Newer Diesel Pickups--MPG?

Super A

501 Club
In the next year or so, maybe shorter, maybe longer, I would like to trade my '02 Chevy Silverado Z-71 (4wd, ext. cab, short bed, "off road package") for a new/newer truck. My current truck has about 170,000 miles on it and hasn't given any trouble, but I would like to trade before it decides to "show itself" and I end up with a major repair.

Right now, if I had to buy today and money was no object, I'd look for a new or '08/'09 model Dodge 2500 with the Cummins diesel and automatic.

Now the question(s). Can anyone tell me of a place to find real, reliable info on fuel mileage for these trucks, and for the other brands as well? All I can find on the www is information from individuals, which may or may not be reliable. (I have asked this same basic question over at Red Power and am getting some good info, I wanted to hear what you guys have to say as well.... :D )

Is a diesel really worth it? I have heard that in the long run, the maintenance costs of a diesel work out to less than a comparable gasoline truck. The fuel price difference that was present several years ago no longer works--diesel around here runs at least 10 cents a gallon more than regular unleaded. Where's the breakeven point where it's more/less cost effective to own a diesel?

I'm not going to pull a trailer every day with this truck. It'll be a daily driver, taking me 30 miles round trip to work each day, pulling a trailer maybe a couple times a month. Sometimes a Cub and Super A together, sometimes an IH 856 (100 hp tractor), and sometimes other farm stuff. In other words, will a diesel pay, for the work I am going to be doing?

What about engine longevity? Will a diesel outlast a gasser, all things being equal?

What about re-sale value? Good used diesels seem to bring more, a lot more, than a comparable gas truck. What about when that same truck is 10-15 years old and has 250,000 miles on it?

As you can see, I have a lotta questions. In my young and single days, I would've just gone and bought one. I guess I've growed up a little bit since then! 8)

Al
 
I looked at a lot of them before I found the one I wanted. The newer Fords are still having some problems with engines. Both the Ford and the Dodge are very loud. So much that its hard to hear when you are going down the road. I ended up with a 2003 Chevy with the Duramax and the Alisson transmission and I love it. In warm weather I get about 18 to 19 miles a gallon empty. Hauling the camper I get 10.
 
A new diesel will cost you what several major repairs would cost. Put a portion of a new truck monthly payment away in a savings account each month and that first "major repair" will be paid for. If you stay up on the maintenance of your '02 and are luckey enough to avoid that major repair, you'll have a big chunk of down payment for a new truck at 250,000 to 300,000 miles. It got you this far, it sounds pretty reliable. Can't give you advise on a diesel since I've never owned one. Never saw the need. I have a friend with an '06 Dodge 2500 Mega Cab diesel. Lot's of torque and no noise. Sounds like a gasser from the cab.
 
A Chevy/GMC 2500 diesel will get between 10% worse to 30% better fuel mileage than your current truck. Economics depends upon how you drive. Short trips, stop-n-go traffic, hills and lousy weather will use plenty of fuel and require shorter intervals between oil and filter changes. Long trips on level highways at moderate speed in good weather and fuel mileage rivals a mid-size V6 pickup. It takes a lot of energy to get a 7000 lbs vehicle moving and warmed up to normal operating temperature.

Oil changes are measured in gallons, not quarts. Filters are pricier than gasoline engines. And you'll need to change fuel filters and purge the water seperator on a regular basis. Diesels are very finnicky when it comes to clean fuel, clean air and clean oil.

Resale value for diesel is higher than gasoline vehicles in the Mid-Atlantic region for the late model used ones. After 15 years and 250,000 miles, figure the resale value to be next to nothing - just like any other vehicle.

***********************************************************************************

Modern diesels are incredible. You'll NEVER want a gasoline engine in a truck after you've towed with a diesel.
 
My best friend Dave just bought a new 2009 1 ton 4x4 Dodge dulley crew cab. That truck is very quiet.


But this is what I am excited about!!!

2010 Ford F-150's New 4.4L V8 Diesel Engine Gets Leaked To Internet

44-Liter-Ford-Diesel-Engine.jpg


Remember that Ford dealer conference we learned about last week from our friends at PickupTruck.com? That's the conference where we heard about the scoop on Ford's upcoming and long-rumored off-road Ford F-150 Raptor program. Well, there's a second scoop for us from the Ford forum fan-boys at F150Online, spotted by the quick-eyed folks at PUTC — the first unofficial shot of Ford's upcoming 4.4-liter V8 Diesel engine that we've heard will make it's way into the 2010 Ford F-150. We're also told we should expect it to get dropped beneath the rails of the 2010 Ford F-250 and 2010 Ford F-350 to serve as the base-level diesel engine available. And why shouldn't it? Supposedly, this smaller oil-burning V8 will give a 20% boost...

... in fuel economy, a 9% boost in power and a 15% boost in torque over an F-150 equipped with a 5.4-liter gas engine. That means the HP of this black-smoke engine should be somewhere around 340. Only problem is that owners will need to drop a load of urea into a special tank at each oil change. Mmm, that sweet, sweet smell of urea.

UPDATE: A closer inspection of the placard also indicates 4.4-liter diesel will find a home in the next Lincoln Navigator and Ford Expedition — of course we're still wondering about those rumors we'd heard about the 5.4-liter Trition V8. [PickupTruck.com]


My dad thought he heard that it is supposed to get 28mpg in a truck.

Billy
 
I have an 03 Dodge 2500 with the Cummins. I consistently get 20+ mpg. It really shines when towing as it stays up in mileage where the 95 Ram with the 360 dropped from about 17 mpg to 12 mpg when towing.
 
I have been very happy with my 2001 GMC! I bought it brand new in March of 2002, and would not buy another gasoline truck again. I have checked the mileage on it several times and on good road trips it gets about 23. In the city of Phoenix I used to get about 17 or so. Depends on how you drive. Right now being in rural TN my mileage is better since I have no stop and go traffic to worry about.

You will be spending more on oil. Mine takes 10 quarts of oil at each change. However, if you do the job yourself you can save money. I have over 140,000 miles on mine and have had only one thing that needed repair. And, that had nothing to do with the engine itself.

My one major complaint is where they put the fuel filter. It is NOT easy to change. However, by now they may have resolved that issue.

Jason
 
I have always driven Fords until I got this 2002 Chevy Duramax with Allison transmission. It gets 20 mpg unloaded and goes down to about 15 when I put the big truck camper on it. I will always try to have a diesel.
 
Unless you have your heart set on a brand-new truck,look for 2006 or 2007 models without D.P.F.(diesel particulate filter).On GM trucks,the older,"Classic"style seems to be the last of the good ones.The newer,uglier,mid-2007 and up trucks(yes,I have one)have great power but worse mileage than the older version. My 3500 dump gets 10 MPG working and averaged 12MPG hauling a trailer to RPRU and back,grossing 19,000lbs. It has a cat. converter,the DPF,and a downspout--no muffler from the factory. Approximately every 20 gallons of fuel consumed,the soot accumulated in the DPF gets burned out by diesel fuel that the computer sends there,no black smoke ever from this engineering marvel!! Tailpipe temps around 1100degrees when this is happening,plus a jet-engine-like roar. I wish I had bought a new truck a year sooner,but the deals being offered when I got this one(late Aug 08)were too good to pass up. Love the power,not happy with the mileage.
Mike
 
I've been happy with my '08 Ford SuperDuty with the 6.4 engine. Like most will say, I shopped for a while prior to going to Ford as I had an '01 Silverado prior to this truck and a '95 Dodge prior to the Chevy. I'm getting 20-22 on the highway and mine is a 4X4 as well. MPG drops a bit when towing, but not much.

It really shines when I'm at the farm which was a selling point for me buying the Ford, I've hooked up to 3 loaded grain wagons and the truck doesn't ship a beat. If you have some serious hauling/towing to do on a regular basis, the cost of running a diesel is worth it in my opinion.
 
:D :D

Something to consider is that the Cummins engine has less working parts than any other diesel engine and has no glow plugs. I've had a Dodge 93 and now a 2004 - 2500 and neither was or has been in the shop for any major repair. Both are used mainly for pulling a horse trailer and travel trailer. Pulling I average 13mph (60mph highway) and 20mph (65mphhighway) unloaded.
 
As a worker you can't beat the diesel, As a daily driver they are great if you don't mind the noise. Maybe I'm getting old and cranky but after an hour or so of the rattle it gets on my nerves. Neighbor has a couple and I know its him comming down the road long before he gets here. Other than the noise I'd have one. :) :) :) Grump
 
When I was shopping for a truck (more than a year, not in a hurry) I talked to a couple of knowledgeable friends. One trains Mopar mechanics and the other was a Ford parts guy (Kevin Ketcham). Both told me to stay away from the 2007 on models (because of the DPF and associated stuff) and since I am frugal :shock: I wasn't going to spring that kind of money anyway.

Even the Ford guys like Cummings....

What I ended up with is a 2001 7.3 L Ford. I sold a truck with less than 150K on it and the 'new' one had 212K on it. But the rust was getting the better of the gas one. I just got the results back on the oil analysis, after the longest oil change in my life (6800 miles) and it was about as perfect as it can be. I changed to synthetic for the winter.

Besides the noise (Duramax is silent in my opinion) there can be issues at cold temps with fuel gelling. I add Howes Diesel Treat at each fill up. In RI they have a deal if biodiesel is made in the state, no road tax. The IH 444 loves the stuff and it sorta smells like a french fry, but anti gel won't work with it so you need a good blend (B20 or less) when it's cold out.

Couple of stray observations by a new diesel owner.... they take much longer to warm up, they should run much longer than a gas engine, they are considerably better on fuel (best I ever got from the gas one was 14 MPG, diesel 19 MPG, 14 or so with a 2000# camper in the bed). I know if I kept it under 2000 RPMs I would get better mileage.

I am thrown by the RPMs not changing under a load, like climbing a hill. You can hear the turbo spool up, but the RPMs don't change.

A quirky one for you is the KBB.com value of my truck is DOUBLE what a gas one is....

Best part is it's got an IH engine.... so it's greeen on the outside and red on the inside.
 
i had a 94 dodge diesel and couldn keep a tranny in it took much torque. my dad bought a 95 dodge diesel he still drives it every day has bout 350,000 miles on it and runs fairly well great power. But i had a 97 chevy z-71 that had 275,000+ miles on it when i sold it and the engine was still good. I had wore out a transmission, water pump and 2 power sterring pumps and several fuel pumps. she would still fire up and run like a scalded dog. i wish i hadnt sold her :big crying:
 
Back
Top