insulating a room

I am going to build a recording studio for my son in the new shed. since I have invested a small fortune in the shed I need to save some money, and have been thinking about what kind of insulation to use in the walls of the 10x10 studio. The shed has Solar Wrap insulation (foil on out side with thin layer of fiberglass, then plastic vapor barrier on the inside), and I have been wondering about filling the walls of the shed with styrafoam packing peanuts for insulation, I can get them free form some of the local stores who are glad to get rid of them. I would use normal fiberglass insulation on the sections where the outlets were mounted. Does any one have any ideas, either pro or con on this idea? The walls will also be covered with carpeting.
Thanks
 
I am guessing its all framed already, but the best thing you can do is offset the studs so there are no "short circuits" use 2x4 or 3s, on a 2x6 plate and have the studs switch from one side to the other. Then weave the insulation through it. I think regular isulation will work, but the best place to find exactly what to do would be to check Home Theater forums and websites. They will have everything you could think of to sound deaden the walls.
 
kinelbor":2bg78vld said:
I am guessing its all framed already, but the best thing you can do is offset the studs so there are no "short circuits" use 2x4 or 3s, on a 2x6 plate and have the studs switch from one side to the other. Then weave the insulation through it. I think regular isulation will work, but the best place to find exactly what to do would be to check Home Theater forums and websites. They will have everything you could think of to sound deaden the walls.

The woven insulation would be better than nothing, but not much. Ofsetting the studs, on the other hand, will help a lot. Doubling the drywall thickness would help stop sound more than the insulation would.
 
I have used peanuts and other small foam pieces of insulation. The only problem is filling the wall if the wall goes all the way to the plate. My experience was that it was a real pain to fill the wall with foam pieces.

If you do use the peanuts - use spray foam around the outlets and switchs to seal the cracks and gaps.

Since I have seen you shed. I would go with R-32 unfaced insulation on the top of the sound studio. I would also put insulation under the floor before the studio is closed in. Walls your choice - I would go with the batt insulation - simply because it would be faster to install.

Another thought. Straw bales have an R value of about 75. You might put straw bales on the studio roof. Although I believe straw is more expensive than batt insulation.

Foam peanuts in sealed plastic bags on the roof.

If the studio is not in use 24 - 7 it may not need very much insulation. - Doesn't get really cold for very long in this part of Missouri.

Eugene
 
John
based on what you have stated I would drywall the inside walls and then seal the outlets with sprayfoam to the drywall. Then drywall half way up on the outside walls and the other half of interior walls. then fill with peanuts to that point. Then drywall to a foot from the top of the wall. fill again with peanuts and then use fiberglass for that last foot with another piece of drywall. this makes a little more taping but allows you to use the peanuts which are free. If you try to fill the whole wall at a time they may jam up and bridge over on you in the wall
Ron
 
John I have seen some studios in building that have the walls at slightly different angles to help with sound. There is some new sound Deadening tecnology out there that involves attaching the wall board to metal flanges thus not allowng the wall board to vibrate as it will when attached directly to the framing. I see some of the high end houses in my area building in the Media rooms that are using the new technology. Check with your local home improvement retailer.
 
You probably want more foam on the walls on every surface on the inside to keep the sound deadend before it even hits the drywall. If that foam is fitted tight enough it might be decent enough on R value.
 
John:

In my life I have seen many forms of insulation and have assisted at times with some rather old fashioned ones as well.

1. My Gramps insulated his house with sawdust. Been there done that.. it settles over time and produces less insulation value but contributes a significantly higher risk value.. read fire trap.. Same goes with stackwall and other forms of old tyme fixes.

2. I have poured, packed, stuffed and blown loose and shredded cellulose insulation. Good R-values.. because of the air spaces.. but will settle and loose effect over time.

3. I have done the same with that newfangled stuff made with recycled newspaper. Same deal.. settles and looses more than it helps.

4. I have seen Kellogg's Corn Flakes boxes, shipping containers of all brands and all kinds of filling material used in structures.

All of these were attempts to minimize cost, provide somewhat reasonable insulation value, deaden noise. Unfortunately some complied with local and National building codes and some didn't

I would hazzard a guess that the styrofoam peanuts and other forms would provide a suitable and inexpensive form of insulation.. but will it pass local, state and national building and fire codes :?: Also, how much urea formaldehyde would be off-gassed from these products? Also, the settling rates and the resulting lose of R-value of the product would have me curious as well..

I guess this just poses more questions huh?? ..... :oops: Hope it helps though..
 
Rudi":xebnhjlf said:
John:

In my life I have seen many forms of insulation and have assisted at times with some rather old fashioned ones as well.

1. My Gramps insulated his house with sawdust. Been there done that.. it settles over time and produces less insulation value but contributes a significantly higher risk value.. read fire trap.. Same goes with stackwall and other forms of old tyme fixes.

2. I have poured, packed, stuffed and blown loose and shredded cellulose insulation. Good R-values.. because of the air spaces.. but will settle and loose effect over time.

3. I have done the same with that newfangled stuff made with recycled newspaper. Same deal.. settles and looses more than it helps.

4. I have seen Kellogg's Corn Flakes boxes, shipping containers of all brands and all kinds of filling material used in structures.

All of these were attempts to minimize cost, provide somewhat reasonable insulation value, deaden noise. Unfortunately some complied with local and National building codes and some didn't

I would hazzard a guess that the styrofoam peanuts and other forms would provide a suitable and inexpensive form of insulation.. but will it pass local, state and national building and fire codes :?: Also, how much urea formaldehyde would be off-gassed from these products? Also, the settling rates and the resulting lose of R-value of the product would have me curious as well..

I guess this just poses more questions huh?? ..... :oops: Hope it helps though..

Rudi,

Is there a distinction between your item # 2 and #3? In our part of the world they are the same thing. Settling is a problem ONLY if it isn't properly installed. Unfortunately it is sometimes installed by untrained amateurs who don't understand it and don't blow it dense enough to prevent settling, but that is not necessarily the case. In 1965 I became a dealer for Electra-Wool as manufactured by Russ Hagan and his son Kenny, two of the pioneers in the industry. I periodically took my employees to factory training programs to assure they were qualified to install the product.

Properly manufactured and installed recycled cellulose is one of the best insulations available.

When I retired and left the business I sold my equipment, but I still feel strongly that it's a great product when properly used.
 
George:

I agree wholeheartedly. But it is a product that needs to be installed correctly. Not only did I learn that by installing it, I learned it well in my college Architectural Design Tech program... theory and practical.. there is a reason for a specifications data sheet...

One cannot assume that all who install, (although many are) to be qualified to do so... sometimes it is a hit or miss.. It was just an observation.

However, Option 1 is kinda illegal.. now :!: It truly is not a recognized nor accepted form of insulation... it has been used all over the world.. usually in European or North American jurisdictions in the past 150 years, but it is not safe.. and should not be used as sawdust and other flamables have no fire retardant properties. I think a minimum of 30 mins plus 30 for the drywall is the standard :?: :?: Or has that changed.. not sure, haven't kept up with current National Building Codes..

My Dad used to sell and install celluose insulation way back in the very early 60's for Cardinal -- big name in Cellulose and Loose Fibre Insulation. There was a factory training program for them as well, as well as periodic refresher courses in Toronto usually on a yearly basis. Installers need to be very well trained when retro-fitting existing buildings as well as insulating new construction to avoid the pitfalls.

And I just realized.. I made a boo-boo... should have read lose vice loose..... and all blown products will settle in time. It is the amount of time and degree of settlement, that distinguishes between a poor and an excellent product :!:
 
Rudi":1e0ycdcq said:
George:

I agree wholeheartedly. But it is a product that needs to be installed correctly. Not only did I learn that by installing it, I learned it well in my college Architectural Design Tech program... theory and practical.. there is a reason for a specifications data sheet...

One cannot assume that all who install, (although many are) to be qualified to do so... sometimes it is a hit or miss.. It was just an observation.

It is the amount of time and degree of settlement, that distinguishes between a poor and an excellent product :!:

Rudi, Properly blown cellulose in a wall cavity will NOT settle in the forseeable future. We've opened walls that we blew 30 or more years before (for remodeling) and when the covering was removed the insulation EXPANDED! That's because it was blown to a density greater than it would settle to when open blown. I doubt very much it could EVER settle during the life of the building.

Settling of open blown (attic) insulation must be allowed for when it's installed since there's no way to compress it.

Failure by settling in walls isn't the fault of the product... It's the fault of the installer, thus my objection to the blanket statement about settling.
 
John *.?-!.* cub owner":g5xcuc2w said:
how do you compact the blown in, just keep forcing more into the cavity?

Yes, with enough air to carry it. The air is very important as well as a way for the air to escape the cavity.
 
I'd use the blown in, I walked in a stereo shop here in town, they used the blown in, you wouldn't believe how quiet it was. You could talk in there, but your voice didn't travel or echo, it was really weird. That's what you'd probably want for a recording studio. There is a recording studio next door to where I work, they have foam mounted on the walls. Brandon.
 
Back
Top