New truck shopping

  • Thread starter Thread starter Anonymous
  • Start date Start date

What do you recommend?

  • GMC/Chevrolet 2500HD

    Votes: 15 38.5%
  • Dodge 2500

    Votes: 9 23.1%
  • Ford F250

    Votes: 15 38.5%

  • Total voters
    39
A

Anonymous

Guest
I have been pursuing a new truck for a couple months. I want a diesel to haul larger red Iron and pull a 5th wheel camper.

I've been looking hard at the Ford F250 and have almost purchased two and didn't. I took a step back and wondered if I should look at the GM & Dodge 2500's.

I am wanting a diesel, crew cab, long wheel base, cruise and a built in brake controller. I'd prefer a standard tranny (only offered by Dodge) but that is not deal breaker.

I'm not into all the power options and chrome packages. I just want truck and power. I have a car if I wan't luxury.

Today I did heavy research on the GM & Dodge and like some things I see in all three models now. I want to ask your experience with these 3 trucks.
 
I have a 2003 Chevy 2500 with a Duramax engine and Allison tranny. It has 102K on it and still runs like a top. It gets over 11 a gallon haulling the camper and over 21 on the 4 lanes empty.
 
Cecil":1uxce62z said:
I have a 2003 Chevy 2500 with a Duramax engine and Allison tranny. It has 102K on it and still runs like a top. It gets over 11 a gallon haulling the camper and over 21 on the 4 lanes empty.

Cecil,
Out of curiosity, have you added a chip or is it plain vanilla?
 
I have an 03 Dodge 2500 quad cab long bed 2WD with the Cummins 5.9 liter diesel. I get 21 mpg on the open road and 18 - 20 mpg pulling the trailer with either 2 cubs or a cub and golf cart. It has the automatic transmission which is fine by me (the older you get the less you enjoy shifting). :D
The long wheelbase and weight make it a very comfortable ride and you hardly know there's a trailer behind you. There are about 2 times a year I wish it had 4 WD but for what I gain in mileage I can live with those 2 times.
 
Having ridden in Cecil's truck, empty, and pulling a camper, I have to say,it is quiet, comfortable, and powerful. Scott has a F250 diesel pickup, which rides rougher, is noisier, and I don't think that the mileage is as good. Does have plenty of power, pulling a trailer. Ed
 
When Cecil brought his 2500 up pulling that new trailer of his, it blew both Em and I away. Were very impressed by the trailer and I was blown away by the Silverado. The last truck I had was an 82 GMC Sierra and it was probably the best darned truck I ever had. I was a dyed in the wool GM guy back then. I became a real fan of the Ram's after Em bought our first Chrysler product -- the 90 Acclaim. I guess I always will be a fan of the Ram, but the Chevy/GMC is really gaining ground and is slowly dragging me back to the GM fold. I was impressed with how Cecil's Silverado 2500 both in power, ride and appointments. My brother in law Ray has a 96 Dodge Ram 1500 4wd .. nice truck for what it is, but is always was rough riding and loud. His new 2010 Ford F150 4 wd is an amazing truck .. simply amazing. Gas though.. but has all the bells and whistles. I really would like some of the bells that Ford has in the Silverado.

I had wanted to get a nice mobile home for travelling like a HIghway Coach conversion etc., but after Em saw Pris and Cecil's trailer... the decision was made. She wants a tag-a-long like theirs and a nice truck strong enough and comfortable enough to pull it. That makes me happy cause I can always find a nice trailer to haul Cubs with after :D Em likes the Silverado too :lol:
 
So as I know they all are good rigs. Considering this is the type vehicle you normally keep a long time, I suggest looking into the reputations of your local dealers for taking car of their customers. That would be the deciding factor for me.
 
I have an 02 Dodge 2500/ w Cummins diesel. It hauls tractors and also it will be used it to pull a 27' RV trailer. Mileage and ride are very acceptable to us.
Berlin
 
Just Fords for me I have and had 3 diesels 1 F-350 and 2 F-250's all stick and 4WD , excellent trucks imop, but there all good, my dream truck is an F-350 with a Cummins good engine better than the Power Stroke too bad there stuck in a Dodge :lol: :lol: ...
 
Jackman":i32f1o23 said:
Just Fords for me I have and had 3 diesels 1 F-350 and 2 F-250's all stick and 4WD , excellent trucks imop, but there all good, my dream truck is an F-350 with a Cummins good engine better than the Power Stroke too bad there stuck in a Dodge :lol: :lol: ...

dream truck a dually, or single
 
I wouldn't buy a new diesel until the Big Three figure out how to best meet the particulate emission standards. Urea tanks and after burners along with who-knows-what are being added on - kind of like what the gassers went thru back in the 1970s.

As far as brand is concerned. I'm very happy with my Chevy. My brother is very happy with his Ram. My BIL is very happy with his Ford. And we all swear at the manufacturers with their inability to build troublefree vehicles and at the dealerships with their lousy service departments.
 
Dealership and service location would be at the top of my consideration list. There are two different vehicle dealerships located in the county. I voted for one of the brands.
 
I was trying to find an old posting on another site before I posted this part, but one of the members on another forum drives for a freight company. there was a similar discussion being held there and he posted that this company had done a study on overall cost comparing their trucks with automatic versus manual transmissions. Their study showed that over the life of the vehicle the total maintenance costs on vehicles having the automatic transmissions was substantially less than with manuals. I am assuming it was due to lower stress on the rest of the power train components, especially if they had a cowboy type driver.
 
My truck is way over-kill for hauling Cub's, but I love the truck. It has 145,000 miles on it now and has always been completely trouble free. (knock on wood)

It's a '99 Dodge 3500 Quad-cab, long box dually with the Cummins Diesel and 6-speed manual trans. With 4:10 gears, I really don't brag about fuel milage and shifting gets old driving through town.

Overall, The Chevy's specifically and the Ford's drive really nice...more like a car. They both have IFS front suspension, where Dodge has always utlized a strait front axle. Their V8 Diesels are also much quiter than the in-line 6 Cylinder Cummins.

For a a trouble free, tough pulling truck, I don't think the Cummins powered Dodge with a manual can be beat. It's essentially the same simple engine Dodge has been using since 1987 with minor EPA improvements. That engine, combined with a manual trans and a strait front axle really makes it a simple, trouble-free powerfull truck.

Just my 2 cents.
Rob
 
Todd W":2zz9s19e said:
I think one of these will be my next truck.
Cheap, well built, plenty of power, low mileage diesels that are army surplus.
I've seen a dealer outlet about 1/2 hour away from me, also I've seen a few on the road and they are sweet.

http://www.100dollarman.com/trucks.html
yup, but I have gotten spoiled by the easy ride and air conditioning. Not to mention running at 70mph on interstate rather than the 55 or so that most of them are governed at. Plus getting them worked on is another story, since even though they are made by regular manufacturers, many of the parts are special items.
 
Back
Top