MPLS Bridge Disaster Footage !

  • Thread starter Thread starter Anonymous
  • Start date Start date
A

Anonymous

Guest
If anyone has a morbid curiosity, go to 92KQRS.com and see tape from a security camera that for some reason was pointed at the bridge. It's chilling. Craig
 
Craig, how far away are you from there? That is just awful and to think of being on that bridge when it began collapsing is just unimaginable, nowhere to go and no way to get out of it. Terrible :!: . It's been all over the news here in Ga. Pete
 
Pete: Where I lived in St Paul is about 5 miles down river from the bridge - now it's about 35 miles from here. Over the years, I've used that bridge hundreds of times. It crosses right by the U of M campus and hospital complex and about 6 blocks from the Dome. Busy, busy bridge that they now say will not be replaced until 2010 !! Just surreal.
 
Craig:

Morbidity aside.. it is splattered all over CNN and other Canadian News Channels. Em and I have been watching, and it is similar to North Ridge and others over the past decade. Our hearts and prayers go out to those who have lost loved ones and have had loved ones injured. Just to witness something like this is devastating. Our prayers are with them all. (+)

On a technical side.. and I know it is not at all likely, but I am facetiously/cynically wondering ifn this bridge was built by the same group that built the infamous Galloping Gertie up in Oregon or Washington? I remember studying that particular bridge in my Architectural/Engineering Stress Lab classes back in the early 70's.

This particular failure however is also reminiscent of the failure of the over pass in Quebec last year. They now after a year of study have identified over 100 bridges that are now CLOSED to heavy commercial traffic. That is in Quebec alone. In North America, both countries are seeing massive infrastructure problems dating back 50 years or more. Back then no one could have even imagined the advances and of course the type of trucking that now goes on, on a daily basis. Back then, most heavy moving was done via the railroad and not the Interstate and Trans-Canada routes.

Time to restart infrastructure work methinks.
 
There's little doubt that the infrastructure in this country is crumbling - big time !! I've heard anywhere from 25%-50% of all the bridges in the US have some sort of structural defect that could be problematic near-term !! This one was built in '67 and evidently doesn't have the redundancy built-in as the current ones do. 140,000 cars/day is more than I can imagine using that bridge - add to that the salt and wintertime stresses that it encounters and it's thought-provoking. They now estimate it won't be replace until 2010 !! Craig
 
From the looks of some of the video and stills that I have seen, it appears that the bridge was under repair at the time of the collapse. It will be interesting to see if that had any impact.
 
Anytime I get peeved at things like sitting in road construction at a full stop, I try to think of the task someone has ahead of him. As you guys have said, the tremendous stress put on roads is mind boggling if you really think about it. Hopefully the silver lining in this case will be to use the lessons learned here and (hopefully) prevent even one disaster down the road.

Now to make sure the government (federal and state) stays focused on truly helping its citizens in a way that makes a difference instead of bickering back and forth about nothing all the time!!!
 
Don: In response to your question, I've been listening to NTSB folks, structural engineers and everyone inbetween all day and altho the concrete deck was being patched, there was nothing being done to the steel superstructure. It's 40 yrs old but it's design was for 75 + supposedly. The NTSB guy said they take all the pieces and reconstruct it on land somewhere - sorta like they do with an airplane. He claims given the tape of the collapse and what they'll ultimately find with the steel, they'll be 100% sure of what caused it, but it may take a year or more. Craig
 
4 or 5 times the load it was designed to carry,plus poorly maintained steel in a corrosive area= splat. It's happening all over this country.Ed
 
The latest news is that this bridge has had structural deficinces since 1990. They have been working on repairing these, but on the last inspection it received a score of 50 out of 100. Apparently there is some 75,000 plus bridges like this throughout the US. Makes you wonder?
I guess, live every day to the fullest as you don't know when you time is up. A person cannot live in fear.
 
I spoke with a friend last night who's a structural engineer with one of the largest concrete construction companies in the world . He says we don't understand the term "structural deficiency" as it pertains to this situation. It merely means things are starting to appear that would signal it should probably undergo major repair/repkacement sometime in the next 10-15 yrs.
It's become a disgusting display by all the media - local and national - who are more than willing to play the blame game. It's GW's fault for putting us in Iraq, it's the Governor's fault for vetoing some recent gas tax increase legislation etc etc. Only in a Communist state like MN could the media/politicians bitch about a failed tax increase. The lines of limos that all the National folks hired would make Al Gore proud (wonder how many flew in in their private Gulfstreams ??) . BTW, there are over 70,000 bridges with structural deficiencies in the US (EX: over 1100 in MN, over 6000 in PA etc etc.) The terrorists won't have to blow things up - given enough time, it'll fall down on it's own. Craig
 
Jim: That's not accurate - it was given that designation sometime after it was inspected in '05 or '06 which put the date for action sometime around 2020. The design was calculated to last 75 yrs - obviously, the deck concrete for a lesser time. The repairs it was currently undergoing were strictly deck related. Craig
 
Craig, makes you wonder when we are going to stop handing out billions to other countries, China for example, that turn around and poison us and our kids, and even kill us with their inferior products. It's about time to stop the handouts and take care of our own, present and future. And if it takes a clean slate in Washington to do it, so be it. Just my grand standing for the day, now I'll get off the podium :? . Pete
 
All I know is what I read on the internet, part of the bridge history:

"1990: The bridge is classified as "structurally deficient" by the U.S. Department of Transportation, because corrosion of the bearings prevent sufficient movement. The classification is based on a score of four or lower on a nine-point rating system.

1993: Federal transportation officials increase frequency of inspections on the bridge from once every two years to every year. They find some corrosion of the steel in the bridge joints and fatigue cracks in the bridge approach spans.

1999: Swiss company Boschung fitted the bridge with an automated de-icing system installed on the bridge deck and railings.

2001: An independent study by University of Minnesota engineers deems the bridge "structurally deficient," but not in need of immediate replacement. (*Read excerpt of this report below) "
 
MnDOT inspected it each of the last three years and gave 2020 as an estimated time for major work to be done.
 
I agree with Jim, 1990 it was deemed structurally deficinent. Now I wonder how many other bridges they estimated major repair work to be done at a much later date??
Has everyone seen the pictures of the steel work that was under this bridge at the last inspection? There are rivets and bolts rusted away and missing!! Joints are rusted out. Beams are just plain rusty on all areas.
 
Craig: A point of interest I crossed over the Osceola bridge from Wisconsin to Minnesota about 1300 hrs today. It crosses over the beautiful St. Croix River.This bridge is said to be of the same design as the one that fell in the river. They had a full scale inspection going on by the Minnesota Transportation Department. They had the truck with the boom lowered over the side inspecting the iron bracing on the underside and when I returned about a hour later they were still at it. I was still nervous going over it. I also have been over the failed bridge hundreds of times. I guess you can't take some things for granted. I guess if you don't take care of your own porch and it falls apart don't blame someone else for your failure. Oh well at least the death toll is less than it could have been. Don
 
Back
Top