivers. Eventually, people quit writing updated drivers for old peripherals. I hit the end of the line on my scanner (which is really old). Microtek didn't update a driver for Win7 but refers people to a third party that does drivers. The third party wants $50 for their driver. Meanwhile I can buy a new scanner for $100. No point investing half the cost of a new one to keep an old one going for a while.
 
Personally, I think that this system is a bit bare bones for what is on the market currently.

I would strongly advise skipping right over integrated graphics for an actual graphics card. And I would skip Vista for 7, although again on a better system. Keep watching for sales flyers and look for a more featured computer. 370 is not that great of a deal in my mind for barebones, integrated graphics, low processor power ( The Celeron 420 iirc is a single core low power draw processor) , and 7.

For comparison my old system which is my back up and now over 7 years old
P4 2.4 ghz, 2 gigs ram
XP Pro
Nvidea GeGorce 6800 256 mb
280 gb hdd

Yes this system was more expensive by far 7 years ago, but then again it wouldn't cost that much now.
 
There's a reason any Vista computers are cheaper than 7. They're trying to get rid of them. I bought an HP laptop during the Christmas shopping season and any Vista computers were drastically discounted. 7 is far better, money well spent.
 
I may be the only person in the world who actually likes Vista. The compatibility issues it had/has with some devices have to do with device manufacturers developing 64-bit drivers. The older the device, the less likely they will be to release new drivers. When I updated to Vista, the only thing I lost was my scanner. I had an old printer that I had used since my old Windows 95 system, and it worked with Vista - go figure. I replaced them both with an all-in-one.

I haven't used Win 7 yet, but I know it's basically the system Vista was supposed to be. It is also 64 bit, so it will have the same driver issues as Vista if the manufacturers don't want to write new drivers. I'd recommend going with 7 over Vista, though. Microsoft has maintained support for XP for so long because it is so popular. Don't look for Vista to have such a long support life.

If all you're going to do with your computer is access the Web and e-mail, just about any boxed system off the shelf will do. If you want to play games or even watch DVD, you'll want a dedicated video card. I've always recommended that folks determine how much they can pay, then get as much system as they can for the money.
 
This is a really bare bones system. It has just enough processor and ram to run the system and not much else. Think of it as taking your cub out to plow the north 40. You could do it. However, it would take you a long time.

Running Vista or Window 7, I wouldn't want less than 4 GB of ram or a 64 bit OS.

Just looking through the local Micro Center add you could get a new HP Pavillion for $419

  • * AMD Athlon II 620 Quad Core processor
    * NVIDIA Ge Force graphics card
    * Windows 7 64 bit
    * 6 GB RAM
    * 640 GB Hard Drive
    * DVD burner
That was just a quick look in the add. I am sure similar deals can be had in your area.

Thanks,

Doug
 
Rick:

Well, I have been building them now since 1994.. so that is what 16 years or so... and IMHO...... Don't waste your money on an E-Machines box. It is one of the worst of the entry level boxes and generally uses very low end componets so that they can achieve the price break that they need to provide the margin needed. In other words.. they may say.. NVIDIA 7050 Graphic on Board - which most consumers would think is a good video card/on board video section. Like ATI, NVidia manufactures their own cards and subsets but they also market chipsets that other manufactures can build their cards/mainboards around. I can guarantee that this is not an NVidia product, just the chipset. That means.. when Windows XP/VIsta/7 attempts to update the hardware, it may very well download the wrong driver for it. (been there, done that, wore out the shirt, jacket and parka on that one :( ) E-machines will use a cheap Chinese mainboard which means that it is not an NVidia but is simply the chipset. If it was say an ASUS, then NVidia may possibly manufacture the subset for ASUS.. but then that is in the upper 5% of top end mainboards.

Oh like other things in life.. you get what you pay for. To be able to sell a box (the CPU is actually the primary chip on the motherboard and is not the box that houses it - in this case the CPU is actually the Celeron 420 (1.6GHz) 2 GB, DDR2 RAM (stripped chip.. no math copro not even comparable to a Sempron or Duron AMD chip), E-machines and other entry level manufactures will use the cheapest components possible. Example.. A Lite-On DVD-RW dual layer will retail for approx $60.00 to $80.00 US/Cdn depending if it is a Light Scribe or not. A white box or OEM version will sell for about $40.00 to $50.00 for the same unit. Right there you have 25% of the cost of the E-machine box.. so the DVD-RW is going to be a lower entry level Rom than say even an ACER entry level box. 1.6ghz is not a fast chip, albeit it depends a lot on the FSB or Front Bus Speed to determine what the actual performace will be.. but 1.6 ghz is an entry level chip.. even with a high FSB speed. 2gb of DDR2 is also old technology.. at least 3 years old and will shortly be difficult to obtain. Of course that also depends on if it is SD DDR2 and what it's speed is.. 4400mhz and above is good. Lower not so good. I have been having problems getting DDR2-3300 for Em's primary desktop. Hers is 4 years old and is an Athalon 64 X2 Dual Core at 4.2ghz. She has 3 ghz of DDR2 ram... not quite fast enough either. I need to upgrade her desktop as well, it is time.

I am not a Mac fan at all.. been there done that. I am pretty much a PC guy as they are easy to fix/repair and are affordable.

I am not exactly a Vista fan either. However, I am posting this on a Vista Business Edition Toshiba Satellite PRO P-300 laptop that is surprisingly fun to use. Not as good as XP for some things, but superior in others. Oh darn did I just actually say that :big what: :big give up:

When looking for a new computer, one has to know what one really wants the computer to do. Unfortunately too many people do not examine what they want their computer to do, so when they buy one it is usually not what they need at all, nor is it the most cost effective one.

Do you want to simply surf the net.. visit farmallcub.com etc. do a little word processing, maybe your taxes etc... Or do you want a gaming computer. Maybe a multimedia computer for playing with your music and movie collection. These are all things that need to be considered. Just like buying a car, a computer is a complicated decison and should be examined for the best deal.

In a packaged system there are a number of levels of quality and a number of manufactures that rank form best to worst. In my experience the best computers available in say a laptop would be a Panasonic ToughBook CF-19, but at $3000.00 (depending on model), it is not very affordable. However some of the best affordable laptops would be Toshiba or Dell. Yes, Dell.. surprisingly if you research their puters, you can find good ones that will last for years. I have had 3 Dell Latitude C-600 series laptops that were dependable, quick and affordable. The better ones are the Toshiba and I/my family have had 9 Toshiba laptops over the last 5 years. All good machines, very dependable and very good warranties. Acer would be a close 3rd. The worst laptops would be Lenovo (formely IBM but now Chinese), Hp and Compaq.

Desktops.. the best are custom built ones.. and those are the ones that I much prefer. Mostly cause I build my own.. but custom built usually use top end components priced to the customers budget. In the packaged systems, probably the better of the mid priced would be HP and Acer. Dell is a close third. Remember that these are entry level machines. Compaq would probably follow Dell. Lenovo, E-machines and other off-brands are at the bottome of the entry level list.

You can get a Compaq - Presario Desktop with AMD Sempronâ„¢ Processor l entry level computer that is twice as good as that E-machine for about $40.00 more :big say what: .. yeah.. Still not a great desktop but far superior to the E-machine. There are deals out there even at big box stores.. just have to look.
 
I agree with what has been said about keeping your eyes open - you never know what kinds of deals you may find at the local outlets. The machine you described, to me, is a little dated. I guarantee you that you will be just as disappointed as you are now if you put vista on that machine you are looking at. It will be SLOW. As has been stated, it is easy to spend someone else's money, but I would really consider looking at a Windows 7 machine. Vista had plenty of problems. It's a pain. They swept it under the rug rather quickly and introduced Windows 7. I have used both - Win 7 is much nicer. I've been pretty slack about it lately, but in the very near future I've got a copy of 7 I'm going to put over the Vista partition on my computer. I've said that for months now :roll:

You've been given a lot of good advice so far. Keep your eyes peeled and just see what you come across. If I could say one more thing........ memory, memory, memory !!!
 
Another thing I've noted on cheap computers is the racket they make. Sound like a bunch of loose screws rattling around in there when the fans spool up.

My HP workstation is pretty much silent. Might not be a huge consideration, but if you don't want to have to shut it off to hear the tv...
 
Rudi":2fa9b609 said:
Yes, Dell.. surprisingly if you research their puters, you can find good ones that will last for years.
Maybe, but if you do have trouble don't expect any help from Dell.
 
One other thing to consider. Find a computer shop that has good recommendations. That does not include the ones in the back of the office supply store. Talk to them. Often a good tec can speed up a machine with just a few tweeks. Also you can usually pick up a reconditioned machine that has the same warranty as a new one and has good ol' XP for much less than a new one. Do go with PC if you can.
 
I started with a Mac and I was either too stupid to use it or not trainable so I went to Dell and haven't looked back. I recently updated to a new dell and had to pay $100.00 to have them install the windows 7. Nothing like paying xtra to go backward!!! My 2nd dell had problems and after a week of talking to them on the phone they sent a guy to my house and after playing with it for a couple of hours he gave me a whole new system that was better than the one I bought. Wife has Vista and she likes it once she figured out the quirks. Grump
 
Ricky,
Guess I'll jump in. All depends on what you are looking for and want to spend. There are some decent puters out there reasonably priced. I myself have a, gulp, Dell. Dimension 4700 and have had it for about 5 years without a lick of an issue. Good computer IMHO. Rudy did a nice job summing up stuff. Windows XP is a good system, stay far away from Vista. If you can swing the extra $100, go for Windows 7! Good luck on your search and keep us posted on what you decide. There are some pretty nice laptops out there for good prices also. Everyone tells me Toshiba laptops are the best. Never had a laptop, so can't vouch for em.

Red56
 
red56turbo":1tdfhbec said:
There are some pretty nice laptops out there for good prices also.
That is certainly an option. There are laptops out there from several reputable companies with Win7 and specs as high or higher than in your original post in the $300 to $350 range. You can plug in your existing monitor. You may have to buy a USB adapter (inexpensive) to use your current mouse and keyboard.
 
Another thing to look for, most of the Vista systems now offer free upgrades to Windows 7. At least, the reputable outfits do.
 
Rudi has been helping me understand better what is going on with my computer. One thing is that my computer does not have near enough RAM, but I can add more which will speed mine up considerably. Also he has been helping me update my computer. I feel like such a moron when it comes to this stuff and am amazed at the wealth of knowledge that Rudi possesses when it comes to computers!!

I'm very grateful to all here who have shared their wisdom with me and have helped to keep me from making a big mistake. I knew that this was the place to get good honest answers to questions about something that I know nothing about.

Thanks, guys!! :wink:
 
:( :( :( I've had vista now for about two years and I hate it. It came with my new PC. Not very user friendly, at times it does crazy things for no reason. I've heard they rushed it onto the market before all the kinks were out. I also received daily updates for about the first year.
 
Back
Top