No Way Bail them out!!!!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.

BigBill

501 Club
There is noway we and our goverment should bail out any company no matter what. All these many years they sat back making themselves and there shareholders/stockholders $$$ while we paid the bill over and over they actually got fat on us the hard working middleclass people. Now they made there money and there going broke now after they paid there dividens to there shreholder/stockholders. So now its up to us to pay them back??? Let the ones who got the profits pay them back not us. Our tax dollars should not be used to bail out car companies or wall street no matter what.

Its funny that none of these companies saved any $$ when things were good for when times got bad. What were they thinking?

I lost my job in '83 to inflation and high interest rates no one would buy a million dollar machine and finance it at 21%. I lost my job again in '84 & '85 as the recession continued. I worked only 3 months each year. My family of four lived on 10k each year and survived and ate good too. Its funny how little you can live on if you watch your $$$ and plant a big garden too. My point is survival is there you just have to work for it. I have no regrets it made my kids knowledgable about survival and how to stay focused and never give up when things are down. Just move forward and never look back the better view is infront of you. Its a test of your will and drive.....life is a game just stay focused and play to win.

Even if i lose my life savings(IRA) for retirement i say no to the bail out let them eat cake....... :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}: :{_}:

If our goverment bails them out they should be bailing out every american too think about it. Its us who paid the taxes so we should be getting the $$.
 
Don McCombs":186u939c said:
It's called corporate welfare, Bill. Methinks we won't have a choice. :(

I think you are right. There would be a lot of people without jobs.
Kyle
 
The US economy has not experienced a full blown recession in too many years, this one is going to be the painful catch up for the last few that were averted with monetary policy manipulations. The enormous bill created by leveraged consumption we've experienced for the past 20 years is coming due for payment. Prepare for tax increases, higher inflation, more unemployment. We have at least 2 more years of mortgage failures to deal with. A personal debt (aka credit cards) collapse and commercial loan failures are looming on the horizon as unemployment increases and spending decreases.

Unfortunately, our esteemed leaders are following the Japanese example for creating a sustained economic slump. Bail outs or not, there simply isn't enough cash to save everyone from their fate.
 
When Mr Greenspan and others in power the last several years made monetary decisions to cut or raise interest and manipulate our economy , we all knew it was a crutch for a more serious problem . But the result was we all got what we wanted in affordable mortgages , easy credit card access and were able borrow more than we truly could afford and Walla here we are today. I agree with a previous post that the corporations and their heads making outrageous amounts of money and benefits should be responsible for their own operation and be fully accountable to their shareholders. But our society does not demand that accountability and here we are. Bail out may or may not be the thing to do here I dont know , but any bailout should come with some hefty strings attached in my opinion. My 2 cents worth :D
 
No more bail outs. There is already $2 billion missing and the people in charge (edit: Treasury Sec., Henry Paulson) of the bail out won't tell Congress where the money went.

The hugh commercial banking firms that received bail out money spent the money purchasing other banks, not as they were supposed to do, help ease the credit crunch.

GM is worth $31.09 billion and has $15.9 billion cash on hand. GM's debt is $45.16 billion. So if GM goes bankrupt and the government has to sell the assetts, great. There should be almost enough money to cover GM's obligations to their retirees. If the Gov steps in and bails out GM with $5 billion or so, GM will be in the same position in 5 years. To make matters worse, if the Gov takes some sort of position (partial ownership) in GM, the government then has to honor all of GM's contracts.

OH. Congress is investigating the corporations involved in the current fiscal crisis. Good luck on that one. Is Congress going to investigate it's own involvement and responsibility in this matter?
 
We are held responcible as individuals, they should be too. Let them fall if they were not.

I guess I am blessed in that in 2003 I went out on disability. We had always struggled financially because we decided to live on one income and Jan raised our children. When I lost all my income, Jan found a job and supported us, even thru my medical tough times. We got behind but never had credit cards and had no car loans.

After 2 years I finally got my disability, we paid our tithe, then all of our debts, bought a couple good used cars for cash, and took a modest family vacation. The rest went to savings. A year later we were able to buy our place.

Since then(we have been here 2 1/2yrs) Jan has lost 2 jobs and has been out of work for a total of about a year. My modest disability pays the mortgage and utilities, and we figure the rest out somehow.

It would scare me to death to think of having the debt's I hear them talk about on the news. I am thankfull and gratefull for HIS provision.
 
dshawz":bgenw2ib said:
It would scare me to death to think of having the debt's I hear them talk about on the news. I am thankfull and gratefull for HIS provision.

Well said Dale, We all are very blessed. A few days from now we all have to stop and consider how thankful we really are :{_}: :{_}:

I agree the free market model should allow mis-management to be rewarded with failure, not billions of taxpayer $ :evil: :evil:
 
"Find the cause then treat the symptoms." $40 per hour for putting on lug nuts under a labor contract? Think about it, it's not rocket science. :censored:
 
DanR":t6mzkruk said:
"Find the cause then treat the symptoms." $40 per hour for putting on lug nuts under a labor contract? Think about it, it's not rocket science. :censored:
At the risk of turning this into a bashing thread, I want to know where that job is. I know lots of auto workers, and non of them make anywhere near that. Ones with 25 years experience make around 17 to 18 for assembly line work, and special skills such as the robot maintenance, etc;. around 22 per hour.
 
I don't know if this is the case any longer since the new contracts with the UAW but when a you are a car company and you spend more money on health care cost then you do on the steel for your cars some things got to give.. and before you go laying all of the blame squarely on the health care system remember this-the number one killer of Americans are obesity or life style related diseases. :x
Now as far as there pay is concerned the best I could find on the web was a average of 27 dollars an hour.
 
Now that may be what the pay hourly but with benfits and over time it looks more like this

"From Forbes....
Labor cost per hour, wages and benefits for hourly workers, 2006.

Ford:$70.51 ($141,020 per year)

GM:$73.26 ($146,520 per year)

Chrysler:$75.86 ($151,720 per year)

Toyota, Honda, Nissan (in U.S.):$48.00 ($96,000 per year)

According to AAUP and IES, the average annual compensation for a college professor in 2006 was $92,973 (average salary nationally of $73,207 + 27% benefits).

Bottom Line: The average UAW worker with a high school degree earns 57.6% more compensation than the average university professor with a Ph.D.(see graph above, click to enlarge), and 52.6% more than the average worker at Toyota, Honda or Nissan.

to think that these professors who had to spend tens of thousands of dollars to obtain phd's could have just gotten a HS diploma and work for the big 3. "

Now I treid finding the article on this on Forbes but it seems it no longer exists.

http://livefromkirkwood.com/2008/10/29/ ... otor-city/

interesting... :wink:
 
Now John, don't get your knickers in a twist. Take the salary, add health care for the family, paid vacation, paid sick leave, discounts, social security, retirement benefits, administrative costs, bonuses, and you have way over $40 per hour. The automaker thru you the consumer pay that.
 
But the employee is not getting the $40 per hour, which was the statement. Many of those things are never seen by them, plus the accounting departments have a tendency to build in a lot that isn't really there to make their taxes, etc. look better. Unless it has changed from a few years ago when I saw figures before the books were "cooked/processed" an employee has to bring in twice his hourly income for the company he is working for to make a profit. That took into account unemployment, social security, etc. Much of the health care costs have been shifted more and more to the worker, and in many instances the only health benefit the employee receives is a lower rate due to being in a big group, but the companies still claim big deductions for it. Then look at companies who are failing, with executives making 400 to 500 times what a line employee makes. Don't balim it on an employee that wants to be able to buy the car he builds, or wants a home for his family.
 
I agree with John on the worker wage issue. I'm a retired UAW Jeep worker and most of the people who gather an opinion about the auto workers only base their opinions on what they see or read in the papers or news media. I still remember the day we(line workers) were supposed to get our big profit sharing check. The news media posted the average check would total $6000-$9000. Most of us were pretty excited. We(line workers) ended up receiving a check with a gross of $600. Guess we all were way below average. They never did explain that one to us. In the days when I decided to retire, the "Lean Manufacturing" practices had everyone racing to do the same job that was enjoyable years ago. When it came time to go home, the first thing you did when you jumped in your vehicle was to take a quick rest. Now if I have to visit the doc, I have to pay full office visits. Please don't believe everything you read or see about the auto industry. It's just not the same as it may have been years ago. I feel bad for the workers, but I'm angry at the big exec's paychecks.

Rick
 
Good point Rick. I'm sure everyone knows that the media distorts the facts and figures. Unfortunately I do not have current accurate information on the Big 3. That said, is anyone inferring that auto makers are cooking the books or anything illegal? I would like to hear from anyone that is pro automakers bailout and can give accurate information on how they arrived at that stand. Bla Bla Bla :)):
 
FRiend of mine, his best friend retired from the auto industry. He tells tales of walking in the front door at 8 am, walking out the back door at 8:10, working his lanscaping business until 3:30, back to work by 3:50, puch the clock at 4:00 and off to home for supper. He stated that this was not only commonplace, it was expected to happen once you had worked so many years on the line. So in esessence the automakers were paying "double" for the job to being done.
 
I have read more conflicting articles this past week relating to the economy, stocks and personal finance than ever before. If genuine economists and financial wizards don't have a handle on what's going on, our esteemed leaders certainly don't have a clue. Washington has been bleeding money for decades, they believe huge deficits is good business practice. Should we expect any viable solutions from these fiscal morons?
 
The worker may not be getting $40 an hour in his/her paycheck, but with all the extras is still getting over $40 an hour compensation. From the employers viewpont, it is the same.
My ex-wife worked for GM at the Shreveport truck plant about 9-10 yrs ago. It was a part time job, around 30-35 hours a week. She worked the assembly line, installing switches of some sort, don't remember, definately unskilled labor. She was making over $18/hr part time! If that was the wage back then, what is it now??
Lurker Carl":3at73eqo said:
Washington has been bleeding money for decades, they believe huge deficits is good business practice. Should we expect any viable solutions from these fiscal morons?
I agree, we are in for a rough ride.
 
Having been to several places in Mexico, it's sad to see where all the manufactoring has gone. While some will say it's cheaper labor,(lower wages and no health benes), others will say that the employees show up for work every day. My FIL was a line super with GM for many years. Always had a hard time getting everybody to show up for work. :roll:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top