Good morning Gentlemen,
Some of the quasi-democratic nations of Eastern Europe used the "professional juror" model, for the very same reasons it seems attractive to us now. I have, too, considered the benefits and problems of such a system.
Some of them did run afoul for the very reason Bigdog mentioned. Others circumambulated that problem by using a "professional juror pool lottery", but indeed, if a juror is inclined to vote a certain way, intrinsically, then, even the lottery system becomes nothing more than justice by the roll of dice.
If we watch a neighbour shoot himself in the foot, and see that it is painful, it is not necessary to repeat that experiment to gain that knowledge. Thus, I do not believe that we need to experiment with a "professional juror" system here to realize that these same problems, and many others that are built into such a system, would follow directly.
I certainly agree that there are problems with our justice system, but they are problems of encumbrance, and not of intrinsic nature. We have a very strong Mule here, gentlemen, in our justice system, and it has the capacity to serve us well, but we must take proper care of it, or it will indeed cease to function properly, and in those instances, we seem to find the reasons to complain about it.
We must have the courage of our convictions to stand behind it, and that means, unfortunately, paying for it. It is necessary to build, and maintain enough prisons, and penal systems so that judges can hand down appropriate sentences for crimes. The less compassionate among you will, at this point, start thinking along the lines of "kill the @%^$@#'s", and "put them all on an island and let them deal with each other"...of course, and I understand this, as I used to be one of you.
The bottom line seems to indicate that prison, or any other punishment, really, is not really a deterrent to crime, but we must, for our own protection, remove those persons who present a danger to society, from society, and we must be prepared to do so for extended periods of time, because "rehabilitation" doesn't really work, either.
So, for everyone who complains about the way judges sentence these days, and the way plea-bargains are arranged to vastly curtail prison time, you need to realize that the only alternative is paying more money, in some shape or form, to imprison these individuals for longer periods.
Of course, some of you are thinking that prisons are "too good" for some of these people......well, you are partially correct, but, I will say, overall, that for every 1 prison that is "too nice", there are probably 3 that are "hell holes". We need some sort of standardization here, being humane and decent, and yet not providing a lifestyle that is enviable in any way.
Of course, by the same token, I have always thought that prisons should be structured in such a way that the inmates provide for themselves, to as great an extent as possible, easing the burden on the public for their care, and at the same time, providing them some personal satisfaction of having accomplished something. This idea is usually opposed by business owners, who see lost contracts as a result of this practice, and by ultra-liberals, who see this, in some way, as inhumane, although I think keeping people as "pets" is much more inhumane than giving them something useful to do.
Let me give you all a "working" example of perversity of our justice system.....
My Girlfriend has a nephew, Mikey, who is 21 now. If you ever encountered him working at my tent at a fair, you would think "Nice, polite, handsome boy." Last summer he worked with us on the road as a "bull"....driving in tent stakes with sledgehammer, carrying heavy boxes and so forth. We did this because employment was a condition of his parole, and, being illiterate, and a parolee, he's not exactly the "pick of the litter" for employers.
The reason he went to prison in the first place, was that one night, he, and 3 friends decided, under the influence of several intoxicants, that it would be a good idea to drive around the wealthy suburbs of Reading, PA, and throw rocks through people's house windows.
Now, Mikey is not a bright boy, in fact, prior to his arrest, he was receiving SSI benefits for being "mentally retarded", and I would say, after working with him for a summer, that this is a fair assessment of his faculties. So, when authorities questioned the other boys, they denied their involvement, but, Mikey admitted his. OK, nothing wrong with being truthful, and owning up to your sins. I find that admirable about him. The problem is that he did not succumb to pressure to implicate his friends, which, I suppose, from a certain point of view, is also admirable. So, at the age of 17, he was tried as an adult for all of the charges, alone, in hopes that at some point he would "crack" and implicate the other boys, which he never did, of course. His sentence, in the end, was 5-10 years imprisonment, and restitution in the amount of $35,000, and an additional fine of $30,000.
Anyone besides me think that this was a little extreme for a case of criminal vandalism? Actually, considering his faculties, more like criminal stupidity??
He told me at one point over the summer that if he could have served out his entire sentence in the County prison, he would have rather stayed the 10 years, because life there was easier than it was outside. When he was 18, however, he was transferred to state prison, which was an entirely different matter. He told me that he had been sexually assaulted in state prison more times than he could remember, both by inmates and prison employees. I encouraged him to take that information public, but he would have none of that..... Male pride and all, of course.
So, two years and a little more of state prison, and he was released on parole, with the condition that he find a job. Fascinating, really..... an illiterate, clueless kid, who has the earning potential of a housefly.
So, we took him on for the summer for a meager $30 a day (on days we were open...nothing on travel days, when he worked the most)...but more than he could get anywhere else. We fed him, and gave him a place to sleep, as well. It kept his payment arrangement with the parole officer, and gave him a few bucks for beer (I myself do not drink, and wish he had saved it for something else, but that was his decision).
At the end of the summer, he went back to his mother's house, and tried for a while to find a job, but of course who would have him? So, when the parole officer started becoming threatening, he took off out of state, with my blessing, and a couple of dollars from me for travel expenses. What is one supposed to do for one such as he? I cannot pay for a criminal attourney to re-open his case for him, although I wish that I could.
His parole arrangement is such that he will remain on parole until the entire $65,000 is paid back, and of course, he cannot regain SSI benefits until he is off of parole. Fascinating, really.
I didn't have a lot of sympathy for "stupid kid syndrome" before this event, but I must tell you now, that the way our justice system treats older teens and young adults in some cases needs to be re-evaluated, particularly in cases where society has failed those kids to begin with.
In some cases, we create our own problems......
Namaste,
--Tom