Pat:
Well put.
I guess I sometimes let some of my feelings carry me away. For years after I retired from the military, I was involved with apprenticeship and retraining through the provincial government. I got a little help with their salaries, they got learnin... Em and I discussed at length a program that we were approached by the province to enrol in.... retraining/re-integration of low and medium secruity parolee's. Some of them were pretty good, some not so hot. But I will say this, they all wanted a second chance. And if I was healthy enough to still have my business, I would still be doing it. It is worthwhile and it does work in many cases, but again not all.
I have no problem with a second chance, or even a third chance, however there are a few places that I draw the line..
1. Looters - valid point guys, and one Em has driven home and one I agree with -- when faced with a natural disaster, many parents will go to great lengths and do things they would never normally do in a normal situation. They could and in this case did break into stores to get food for their kids.
That is not ok but it is understandable... Em and I both agree... however, we would have gone one step further. We would have left our name, address and other pertinent info, with a promise to make good for what we borrowed at the time, as soon as we could get access to our bank and such. IT STILL IS NOT RIGHT - however, I would if I had to, to feed my kids.
As far as taking TV's, stereos, tires and all kinds of other stuff -- it is JUST PLAIN STEALING - period. And for that they deserve to be punished. Even if it is just their own conscience that will bother them until they do the right thing, fine. But, it is stealing and they are responsible for their actions. btw, these people were caught on camera doing it - live on CNN and other networks, they admitted to it, they were proud of it.... something wrong there... and just a thought... even though this was commited in the US, I will be paying for these crimes. Stealing costs companies billions every year. Those costs have to be recovered. So, I get to pay higher costs because some joker wants something for nothing. Whether it is somebody in the US, Canada or Europe - WE ALL pay for it in increased costs. That isn't right.
As for the rest of the scum... and these are the ones I was alluding to and not those trying to feed their families, well I have very strong feelings.
2. If you KILL someone intentionally, and not to protect your own life, then you are a criminal and you must be punished. The Lord sayeth ' Thou shalt not Kill -- or as a better translation of the old Hebrew - Murder".
3. If you kidnap, abduct. rape, abuse or in any way harm a child, you are a criminal and you must be punished.
4. If you kidnap, abduct, rape or abuse a woman, in any way, you are a criminal and you must be punished.
5. If you traffic in illegal substances, you are a criminal and you must be punished.
6. If you commit terrorism, you are a criminal and you must be punished.
7. If you commit armed robbery etc., then you are a criminal, and you must be punished.
Now, there are varying degrees of punishment.
Do I believe in the 3 strikes you are out? Not a chance. That is idiotic.. 3 speeding tickets and you go to prison? Not! Rob a store 3 times and you go to prison for life - no - a little harsh. But you MUST pay for your crimes, if you break societies laws, then you must be punished. If you break God's laws, you must be punished. This is the way the world works.
There are different approaches. Some work and some don't work so well.
1. Community sentencing and alternative justice - does work in some areas.
2. Tribal councils - native justice through a healing circle does work. Surprisingly it works very well, and it is something we should look at as an alternative.
3. Community service - definitely should be used in non-violent offenders sentencing as well as white collar crimes etc. People must become aware of just who it is they are hurting.
The MAN, just doesn't exist, it was a cop out in the 60's and 70's. it is a cop out now and it will always be a cop out.
Got a question? Do you think John Fitzgerald Kennedy would have become President of the United States and his brother Robert F. Kennedy would have become the Attorney General, if their father Joseph Patrick Kennedy has been caught and found guilty of rum running back in the 30's??? That was illegal, (see item #5 above) and many people went to jail for it. The only ones who didn't were the ones who paid of the right people, made sure that the juice was passed around. This is real history... factual and documented. JP was one of the most successful of the rum runners between Canada/ Newfoundland and the US..
Pat, what you have done with that young man is commendable, however, it doesn't always work. In his case it has, and I would expect that the last 2 years must be taken into consideration during his sentencing.. however, that does not abrogate his obligation to society, to those he hurt and most of all, to himself. Remember, punishment is not only a metteing out of penance, but it is also meant to invoke personal responsibility for ones actions.
People can and do make mistakes, we all do, and sometimes some of us make major blunders that will follow us for the rest of our lives. But do we have the right to expect a slap on the wrist and a don't ever do that again? NO, we must accept responsibility for our actions, that is what makes us civilized. That is what makes democracy safe.
Hey, I live in an area where the crime rate is almost non-existant. I think we have had 2 homicides in the last year and a half. We have a few B&E's, a couple smash and grabs and minor stuff like that. We are relatively crime free. However, the biggest criminal element that we have are drug traffickers.. everything from weed, hash, oils to PCP, Dillaudid, Heroin, Oxy-contin and all the inbetween stuff. We just had a bust for over $800,000.00 US in marijuana plants. These jokers need to go to jail for a very long time.
Do I believe that one should go to prison for tokin on a joint. No, the only ones they are harming are themselves. Do I believe that one should go to jail for a very long time for being a trafficker? You Betcha bottom dollar I do. These people are criminals. They live off the avails of crime.
Do I believe that prostitution is a crime? No, I am more European in that regard.. also, it is the worlds oldest profession. I believe that they do provide a requirement and whilst they are doing so, then there is likely less rapes etc. Do I believe that a pimp belongs in prison - you betcha bottom dollar I do, mostly cause these guys really are scum... they are the dregs of society...
But that is just my opinion...don';t get me started on prison wages or welfare either... I gots me pretty strong ideas on that too... but it all goes back to responsibility...
one last comment -- I take very seriously the Gospels and I am a devotee of the parables about Calvary. When Christ was crucified, he was crucified with 2 criminals; -- murderers. Barabas was repentant and Christ forgave him and promised him eternal life. The other, laughed and belittled Barabas and Christ -- I think he got Life in Hell.... something to live by I think....and it applies to all of us.
Guys, thanks for letting me once again mount my
Carm, I hope you got the laptop... :roll: :lol: :lol:
I really enjoy these types of discussions. They can be very thought provoking.
Well put.
I guess I sometimes let some of my feelings carry me away. For years after I retired from the military, I was involved with apprenticeship and retraining through the provincial government. I got a little help with their salaries, they got learnin... Em and I discussed at length a program that we were approached by the province to enrol in.... retraining/re-integration of low and medium secruity parolee's. Some of them were pretty good, some not so hot. But I will say this, they all wanted a second chance. And if I was healthy enough to still have my business, I would still be doing it. It is worthwhile and it does work in many cases, but again not all.
I have no problem with a second chance, or even a third chance, however there are a few places that I draw the line..
1. Looters - valid point guys, and one Em has driven home and one I agree with -- when faced with a natural disaster, many parents will go to great lengths and do things they would never normally do in a normal situation. They could and in this case did break into stores to get food for their kids.
That is not ok but it is understandable... Em and I both agree... however, we would have gone one step further. We would have left our name, address and other pertinent info, with a promise to make good for what we borrowed at the time, as soon as we could get access to our bank and such. IT STILL IS NOT RIGHT - however, I would if I had to, to feed my kids.
As far as taking TV's, stereos, tires and all kinds of other stuff -- it is JUST PLAIN STEALING - period. And for that they deserve to be punished. Even if it is just their own conscience that will bother them until they do the right thing, fine. But, it is stealing and they are responsible for their actions. btw, these people were caught on camera doing it - live on CNN and other networks, they admitted to it, they were proud of it.... something wrong there... and just a thought... even though this was commited in the US, I will be paying for these crimes. Stealing costs companies billions every year. Those costs have to be recovered. So, I get to pay higher costs because some joker wants something for nothing. Whether it is somebody in the US, Canada or Europe - WE ALL pay for it in increased costs. That isn't right.
As for the rest of the scum... and these are the ones I was alluding to and not those trying to feed their families, well I have very strong feelings.
2. If you KILL someone intentionally, and not to protect your own life, then you are a criminal and you must be punished. The Lord sayeth ' Thou shalt not Kill -- or as a better translation of the old Hebrew - Murder".
3. If you kidnap, abduct. rape, abuse or in any way harm a child, you are a criminal and you must be punished.
4. If you kidnap, abduct, rape or abuse a woman, in any way, you are a criminal and you must be punished.
5. If you traffic in illegal substances, you are a criminal and you must be punished.
6. If you commit terrorism, you are a criminal and you must be punished.
7. If you commit armed robbery etc., then you are a criminal, and you must be punished.
Now, there are varying degrees of punishment.
Do I believe in the 3 strikes you are out? Not a chance. That is idiotic.. 3 speeding tickets and you go to prison? Not! Rob a store 3 times and you go to prison for life - no - a little harsh. But you MUST pay for your crimes, if you break societies laws, then you must be punished. If you break God's laws, you must be punished. This is the way the world works.
There are different approaches. Some work and some don't work so well.
1. Community sentencing and alternative justice - does work in some areas.
2. Tribal councils - native justice through a healing circle does work. Surprisingly it works very well, and it is something we should look at as an alternative.
3. Community service - definitely should be used in non-violent offenders sentencing as well as white collar crimes etc. People must become aware of just who it is they are hurting.
The MAN, just doesn't exist, it was a cop out in the 60's and 70's. it is a cop out now and it will always be a cop out.
Got a question? Do you think John Fitzgerald Kennedy would have become President of the United States and his brother Robert F. Kennedy would have become the Attorney General, if their father Joseph Patrick Kennedy has been caught and found guilty of rum running back in the 30's??? That was illegal, (see item #5 above) and many people went to jail for it. The only ones who didn't were the ones who paid of the right people, made sure that the juice was passed around. This is real history... factual and documented. JP was one of the most successful of the rum runners between Canada/ Newfoundland and the US..
Pat, what you have done with that young man is commendable, however, it doesn't always work. In his case it has, and I would expect that the last 2 years must be taken into consideration during his sentencing.. however, that does not abrogate his obligation to society, to those he hurt and most of all, to himself. Remember, punishment is not only a metteing out of penance, but it is also meant to invoke personal responsibility for ones actions.
People can and do make mistakes, we all do, and sometimes some of us make major blunders that will follow us for the rest of our lives. But do we have the right to expect a slap on the wrist and a don't ever do that again? NO, we must accept responsibility for our actions, that is what makes us civilized. That is what makes democracy safe.
Hey, I live in an area where the crime rate is almost non-existant. I think we have had 2 homicides in the last year and a half. We have a few B&E's, a couple smash and grabs and minor stuff like that. We are relatively crime free. However, the biggest criminal element that we have are drug traffickers.. everything from weed, hash, oils to PCP, Dillaudid, Heroin, Oxy-contin and all the inbetween stuff. We just had a bust for over $800,000.00 US in marijuana plants. These jokers need to go to jail for a very long time.
Do I believe that one should go to prison for tokin on a joint. No, the only ones they are harming are themselves. Do I believe that one should go to jail for a very long time for being a trafficker? You Betcha bottom dollar I do. These people are criminals. They live off the avails of crime.
Do I believe that prostitution is a crime? No, I am more European in that regard.. also, it is the worlds oldest profession. I believe that they do provide a requirement and whilst they are doing so, then there is likely less rapes etc. Do I believe that a pimp belongs in prison - you betcha bottom dollar I do, mostly cause these guys really are scum... they are the dregs of society...
But that is just my opinion...don';t get me started on prison wages or welfare either... I gots me pretty strong ideas on that too... but it all goes back to responsibility...
one last comment -- I take very seriously the Gospels and I am a devotee of the parables about Calvary. When Christ was crucified, he was crucified with 2 criminals; -- murderers. Barabas was repentant and Christ forgave him and promised him eternal life. The other, laughed and belittled Barabas and Christ -- I think he got Life in Hell.... something to live by I think....and it applies to all of us.
Guys, thanks for letting me once again mount my
Carm, I hope you got the laptop... :roll: :lol: :lol:
I really enjoy these types of discussions. They can be very thought provoking.