Negotiating prices

Jimdawg

501 Club
My wife and I are in the market for a used car and think we have settled on a model. We've visited a couple of local dealers and did a test drive but haven't found 'the one' yet so that is as far as we've come. Our goal is to buy before December 1. Already I have noticed a few tricks the dealers are play. First there is the disappearing-car-from-the newspaper ad that 'just left the lot' but is just like this other car ( at 10-15% more $). Then there is the low price that is only applicable if you use the dealers rip-off financing. Lastly we noticed that all prices include a disclaimer that says something price does not include title/ tax /registration and dealer fees, paperwork fees, destination fees, emission fees, compliance fees, etc. I'm sure there are other tricks too. After some reading on the subject advice seem to be to negotiate the 'out the door' price, but not sure salespeople are willing to do this.

We understand that the dealer needs to make a profit, we're willing to pay an honest price, but how do we get there?

Thanks in advance for any advice you all might have.

~ Jim
 
Carmax
Fair prices, no tricks, can get you anything you want, normally below book price. Salesmen paid hourly with no incentive to "sell up". Always best to get pre-approval from your bank, before you find what you want. Then it is a simple phone call and you are on your way.

Daughter bought a '07 Lincoln MKX best car buying experience I have had, and I use to sell new and used.
 
Dale Shaw":2hpg260b said:
Carmax
Fair prices, no tricks, can get you anything you want, normally below book price. Salesmen paid hourly with no incentive to "sell up". Always best to get pre-approval from your bank, before you find what you want. Then it is a simple phone call and you are on your way.

Daughter bought a '07 Lincoln MKX best car buying experience I have had, and I use to sell new and used.

Hmm....I will have to keep that in mind. Closest Carmax to me is about 2 hrs. away but may be worth a look-see. My faithful pickup has almost 210,000 miles and though I don't want to part with her, it's a reality I will one day face.... :(

My wife and I bought our first new car together in 2008, literally took delivery Christmas Eve of that year. There's some good buyer's resources on Edmunds.com and other places. One thing they always do is ask you what you want your payment to be before you ever get a price. So when I told the salesman to figure me a price and then we'd talk financing, that nearly broke his brain...

In my limited experience, the dealer financing around here hasn't really been any worse than going out and getting it yourself, at least in terms of interest rates.

Al
 
Al, it is ALWAYS a benefit to them to provide your financing.

When they Sell you a payment rather than a car, there are soo many ways they can make extra money for the salesman and the dealership.

We did buy a car on payment once. Not a price. We got lucky that the bank would not approve the term, and they had already sold our trade. We got the car for the same monthly payment, but 6 months were removed from the term of the loan. Big savings on a nice used DeVille.
 
The nearest carmax right now is three hours from my home, but a new store is opening 45 minutes away this month. If it opens before we buy, we'll check it out.
 
First figure out how much you want to pay for the model you want. Put a limit on the amount you want to spend. Look at the kelly blue book prices and the local news paper to get an idea on the price of what you want. You need to research before you go buying to plan your game.

Find the dealer who has the car then haggle the price and start with a very low offer. Go slow and play the game.

I went looking for a new car in my work clothes, i put my kids in ripped play clothes too. After working for the car dealers which are lower than slime i learned to play my game on them.

Many years ago the dealer had a new $4495 car which was on sale for $3750. Of course when i asked all of the $3750 cars were sold out and i'd have to order a $4495 car. After some haggling i walked out with a new $3605 car that was the same as the $4495/$3750 car too. Funny i walked in offering to pay $3750 and walked out paying only $3605.

I also go shopping when its slow and the end of the month when the interest is due on the new cars that are on the lot.

In '97 i went into a subaru dealer looking for a new outback. I asked the dealer if he would match and dealers price?? He said he'd match any dealers price. I pulled out a flyer from Berlin City maine and showed him an outback for $16,650 on sale these were $21,000 cars loaded. After some crying he sold me the outback and i also got a free factory option for the auto tranny. With a worthless trade in i walked out paying $15.500 with tax and reg. He did asl me if i would drive to maine for a car? I said to save $5,000 you bet i would. Having and extra $5,000 in my pocket is better than the dealer having it.

The dealer never loses money lets face it but get the best deal you can and haggle the whole time and cry too. Play there game as they play it and keep on throwing the hot potato back to them and make them go to the boss with your offers. Just don't let up, pressure them.

My daughter had a new chevy cavilair at the time and her monthly payments were $250 on it. She want a new mitsubisi spyder convertible. I have the dealer begging me to make this how can he deal happen. It was the end of the month and sales were slow. She traded in her chevy and the payments stayed at $250 a month, the amount of payments stayed the same and she got a dvd changer thrown in for free to make the deal. I did my best haggling.

Never show any body english or facial expressions too this give them a heads up they got you hooked. Stay calm and cool the whole time. Never tell them what you want to pay keep them hanging when they ask you and change the subject. Make them change there offer many times. Read there body english and know what there thinking.

The old haggling is a lost art....never pay what they want. Pay what you want to. Just tell them thats too much for my budget constantly and make them regroup.

Ok i'll say that 85% of the time my game works. But there is about 15% of the sellers that know the game i'm playing.

It also works at flea markets too. I use my kids for this one. The seller has a chainsaw for $40. I haggle him to death and can't get him to part with for $20. I work him over really good. I'm putting my best game out there. He is pissed at me when i finally walk on. Now in the beginning i wanted to pay only $25 but i offered only $20 now he is mad and won't part with it for $20, my offer. I know he wouldn't take $25 from me.But he is all set up to take $25 for it as long as its not me buying it. He wants to screw me now, then I send my kid back in 10 minutes with $25 and he sells it to my son. I got it for my price of $25. He thinks he beat me and made $5 more. Outwit / outsmart.....play the game. Its really the Sting in a small scale. You can work over the flea markets too by haggling.

Soon the haggling and playing the game becomes more fun than the purchase. Sometimes if your going to make a foolish low ball offer to start the game of haggling showing the exact amount of cash fanned out can make the purchase right away too. Never show your whole bankroll. I seperate my cash by putting a little in each pocket. But one pocket will have my silly low ball offer in it. If my low ball offer isn't accepted i will take out another $10 or $20 to add it to the fan. Unless he gives me his bottom final offer on what he will take. Trust me seeuing the green being offered gets the seller exceited about making a sale too. This works with tractors too. Goodluck, bigbill
 
BigBill":e420pkl8 said:
showing the exact amount of cash fanned out
I've had people try that on me a couple times. I always reply with "You heard my price, you can take it or leave it."
 
My son spent some time selling cars. Have the price you want to spend in order. Don't be afraid to get up and leave. Go through your bank or better yet a credit union. My son now is selling RV s but hopes to be back working in law enforcement again soon. When he sold cars he would only make a couple of hundred on a new car but a used car he would make anywhere from three hundred to a thousand on high end stuff.
 
I bought a new car once.... I still know nothing about the process, but I helped Chrysler stay in business. Honestly, you may be better off these days with new because used seem to be pricey. New gives you warranty, financing, etc. I know someone that had a new car delivered (Swansea) from Berlin City.

Ebay can be an option too.
 
Jim Becker":2p1mr7ih said:
BigBill":2p1mr7ih said:
showing the exact amount of cash fanned out
I've had people try that on me a couple times. I always reply with "You heard my price, you can take it or leave it."

And you did not have to write 1,000 words to say it either :lol: :lol:
 
My advice, keep it simple in your own mind. I always have a price I would pay in mind, because I research first. Then I always make sure that whatever words come out of the salesman's mouth, they put their offer down on paper so I can see the bottom line to me. They can add dealer cost, add-ins, destination costs, etc, then remove incentives or trade-ins, rebates, etc. to their heart's content. But I want to see the bottom line, what will it all cost me?

NEVER buy a car on payment price, you might not even know what the total is you are paying.

I actually had a salesman make me an offer on a newer used car, trading in my own, that went like this:

" You can pay $11,000 for our car, and we will give you $2,000 on yours. But if you think yours is worth more, you can pay $12,000 for ours, and I will give you $3,000 on yours, or you can pay $13,000 for ours, and I will give you $4,000 for yours."

First time I was ever told how stupid I looked. :lol:

I asked to speak to someone with actual negotiating authority, since I really wanted the car. I should have walked out, but I at least wanted to tell his manager why I was walking.
 
Rick Spivey":2sdook0i said:
" You can pay $11,000 for our car, and we will give you $2,000 on yours. But if you think yours is worth more, you can pay $12,000 for ours, and I will give you $3,000 on yours, or you can pay $13,000 for ours, and I will give you $4,000 for yours."

That's something else!
 
I subscribe Ricks approach. I want to know the total amount I will owe including , tax , title , license , tire shine , glass cleaner and whatever else they feel the need to include. If I'm thinking 21000 out the door , its 21000 out the door , no matter what they write on the proposal . If you dont enjoy the face to face , the internet sales department is an excellent way to purchase as well . I have used the internet sales department of local dealerships with very good results .

One incident years ago. After letting the dealership evaluate my trade , and no agreement being made on a new vehicle, I asked the salesman for my keys so that I could leave. He him hawed and politely refused to give them to me until I bought from him. I was much younger then and I had my keys in hand within a couple of minutes after that moment :lol:. Be ready for this type of thing and whatever else they think you will put up with. Always be willing to walk out the door. A dealership that will treat you this way making a sale , may not be any better in the serevice department.
 
I subscribe Ricks approach. I want to know the total amount I will owe including , tax , title , license , tire shine , glass cleaner and whatever else they feel the need to include. If I'm thinking 21000 out the door , its 21000 out the door , no matter what they write on the proposal . If you dont enjoy the face to face , the internet sales department is an excellent way to purchase as well . I have used the internet sales department of local dealerships with very good results .

One incident years ago. After letting the dealership evaluate my trade , and no agreement being made on a new vehicle, I asked the salesman for my keys so that I could leave. He him hawed and politely refused to give them to me until I bought from him. I was much younger then and I had my keys in hand within a couple of minutes after that moment :lol:. Be ready for this type of thing and whatever else they think you will put up with. Always be willing to walk out the door. A dealership that will treat you this way making a sale , may not be any better in the serevice department.
 
I subscribe Ricks approach. I want to know the total amount I will owe including , tax , title , license , tire shine , glass cleaner and whatever else they feel the need to include. If I'm thinking 21000 out the door , its 21000 out the door , no matter what they write on the proposal . If you dont enjoy the face to face , the internet sales department is an excellent way to purchase as well . I have used the internet sales department of local dealerships with very good results .

One incident years ago. After letting the dealership evaluate my trade , and no agreement being made on a new vehicle, I asked the salesman for my keys so that I could leave. He him hawed and politely refused to give them to me until I bought from him. I was much younger then and I had my keys in hand within a couple of minutes after that moment :lol:. Be ready for this type of thing and whatever else they think you will put up with. Always be willing to walk out the door. A dealership that will treat you this way making a sale , may not be any better in the serevice department.
 
Rick Spivey":1gzldnk8 said:
My advice, keep it simple in your own mind. I always have a price I would pay in mind, because I research first. Then I always make sure that whatever words come out of the salesman's mouth, they put their offer down on paper so I can see the bottom line to me. They can add dealer cost, add-ins, destination costs, etc, then remove incentives or trade-ins, rebates, etc. to their heart's content. But I want to see the bottom line, what will it all cost me?

NEVER buy a car on payment price, you might not even know what the total is you are paying.

I actually had a salesman make me an offer on a newer used car, trading in my own, that went like this:

" You can pay $11,000 for our car, and we will give you $2,000 on yours. But if you think yours is worth more, you can pay $12,000 for ours, and I will give you $3,000 on yours, or you can pay $13,000 for ours, and I will give you $4,000 for yours."

First time I was ever told how stupid I looked. :lol:

I asked to speak to someone with actual negotiating authority, since I really wanted the car. I should have walked out, but I at least wanted to tell his manager why I was walking.

Had something similar when I bought my first vehicle "myself."

I wanted them to knock off another thousand or so on the prices and they were "firm." But they would add a thousand to my trade-in. I didn't care where the extra 1000 came from just so I got it....I figured it was a way to show a higher profit margin or something.....?

We finally settled on a price "If you buy it today." I told him that sounds good but I wanted 24 hrs. to think on it. I had written down all their figures, so I knew all their offers and counter-offers. When I came in the next day to sign, they tried to back up a couple steps in the negotiations... said the company's "special deal" had expired yesterday. :evil: Needless to say, I told them if they wanted to sell me a truck that day, they'd better come back to our original figures.

That dealer is no longer in business....

Al
 
Back
Top