MPG

  • Thread starter Thread starter Anonymous
  • Start date Start date
Here's what the EPA says about summer versus winter gasoline and oxygenates. http://www.epa.gov/oms/rfgecon.htm

They ignore human behavior when most drivers experience even a slight decrease in energy content of fuel, we overcompensate with the gas pedal. Those small percentages expand by several times when the automobile does not respond as quickly as we think it should. Just like it's more fun to drive a puny car hard than a powerful car gently, most folks will push the pedal harder to get the same thrill.

They also leave out a very common yet overlooked element in fuel economy, rain. It's much denser than air and puddles on the road, that can put a big dent in fuel economy.
 
I've been on that site and it appears to me to illustrate my point exactly.
# Summer RFGs contain approximately 1.0% less energy than summer conventional gasolines.

* This is expected to reduce fuel economy on average by 1.0% during the summer.
* For example, a car that gets 25 miles per gallon with conventional gasoline may get 24.75 miles per gallon with RFG.

# Winter RFGs contain approximately 3.0% less energy per gallon than winter conventional gasolines.

* This is expected to reduce fuel economy on average by 3.0% during the winter.
* For example, a car that gets 25 miles per gallon with conventional gasoline may get 24.25 miles per gallon with RFG.

Now factor in the Ethanol content ( of which I don't know from one tank full to another or station to another ) and what I'm saying is at least plausible. RFG fuel has been here since the early nineties so it is a constant in this equation. The whole RFG thing was dicussed at length a couple of yrs ago when fouled plugs was a big issue.
There are many factors that will determine what any one vehicle might experience when changing over to summer blend but the gist here is that fuel mileage gain is real and has been documented from using different fuel types because of the varying BTU's in those fuels.
 
BTU difference among blends is only 2 or 3%, yet you've gained over 10%. That math doesn't work, factors other than fuel are causing the majority of the increase.
 
Carl, Ethanol content is what I'm referring to that isn't in that document. Well this is one of those things that can be tossed around forever. There are some official like tests done you can Google up and even those are very subjective as different makes and models respond very differently to fuel types. If you scan the forums this topic is pretty hot right now with many people reporting similar finds and of course many people not reporting much difference. I think you can't dispute however Ethanol content does make a very noticeable difference ( as much as 30% in E85) and since who knows what we really pump into our tanks. The Ethanol content is most likely the culprit. I get gas where ever its convenient. So there again I can't say for sure what I pumped in. My math could be wrong one time but not repeatedly.
 
That EPA site shows twice the variation in energy content from batch to batch in summer fuel than the difference between summer and winter. There is even a bigger difference batch to batch in winter ges. The summer vs. winter difference is noise level.

If you found a 3 mpg difference between 2 adjacent tanks of gas, it is almost certainly from variation in how full the tank was filled after the first tank was run out. Modern car gas tanks have pretty big air chambers above the filler pipe. Slight tilting of the car one direction or the other can make a big difference in how much fuel they will take. Speed of the gas pump can make a big difference in how soon they click off too.
 
I am aware of that Jim thats why its best to compare over time. If its a tank filling issue then it will change on the next tank which it has not. That can certainly be the one easiest places to corrupt the results. However remember I said I've been checking mileage since early Feb and it was consistently 25 +-.5 every time. So I must be topping it off about the same. And at least around here filling stations are on the level.
The best way to know exactly what the fuel consumption is would be to install a fuel flow meter. But on a fuel injected car that might be impossible because the injectors merely sample some of the fuel available at the rail ( unless maybe one could measure return flow to the tank). On the A/C we monitor fuel flow and that tells us exactly whats going on. My brother installed one on his boat so he can fine tune the best throttle position for optimal cruise efficiency. I'm surprised the auto industry hasn't come up with something to let drivers know when they are getting the best mileage.
 
You can buy a ScanGuage to retrieve and clear the trouble codes AND perform real time monitoring of engine operation parameters, including fuel consumption. That capability is built into most all OBD2 equipped vehicles built from 1995 model year to current. The OBD2 is what mechanics plug into for retrieving CEL/SES trouble codes and exhaust emissions data.
 
My bro has the auto exray brand. OBDII is 95 1/2 yr and mine is 95 so this vehicle won't qualify. My wifes new van gives you the mileage on a screen in the car but I told her to check it herself as I don't think its anything close to correct. Its a new Uplander w/3.7 and it says she gets 17MPG. There ain't no way that is correct. But she has yet to check herself. I'm not sure how the ECM derives that info.
 
A lot of cars have an MPG display, mostly ones that are intended as a high mileage car or ones that have higher end info displays. I have/had several with them. My Chevy truck even has one. You don't want to look at it while pulling a loaded goose neck. My understanding is that fuel injector nozzles are either on or off and fuel is metered by pulsing the injector. The ECM keeps track of the on time for the injectors and uses that to calculate the fuel used and thus MPG. My personal experience has been that the calculated average MPGs are a little on the optimistic side. My oldedst one with a display (a '92 model) seems to be off the most, approaching a 10% error.
 
A couple more thoughts.

If your mileage changed abruptly then stayed that way, don't assume it was all because of the same cause. On one hand, you are saying all the seasonal weather, driving habit etc. changes aren't the explanation because you saw the difference on 2 adjacent tanks of gas. On the other hand, you say it isn't a question of how full the tank was because you have the same results over time. You can't work both sides of the street. One could equally argue the diffeence between 2 adjacent tanks was the fill-up and the longer term difference was due to the change in weather and seasonal changes in driving habits. The difference is likely to be a combination of all the factors.

Way back at the start of this, you indicated that you were closely monitoring fuel usage to help decide whether it was time to buy a newer or more fuel efficient car. Most likely you will find the replacement question is determined by reliability and repair costs of your current car. At 25 MPG (more so at 28), you are already doing pretty well. Higher mileage cars have diminishing returns. If you travel 500 a week at 25 MPG, you are using 20 gallons. You will have to get something pretty stingy on gas to break 40 MPG. That still will use 12.5 gallons a week. At $4 a gallon, that is $30. Even with $5 gas, it will only save you $37.50 a week. What are you going to get into for about $150 a month that will get 40 MPG? If reliability or repair costs justify replacing the car, expected mileage difference can have a practical effect on your choice for the replacement. But mileage by itself isn't going to justify it.
 
One thing I try to do is keep my posts somewhat short and in doing so sometimes leave information out for which ( only naturally ) others try to fill in the blanks. I'm just barely smart enough to know that even by doubling my mileage it would be hard to justify a new car on that alone. I slowly filled in the blanks in subsequent posts about the actual vehicle condition and how many miles I drive to work ( 42 one way ) that make the mileage issue but one part of the equation.
Rationally I agree 3mpg increase is a hard sale. I'm starting feel there must be another piece to the puzzle missing just like the Farmall H fouling plugs that everyone said had to an over fuel issue only to recently find out the compression tester I was using reads about 40lbs. low which made the actual compression about 220lbs.
Just had a pilot tell me today he was seeing similar results. Here again just because many people are talking doesn't mean its really happening.
 
One more thing to think about, gas pumps at stations are checked by the state, but still have errors. if you always use the same one, it may have been adjusted. There is a local station I use that always gives me a little more gas on one pump than the others ( as compared when filling cans). In addition, when I filled at that pump the cans were always a little over the full mark at 5 gallons. Last week they fixed the pump. :x
 
Man OH man, this thead is sure filled with the miniscule how's and why's of squeezing the last drop of fuel for better gas mileage. None of this is gonna make a hill a beans worth of difference when gas reaches 5, 6 or higher dollars/gallon!
Why are you all refusing to get f'n mad and i mean really f'n mad at the root cause of all these BS fuel prices?

We are a democracay, are we not?
Our elected officials are 'supposed' to serve us the public 'in our best interest' are they not?
We do have free speech, do we not?
We can protest to our Congressman, can we not?
We can throw the bas_ards out of office who started this BS, can we not?
-Ken
 
Keep it civil guys. Remember the pink area at the top of the pages.
 
moparado":3oprpf7i said:
Man OH man, this thead is sure filled with the miniscule how's and why's of squeezing the last drop of fuel for better gas mileage. None of this is gonna make a hill a beans worth of difference when gas reaches 5, 6 or higher dollars/gallon!
Why are you all refusing to get f'n mad and i mean really f'n mad at the root cause of all these BS fuel prices?

We are a democracay, are we not?
Our elected officials are 'supposed' to serve us the public 'in our best interest' are they not?
We do have free speech, do we not?
We can protest to our Congressman, can we not?
We can throw the bas_ards out of office who started this BS, can we not?
-Ken

Squeezing the last drop of energy from fuel becomes far more critical as prices rise. Those droplets rise in price as well and I prefer to save them to use later. Getting mad at rising prices accomplishes nothing except higher blood pressure. Complaining is futile but reducing demand will grab attention. If everyone suddenly and permanently reduced their total energy usage by 10%, that would speak far louder to the appropriate ears than any angry voice.

Here's my viewpoint as answers to your questions:

1. I can't address the root cause of the spike in fuel costs or my electric rate doubling so I choose to speak with my wallet instead. It's personal economic stimulus package for my family.

2. We are a Republic, not a Democracy. There is a huge difference as the Greeks discovered thousands of years ago.

3. There is no requirement for elected officials to serve everyone's best interest, they are free to pick and choose any interests they wish.

4. We do not have free speech but freedom from governmental censorship. Don't yell fire in a crowded theater unless you want to test the free speech theory.

5. You can protest to your Congressmen but they are not required to listen or respond to your argument.

6. We can not throw them out of office, we can only elect new ones. Althought they can throw each other out of office, we usually can not. In my opinion, the replacement crop is seldom different from the old crop.
 
Alright, took a deep breath, drank a cup of coffee and all settled down now. :)

There's no doubt IMO what triggered this spirraling out of control crude speculation which i've outlined in my past posts. The problem as i see it now once the speculation genie was intentionally or accidentally let out of the bottle whats goin on now reminds me of the Holland Tulip Mania speculation back in the 1600's where trading speculation takes on a life of its own. If we all are willing to pay a speculative $5/gal price for fuel without even a whimper, then $5/gal. it'll be!

http://www.stock-market-crash.net/tulip-mania.htm

"Could a mere tulip bulb be worth $76,000? It is if people are willing to pay for it! It may sound preposterous, but this is exactly what happened in Holland in the 1630’s....

The name of the game was to buy low and sell high, just like in any other market. The whole Dutch nation was caught in a sweeping mania, as people traded in their land, livestock, farms and life savings all to acquire 1 single tulip bulb!....

All common sense and logic was thrown to the wind, and even scoffed at. This is exemplified by how many USEFUL items it cost to buy 1 single tulip bulb:

• four tons of wheat
• eight tons of rye
• one bed
• four oxen
• eight pigs
• 12 sheep
• one suit of clothes
• two casks of wine
• four tons of beer
• two tons of butter
• 1,000 pounds of cheese
• one silver drinking cup.

Mind you, these valuable items COMBINED only equaled the value of 1 tulip bulb! The modern day value of these items is over $40,000!...."

-Ken
 
The tulip mania reminds me of the current "crisis" with the housing market where folks were reselling houses for profit or purchasing properties far more expensive than they could afford, treating real estate as leveraged investments rather than permanent shelter. Energy isn't that same kind of bubble, it isn't being bought and resold it at the retail level, it's being consumed. There is speculation in the production and wholesale markets but we, as consumers, aren't part of that except as the final buyer. This is why a concerted conservation effort is key to disrupting this speculative market; when demand drops, supplies rise and prices moderate.
 
I can say for certain that my wife and I have joined the "conservation ranks" with our driving habits. My wife drives a "grocery-getter" Dodge Minivan. It is very efficient at what it does (hauling three kids around) but it gets so-so gas mileage. My Pathfinder gets crappy gas mileage as well. My wife has been not using the car any more than she absolutely has to as of late. The kids have been walking to school, and my wife does most of her daily work by walking or riding a bike (with a kid trailer behind it) to the stores that she needs to go to. We live in the city, and I must say that it does make it more convenient than I am sure it is for you folks who live out in the country. Today, for example, the van hasn't been out of the driveway...not a drop of gas wasted or used.

For my part, my Pathfinder gets me to work and sits in the office parking lot all day. I bring my lunch with me, and just go outside and sit and eat it in the sun.

I agree totally with Lurker Carl. The prices of gas is being controlled by supply and demand as well as the US dollar in the world market. Supply isn't going to be going up drastically in the near future, so the best way to help drive prices is to take a look at our demand... Let the car/truck sit for a couple of days and reduce your demand. That is a sure-fire way to reduce costs (even if only 0.10 per gallon...)...

Big Daddy Government is NOT the way to take care of this problem...

Mike in La Crosse, WI
 
Back
Top