New fuel additive that makes Cubs even more fuel efficient?

Matt Kirsch

501 Club
I was listening to the radio yesterday at lunch when this guy started spouting off about a product called "CA40" which is supposed to give you 10% better fuel economy, "guaranteed." They've got a website http://www.ca40g.com with a bunch of information on the product.

The main ingredient is this calcium sulfonate stuff which looks to be a thickener for petroleum grease (gun grease, wheel bearing grease, etc.) from my online research. Supposedly this calcuim sulfonate mixes with the hydrocarbons in the fuel and causes a catalytic reaction beyond the normal combustion in the engine which more completely burns the fuel, providing more power and cleaner exhaust. Their data is mostly for diesels, but they claim it does the same thing for gasoline engines too.

$30 a quart, but supposedly you save enough gas to more than pay for it. With these computerized engines, I really don't see how.

I really wonder what this stuff does. No way I'm gonna put it in my truck, at least not until I see some real-world discussion on the stuff, but I figure I can't hurt my Cubs' simple carbureted fuel system. The problem is, how do I tell if I'm getting better fuel economy with my Cubs? They don't use enough gas to speak of!
 
Matt,
I agree, I would have to see some real life information, other than just BS on a website.

I remember back in 1989 when I bought an S-10 pickup from a friend of my dad's who owned the Chevy dealership in town. My dad was there and talking about drilling out the catylitic converter to get a little more pep out of the 4-cylinder engine. The dealer laughed, and told us how the "new" computer controlled engines use oxygen sensors and electronic spark advance, to give the most accurate mixture of gas and air to maximize power, and by messing with the catylitic converter, you would just lower the efficiency of the enging.

Then in 2001, when I ordered by Dodge 2500, the dealer told me something along a similar line. Never put anything higher than 87 octane gas in this engine, as it screws up the oxygen sensors and actually reduces the fuel efficiency.

I cannot imagine that there is any additive that will make engines run better than they are designed to do. Also knowing how little gas the cubs actually use, cannot imagine that any additive would make much difference.
 
Snake oil. Don't be surprised if these gimmicks do more harm than good.

What this product does best is transfer money from your pocket to someone else's. If these products were legitimate, they wouldn't need some huckster hawking it on a commercial. The auto and oil industries would be all over it trying to perfect it into a standard item pushed into your vehicles without you even knowing about. Big business does not suppress anything they can market themselves.

Remember when 55 mph was the national speed limit? The best way to achieve 10% increase in fuel economy is to take your foot off the gas pedal. My experience on the American highways is folks won't become conservative with fuel consumption until gasoline becomes a scarce commodity like the shortages we experienced 30 years ago. They'll gripe about the price yet keep on truckin', pedal to the metal, as though they have no direct control over their money.
 
Matt Kirsch":2eqng11k said:
Supposedly this calcuim sulfonate mixes with the hydrocarbons in the fuel and causes a catalytic reaction beyond the normal combustion in the engine which more completely burns the fuel, providing more power and cleaner exhaust.

OH NO! Wait till the greenies find out about it. More complete combustion leads to more of the dreaded CO2. :( I hope they can keep it a secret from algore.
 
This was inevitable. "New" Diesel fuel has less sulphur than "old" Diesel fuel. So some huckster has to come up with a product that sounds like it will make new Diesel more like old Diesel (and therefore automaticly "better" in the minds of a few). Strikes me as about the same as "lead substitute".
 
Lurker Carl":2u7z8v09 said:
Remember when 55 mph was the national speed limit? The best way to achieve 10% increase in fuel economy is to take your foot off the gas pedal. My experience on the American highways is folks won't become conservative with fuel consumption until gasoline becomes a scarce commodity like the shortages we experienced 30 years ago. They'll gripe about the price yet keep on truckin', pedal to the metal, as though they have no direct control over their money.
I have done a little experimenting this spring with my new F150 (8200GVW package). Dropping from 70 to 60 increases my gas mileage by 20%. I can afford the extra hour and 10 minutes a 500 mile trip takes to save that much.
 
Just so you guys don't get the wrong idea, this wasn't a commercial. This stuff isn't advertised anywhere. It was a radio talk show and the host was interviewing the marketing guy.

I figure, if it worked, it wouldn't exist. Gas is too much of a cash cow. Why would you cut your sales by 10% to sell a product with 1/4 the profit margin?

On a gas engine:
1. It takes a certain engine RPM to maintain a certain speed.
2. The engine pulls in a certain amount of air at that RPM.
3. The engine computer applies a certain amount of fuel based on that amount of air.
 
Recent TV news story about "E10" fuel offered in a few places. The broadcast said that it was suitable for all vehicles- probably true for gasoline engines. Said that it offered increased fuel economy- probably true for only a few special cases. The BTU content of a gallon of E10 would be less than a gallon of gasoline. If the E10 is 91 octane ( I do not know) and the gasoline is 87 octane, some higher compression engines might experience better fuel economy with the higher octane- but a Cub would certainly not do so. I had a car that would run well on 87 because of the knock sensors which adjusted the ignition timing. It ran better (more power, more fuel economy) on the manufacturer-recommended 91 octane and actually operated at less cost per-mile with the 91 octane. Be very skeptical of such stories.
 
I have read forums about making your on fuel catylist. Some of the guys on there seem pretty sure that its helping their milage.
 
kinelbor":2xb5z8gm said:
I have read forums about making your on fuel catylist. Some of the guys on there seem pretty sure that its helping their milage.
Probably the guys that don't keep close track of their actual milage, or the ones that start driving more carefully when they start using the magic potion.
 
John *.?-!.* cub owner":2e5mfw8a said:
I have done a little experimenting this spring with my new F150 (8200GVW package). Dropping from 70 to 60 increases my gas mileage by 20%. I can afford the extra hour and 10 minutes a 500 mile trip takes to save that much.

OK... Does this supposition carry through to the Cub? If you take the governer control lever down a couple of notches from "full bore" so that you can hear the engine idle down just a little while mowing (while still keeping the power you need to get through the weeds)... Will this save any gas or increase efficiency? Will you get more yard mowed using slightly less gas? I know the cub is a pretty efficient little machine, but would it be just a little bit moreso if you got off the gas a little bit?

Mike in La Crosse, WI
 
Matt Kirsch":2c033kbf said:
Just so you guys don't get the wrong idea, this wasn't a commercial. This stuff isn't advertised anywhere. It was a radio talk show and the host was interviewing the marketing guy.

I figure, if it worked, it wouldn't exist. Gas is too much of a cash cow. Why would you cut your sales by 10% to sell a product with 1/4 the profit margin?

If the company has a marketing guy, the stuff is being advertised. Infomercials come in many varieties and flavors, radio isn't immune to taking money for interviews.

Gas isn't as much as a cash cow as it is an increasingly popular commodity world-wide. With a few cents profit, companies can make billion$$$ due to demand. Henry Ford became one of the worlds richest men by selling millions of inexpensive vehicles by controlling the entire process from raw material to finished product. The consolidated oil companies operate in much the same manner.

"Big Oil" is eager to back a product that reduces an individual's gasoline consumption. It produces wonderful public relations and media clammor which becomes more valuble than free advertising. Sales wouldn't really drop. Consumers will alter their driving habits and vehicle purchases to take advantage of the savings = more driving and fuel thirsty vehicles to absorb the difference. Case in point, as fuel prices dropped between 1985 to 1999; vehicle size, engines, speed limits and miles driven increased to overtake the "savings" at the pump.

To look at another energy product and price, electricity comes to mind. The Public Service Commission in Maryland managed to freeze electric rates at 1998 prices until June 2006. In the meantime, the housing boom took off and builders could build very large houses that were rather inexpensive to heat and cool - at 1998 electric prices. Maryland has risen to the dubious distinction of having the 2nd largest square foot new houses in the country. Electric rates rose 15% last June and will rise another 50% next month. We will now be paying "spot market" rates for electricity for an indefinate number of years. :cry:

Be aware, however, your greedy local, state and federal officials take the largest profit from gas sales than any single entity between the oil well and your tank by far. The Maryland legislature is seriously considering a 50% increase in the state motor fuel tax, even as the price of fuel continues to rise. That will add 15 cents additional to the state's coffers with every gallon sold. Elections were back in November. :cry:
 
WisconsinCubMan":pu09wjif said:
John *.?-!.* cub owner":pu09wjif said:
I have done a little experimenting this spring with my new F150 (8200GVW package). Dropping from 70 to 60 increases my gas mileage by 20%. I can afford the extra hour and 10 minutes a 500 mile trip takes to save that much.

OK... Does this supposition carry through to the Cub? If you take the governer control lever down a couple of notches from "full bore" so that you can hear the engine idle down just a little while mowing (while still keeping the power you need to get through the weeds)... Will this save any gas or increase efficiency? Will you get more yard mowed using slightly less gas? I know the cub is a pretty efficient little machine, but would it be just a little bit moreso if you got off the gas a little bit?

Mike in La Crosse, WI

The increase in fuel mileage by reducing speed also reduces drag. Doubling the speed roughly quadruples the resistance from air. Not practical when compared to cutting grass, although mowers do operate more economically at lower speeds do to decreased friction among all those moving components. Economy comes from keeping the Cub and mower in top operating mechanical condition. A real and measureable savings would be realized if repairing deficencies allowed you to cut grass in 2nd gear instead of 1st gear.
 
Jim Becker":2gif752s said:
kinelbor":2gif752s said:
I have read forums about making your on fuel catylist. Some of the guys on there seem pretty sure that its helping their milage.
Probably the guys that don't keep close track of their actual milage, or the ones that start driving more carefully when they start using the magic potion.

I bet your right, or they dont factor in that they are adding a gallon of compustable stuff to their tank.
 
Matt Kirsch":cs0thb4m said:
Yup, wind resistance isn't an issue on a Cub :)

No so Matt. It all depends on how large of an area the tractor operator presents. Also, operator weight reduction might help fuel consumption.

No help on the Cub fuel conservation issue here.

Chubby - Eugene
 
I wonder what became of the test they were supposed to do in Butte-Silver Bow county, MT (here), and whether they're still using the stuff. Not that it would be the last word. Would still need some independent lab testing.

And George, more complete combustion may mean more CO2 (up to ~19 lbs per gallon for gasoline), but it also means less fuel consumption per mile. So CO2 per mile should at least be a wash. :)
 
With fuel comsumption my only problem is I tend to cut my grass a little longer to get more seat time because i'm having fun with my cub. I tend to go around more than once. Well as many as 3 times around sometimes. I'm cutting almost 2 acres of grass. I timed it with my cub cadet recently and it takes 60 minutes in 3rd gear to cut it yet it takes me hours with the cub. funny? I gotta make sure every blade of grass is cut to the correct height with the 60" mower deck on my cub......right?


The simplest thing with extra performance or getting extra performance out of your equipment is as simple as changing the oil often.

I put in a little two stroke mix in the gas in all my equipment every so often it acts like the old Mobil Upper Lube did. It lubes the uppers like the valve guides/valve seats plus lubes the upper rings too. It works because my cheap briggs motor with the alumium cylinder on my log splitter lasted over 25+ years and its still running with its new owner. I was told by the dealer when i purchased it it wouldn't last one year on a log splitter running wide open all the time. I just added two stroke and kept the oil clean.

When ever i build or assembly anything i use moly to lube it.

Have you ever tried using Rislone? If your motor is running as you pour it in you can hear the rpms going higher. That tells me this stuff is a better lubricate when added to your engine oil. We always used Rislone in the older cars/trucks many years ago. I should try it in the modern cars too. I haven't used it in many years.

They say that Marvel mystery oil is good too.

I know that using CD-2 for hydraulic valve lifters will quiet them up. We did that with used cars at the car dealer were i worked.

Some of these products work really good too.
 
Back
Top