How Much CO2 Does Electic Use Produce?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Anonymous
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Nik:

Depositing it in space is tantamount to suicide... very similar to depositing it in the deeps of the Pacific Ocean.... it will come back to bite us in the butt.

There must be a solution, but exactly what it is or what it will look like is still years away. It may be our (my genrations) grandchildren who will have not only the technology, the vision and the political clout to make it happen. I hope sooner, but I fear it will be much later unfortunately.

Dumping garbage indescriminantely is what has gotten us into this position in the first place... we need to start being responsible.

A term from the Bible oft seems to come to mind when these types of discussions arise, be they about our 4 footed friends, fowl or fish, trees, savanahs or crops...

God gave Mankind - Dominion - over all of the animals, the birds of the air and the fish in the sea. What many of us do not understand is that with Dominion - comes responsibility.

It is something we should really look at.


Tom:

In many ways you have a point, but remember.. much of the so called criticism of the US position on Kyoto and Greenhouse emmisions is mostly political hot air. Joe and Jane Average citizen, would just like to see all of us clean up our act.

It will be interesting to see what happens now that we have a Conservative Prime Minister instead of a Liberal and exactly what the relationship with the White House, Congress and the Senate will be with our House of Commons....

Let the games begin :!: :shock: :roll: :lol:

Em just called down and told me Ghost Whisperer is on -- time to go get a chuckle.. :lol:
 
Rudi":1hienaa0 said:
It will be interesting to see what happens now that we have a Conservative Prime Minister instead of a Liberal and exactly what the relationship with the White House, Congress and the Senate will be with our House of Commons....

Reminds me of one of the three biggest lies of all time: "I'm with the Government and I'm here to help you."
 
kinelbor":6bs2d9ug said:
I just read through these last posts, and it reminded me of a nuclear project I had to do last year. I had to defend why nuclear power is a good option for producing power. The only bad part that I found from nuclear was the waste. Couldnt we just send it into space? at least until we figure out how to use it. One other fact that I learned was the radiation given off by different sources around us. Coal plants gave off much more radiation than the nuclear plants. Just thought I would add to the discussion.
Niki,

The Russian Federation has recently begun operating "permanent" nuclear waste storage facilities, where, for a relatively low price, they will store spent nuclear fuel (and possibly recycle it at a later point), thus eliminating our immediate need for storage and containment concern. Their offer is open to any nation that has the cash in hand.

Since they have massive areas of uninhabitable land, and have the technology, and want the money, I think it is a good idea.

I think that the real motivation behind it, though, is fuel for their recycling technology experiments. The reason we do not have any sort of acceptable spent fuel recycling in the US, is that it is so difficult to license any sort of nuclear research here, that most projects remain merely theoretical, and are never pushed into the research and development stage.

Russia is seeking to dominate the world market in nuclear fuel and spent fuel recycling. They have the resources, and hopefully have learned enough from Chernobyl to improve safety conditions.

Ultimately, Niki, if we could be sure where the waste would eventually end up, we could infact export it to space. Our present technology, however, is likely to scatter radioactive material throughout the upper atmosphere, where it would rain down on us for centuries to come. Once surface-to-orbit becomes safer, and we develop better and more fool-proof propulsion systems, we might be able to deposit this material on dead moons of other planets. So far, the best way to handle nuclear waste is "containment", and not "liberation" in any fashion.

There is the ethical question, though, of whether or not we are the only planet in our system that will Ever evolve life. We have only recently learned that life does not have to be based upon carbon, oxygen, and iron. The possibility that some entirely different sort of life exists on what we believe to be "lifeless" worlds exists, as well as the possibility that life may come, aeons henceforward, on those worlds, in which case we may be destroying the ecology of someone else's planets, even if those "someone elses" are single celled organisms, who eat ammonia, and excrete liquid nitrogen, on some frozen moon of Saturn. The universe, as we seem to be understanding it, is the very mechanism of creation, and I think we'd be wise to leave the monkey wrenches out of it, if for no other reason than "just in case".

Nuclear plants, in proper operation, release much less radiation to their surroundings than virtually any other method of electricity generation. Coal, although containing primarily carbon, can host any other quantity of other elements, isotopes, and compounds. Once you remove the carbon, by burning the coal, you have concentrated these other materials, both in the form of gasseous emissions, as well as ash. Some recent research I did on using coal ash as a soil amendment suggested that mixes higher than 25% ash would add an unacceptable amount of radiation to the soil, making it generally unsuitable for agriculture without further ammendment to lower the concentrations.

Additionally, the present use of fly ash (the ash that is trapped by scrubbers and filters in the smokestacks of coal burning plants), is to add it to concrete mixes, as it seems to add bulk without weakening the actual concrete (saving a great deal of money on other materials). Unfortunately, indiscriminate use of fly-ash in concrete leads to much higher than normal radiation levels in the concrete, and it is not recommended that these mixes be used for constructs that have constant human habitation (houses, office buildings, schools, etc.), but that it should be used for things like paving, bridges, etc, where exposure would be somewhat more limited.

My feelings, however, are that the radiation from either coal or nuclear power generation is negligable, and we need to look at the real problem with coal, being the most carbon-inefficient method of power generation.
 
Rudi":1c22mn7i said:
Tom:

In many ways you have a point, but remember.. much of the so called criticism of the US position on Kyoto and Greenhouse emmisions is mostly political hot air. Joe and Jane Average citizen, would just like to see all of us clean up our act.

Rudi,

I'm afraid that Joe and Jane here in the US, doesn't really give a rodent's buttocks one way or the other. I suppose that's why I'm writing so much on these topics these days.

To paraphrase (because I don't recall the exact words) Churchill, expressing his anger to US congress for their refusal to enter WWII: "The United States always does the right thing, after it has exhausted all other possibilities."

Most regrettably, I feel this has long been a hidden truth of the American agenda. Regarding the issue of climate change, however, I don't feel as if we have the time to explore all the other possibilities.

I don't know when exactly it happened, but sometime after the end of the cold war, the US shrugged off the mantle of world leadership in all forms. We are not, and do not seek to be any sort of model for the rest of the world. We are nothing to be envious of. Presently, in our ongoing partnership with the UK, we are simply the world's anti-terrorism police.

The point of this being, I suppose, that if the rest of the world is waiting for us to clean up our act, or in some way provide a model for the other big polluters, it simply isn't going to happen. I can virtually guarantee you that the US and China will still be burning coal after all other nations have given it up.

I feel there will come a time when the US will face economic sanctions by other nations due to this sad fact. Perhaps they will come in the form of tariffs on fossil fuels, and if the rest of the world is wise, they will use that very tactic to fund programs of carbon reduction in their own right. The US is already making overtones towards precisely that. Many states have begun their own programs of "carbon credit trading", whereby, some of the states that must, out of economic necessity, use more carbon, pay small fees to neighbouring states to help keep their carbon usage levels down.

The UN is already talking about global carbon credit programs, and I feel that this, perhaps, is the best way to go. Only when alternatives are made cheaper will the most industrialized nations abandon the worst polluting fuels. At the very least, if a per-capita carbon credit system were instituted, and carbon credits traded between governments, we could see a global improvement, even if the US and China lag 20 years behind the rest of the world. The least-polluting nations would be rewarded financially, and the worst-polluting penalized, which would put some sense of urgency on the part of all world governments to push their private sectors into compliance.
 
I'm afraid that Joe and Jane here in the US, doesn't really give a rodent's buttocks one way or the other. I suppose that's why I'm writing so much on these topics these days.

There are too many peaple tied up in causes :!: 400 cub I am not talking about you as you research and know what you are geting into. Peaple geting involved causes without thinking about all the concerns involved with that stand. Or tolerence of peaple that have different ideals. Instantaly codeming others becuse the do not belilve as they do.

I cannot belive how many peaple belive animals are peaple with fur :!: And try to give them the same rights as peaple. Never seeing that they see the wourld through different eyes and have different ways of reacting to it. That can prespective on our own lives if we take the time to see it. I had a problem here where somone was telling my neibor that she was going to call the humane soicaty becuse I did not put horse blankets on my horse. Never said anything to me so I could tell her that horse blankets are for for working horses which are kept warm and inside and so do not develope good thick winter coats. A horse with a blanket will not get as thick as a coat as one without one and a winter coat of fur does not get drafts under it. Not to mention you need to be there to keep a eye on them so if they slip you can untangle the horse before they get hurt. And yes I did have one that another horse loosened up the straps and my hores was unable to move.

We have 400 acers in michigans UP. Me and my dad sold a 40 to my cousin and bought another 40 deeper in the woods. For him it is a sin to cut down a tree. Any tree :!: Has no idea of a first or second generation forest and the differences between them. Forget about thinning the woods making it healthyer. Or that a road is a fire break. and a trail makes it easier for the animals to move around too. Becides if you cannot get in to see the beauty in the woods is it really their :?:

400 cub thanks for doing the research and bringing up instring topics to think about. So we can find way to work with our wourld insead of aginst it.

Billy
 
Cowboy":2irn438b said:
I cannot belive how many peaple belive animals are peaple with fur :!: And try to give them the same rights as peaple. Never seeing that they see the wourld through different eyes and have different ways of reacting to it. That can prespective on our own lives if we take the time to see it. I had a problem here where somone was telling my neibor that she was going to call the humane soicaty becuse I did not put horse blankets on my horse. Never said anything to me so I could tell her that horse blankets are for for working horses which are kept warm and inside and so do not develope good thick winter coats. A horse with a blanket will not get as thick as a coat as one without one and a winter coat of fur does not get drafts under it. Not to mention you need to be there to keep a eye on them so if they slip you can untangle the horse before they get hurt. And yes I did have one that another horse loosened up the straps and my hores was unable to move.


Billy

Billy, I couldn't agree with you more. While, philosophically, I believe that we are nothing more than animals ourselves, I do believe that when it comes to "domestic" animals, we, by virtue of having bred, fed, and purchased the beasts, have a certain right of "dominion" over these creatures, so long as they are not outrightly abused. Differences of opinion in regards to the care of domestic animals is not tolerated whatsoever by local chapters of the SPCA. I have had livestock "confiscated" under threats of criminal punishment, for these differences of opinion, and I can truthfully say that I have never abused a living creature in my life.

In regards to horses, man has kept horses in healthy ways for centuries here in North America, without the use of any sort of wintertime garmentry. It has become common practice to use these on horses with arthritis, and elderly beasts, and I think that's probably a fine idea, but for a young, healthy animal, it is pure nonsense to think it is necessary in any way.

I used to have 2 head of steer, which I fed green chop (fresh cut grass) to in spring and fall. They were confiscated for my refusal to feed them grain, which in my opinion is a choice that should be left up to me. I would cut 700 lbs a day of fresh cut grass, and feed it to them immediately. On cold nights, the younger of the two would lay upon the leftover cut grass for warmth, and would, on occaision, get a mild skin burn. Nothing that was even worth treating. The local SPCA told me that the reason for the skin burns was malnutrition, and not the cut grass. I provided them volumes of literature on the matter of feeding grass to cattle, and their ability to manufacture all needed nutrients, except vitamin D and salt, which I always did supplement. I may as well have recited "the owl and the pussycat" in my defense, for all the good that it did.

I was ordered on a saturday evening to have both steer, and all 7 of my goats examined by a Vet within 24 hours. Since I could not find a Vet that would come on Sunday to see a "new client", and I had been treating and immunizing my animals all along, and hence had no established Vet, this proved quite impossible. All 9 of the animals were "voluntarily relinquished" by me on Monday morning, with a verbal promise from them that I would hear no more on the matter. 3 months later I received notice that I was being charged with criminal negligence. I had to engage an attourney to sort the matter out, and prevent me from going to prison, and having my daughter taken away from me (they actually threatened that by telephone, and I received a visit from child services regarding the matter, not 2 weeks after my wife's death). I ended up having to sign a waiver stating that I would never again (meaning for the rest of my life) own an animal with fur in their jurisdiction, in order to have the charges dropped.

All in all, I must urge caution when dealing with animal rights people. I came very close to a legal nightmare for simply doing as I was taught to do with livestock. Additionally, I relinquished my dog, and 5 rabbits to them, as they did not feel that the structures I provided were adequate, even though they were less than 1 year old, and were freshly shingled and painted. (In the case of the dog house, the entrance hole was too large, they contended. In the case of the Rabbit hutch, the hutch size was too large to provide the animals with sufficient warmth retention, was their claim.)

In retaliation, on the morning of the confiscation, I forced them to take an old 75 lb male turkey of particularly mean disposition, who was a pet of mine. They do not consider birds to be "animals", and hence have no regulations regarding them. I, however, told them that since they had essentially put me out of the animal business, the least they could do was to take the last of the lot. He greatly resented being picked up, and was never de-beaked, and thus, his bite was quite severe. He could neither run, nor fly, so his defense was to fight. I refused to assist with the abduction, so I watched out the window as they lost control of the turkey, and were badly bitten trying to capture the animal. When they presented me the papers of "voluntary relinquishment", I noted that their gloves were tattered, and that their hands were bleeding here and there. It did not compensate me for the ill-treatment at their hands, but it did make me feel a little better.

When the SPCA sends their monthly "appeals" for donations, I tend to use them as toilet paper.
 
Ljw I like that term "talking heads" ain't it the truth :!: Peaple making decisions on on what other peaple say regardless of any facts or facts taken out of contex.

Yesterday I had a 8hr HASMAT class (hasazard material handling as safty). To stay current with my certifaction I have to do one every year if I miss a year I have to take the forty hr class agin. This year they have started somthing new DSW disaster site worker course. Because it covers a lot of the same materials it has been given equality to the hasmat. So we were given the first class of DSW. And given a overview of structal collapses. CBRNE agents / chemical/ biological/ radiation/ nuclear/ explosives. Incident command/Unified command systems and how they will work on a disaster site. Biological agents and their symptoms and how to identify them. Dirty Bombs which may only be regular explosives pacted with radio active materias so the are dispursed by the explosion. And how far our country has come since 911 to making a national responce for disasters weather natural or terriost. Our training center has setup a collapsed structure for the fire dept. So the fire dept, police and heavy equ operators can get used to working to gether. And what we can do and our limitations, hand signals etc. To be efficant and safe on disaster search and rescue operations.

Rudi there are a lot of holes out west where they dug it up I guess we need to put it back when we are done.

Tom its a shame that other peaples dis-knolage (ingorance) hurts us and our lifestyle. After all grain is just a high proteen food which will add weight faster. All my horses extra vitimens and minerals are in the salt block. I give him grain in the winter to balence his weight and keep him warm. And give him a very little grain in the summer as a treat. But they do not need it. The mare I traded for my cub. Which I wanted to get rid of becuse she was a kicker could not handle oppen pasture and was a good 200 pounds overweight without any grain. She had had a sore on her neck since I bought her (5 years till I move in here) once she got on oppen pasture no grain it went away.

Billy
 
Cowboy":1perl2hn said:
The mare I traded for my cub. Which I wanted to get rid of becuse she was a kicker could not handle oppen pasture and was a good 200 pounds overweight without any grain. She had had a sore on her neck since I bought her (5 years till I move in here) once she got on oppen pasture no grain it went away.

Billy

Billy,

Sounds like a case of Equine diabetes, actually. Not really uncommon in overweight animals (like me.... :twisted: ) Switching her to the lower-carb pasture would have reduced her blood sugar naturally, and allowed the sore to heal up. Had that with a cat once. We switched her to canned fish (tuna and salmon) and her skin problems cleared up as well. Had you started feeding that mare molasses, she probably would have had even more symptoms.

It's not difficult to treat animals with problems, unless they are gravely ill, and the cause is not apparent. In an area with few Vets, everyone up here always had a copy of the Merck Vetrinary Manual on their bookshelves, and Agway, the local feedstores, and TSC carried all the medications and vaccines you needed.

I've also used insulin (the human variety) to "put down" old or sick animals humanely, without scaring them. They'd just go to sleep with their heads on my lap.

Of course, I'm an idiot, and don't know what I'm doing, so therefore I shouldn't own animals.
 
Rudi":1engsedv said:
Guys:

I agree completely with George on this point and Larry and Brent....

Wow :!: Pretty interesting commentary. Too bad our politicians don't listen as well as they yak......

Tom, George, Rudi, et al,

Anyone who listened to the State of the Union Speech.

And you think our politicians don't listen, especially the leader of the free world? Isn't this absolute proof that Mr. Bush does lurk on the Farmall.com website. Tom, he feels your pain!! Although I didn't hear too much about the CO2 levels, the zero emission coal plant, wind energy, and "safe, clean nuclear plants" did ring true with our previous discussions.

Seriously, it was interesting that the topic was discussed during his address. And there are people that can agree or disagree about the various issues of the day, and the different ways to address these issues. The key thing is that the energy issue and the problems with oil dependency were brought to the US and the rest of the worlds attention.

And it really made me think. What guests are really lurking in the shadows, and is Tom really who he says he is????? :shock:

*urds of wisdom from Larry
 
Larry:

Good Point!

Now you will probably have us all wondering... Who is Tom -- REALLY :!: :?: :idea: :roll: :lol: :lol:

Missed the SotU speach.. kinda busy trying to understand Wireless Networking, Keys, Encryption and other ephemeral issues of the ether world....

Tom! what say you good sir!?
 
ljw":1uhev702 said:
And it really made me think. What guests are really lurking in the shadows, and is Tom really who he says he is????? :shock:

*urds of wisdom from Larry

Funny, I don't ever remember saying who I was in the first place... :shock:

It would be nice to think that someone actually does pay attention to our rantings here, we being a group of generally conservative, grassroots kinda people. It would do the government good to review the posts in "Way, Way, Way Off Topic" in an effort to keep their fingers on the pulse of "everyday folks" like us.

I think that Mr. President has merely taken his head out of the sand on this issue, much as I have recently done. One thing that scares me, though, is that Mr. President only addresses things when he absolutely has to. This makes me wary that he is being advised that things are as bad as I'm afraid they are. The logic to this is that he does not wish to be seen by posterity as "the one who knew the truth, but did nothing."

I think that if he is able to streamline the NRC and the DOE enough to make the process of nuclear power plant licensure "cheap and easy", it will be sufficient to draw investment into this industry once again. The UK is putting its faith in nuclear power to get itself out of their CO2 pollution problem, and, where the UK goes, the US is seldom far behind. France already produces most of its power by Nuclear plant. Germany has decided to scrap its nuclear power program, for various reasons, most of which have to do with the bulk of the plants being of Pre-Cold-War East German design. Germany has a lot of its own demons to contend with, and I don't envy them one bit, in fact. Now, with an East-German-born, Catholic, female chancellor (a first for all three of those qualities), I'm sure that things will be viewed from a different perspective, at least.

As far as any connection to Mr. Bush, I can truthfully say that I have none. In fact, my most recent connection to any seated president was with Martin Van Buren, a distant relative. His being dead the last 1 1/2 Centuries provides me with some clarity of conscience. :twisted:
 
Tom:

You do raise interesting points to ponder, many which have been favourites of mine for a lifetime.. I hope this doesn't get me in pooh, but yust meine opinion..

Germany has decided to scrap its nuclear power program, for various reasons, most of which have to do with the bulk of the plants being of Pre-Cold-War East German design. Germany has a lot of its own demons to contend with, and I don't envy them one bit, in fact. Now, with an East-German-born, Catholic, female chancellor (a first for all three of those qualities), I'm sure that things will be viewed from a different perspective, at least.

First point - it is scrapping it's Soviet designed and built plants as they are even less reliable than the Chernobyl reactor and they are practically just implosions waiting to happen... this is a sound move... The German designed plants are as safe as a GE plant in the US, a Candu plant in Canada and around the world, a UK or a French plant.

Second point - Demons yup.. they got the Greens and other nudninks who haven't got a clue about what the real world is...

Third point, no such thing as East German.. that was just a political differentation which was an artificial creation of the Allied Dysfunctional Ego Power Trip in 1945... East German/West German, Communist/Socialist same as a Republican/Democrat, Liberal/Conservative ... just a political stripe.

Foruth point - Females can and have been good Prime Ministers, so why not Chancellors -- Maggie Thatcher was a good one, even our own Kim Campbell couldn't screw it up as bad as say Nixon did.... some day even POTUS may be female... ooooh radical !

Fifth point - Catholic... well 90% of Germany who declare their faith are catholic... you have Evangelical Catholics which are Lutherans and you have Roman Catholics... which are just a branch of the catholic (universal) Church..

Quick trivia facts:

catholics are :

1. Evangelical
2. Roman (Pope is the Bishop of Rome -- equal to the other Bishops such as the Bishop of Constantinople, the Bishop of Damascus, the Bishop os Cyrenica and a couple others I cannot remember off-hand)
3. Orthodox (includes, Greek, Ukrainian and Russian branches)
4. Anglican and in the US - Episcopalians (that way they get to be Church of England without using the Anglican term.... post 1776 change of term)

are all catholics. Calling all catholics Roman is incorrect.

Protestants are a mis-nomer when discussing Evangelicals. Luther protested the abuses in the Church, he did not invent Protestantism.. if one is to get the credit for that, then it should most likely devolve to Zwingli and Calvin (both Swiss catholics who disagreed with Rome btw)...

And for clarity, this is not to foment any argument on faith, this is just clarification of definitions.. period. Faith is good, faith is personal, faith belongs to each one individually, no matter what that faith is... be it in Creationism, Evolution, or any other form...
 
Rudi":473dgam9 said:
Tom:


First point - it is scrapping it's Soviet designed and built plants as they are even less reliable than the Chernobyl reactor and they are practically just implosions waiting to happen... this is a sound move... The German designed plants are as safe as a GE plant in the US, a Candu plant in Canada and around the world, a UK or a French plant.

Second point - Demons yup.. they got the Greens and other nudninks who haven't got a clue about what the real world is...

Third point, no such thing as East German.. that was just a political differentation which was an artificial creation of the Allied Dysfunctional Ego Power Trip in 1945... East German/West German, Communist/Socialist same as a Republican/Democrat, Liberal/Conservative ... just a political stripe.

Foruth point - Females can and have been good Prime Ministers, so why not Chancellors -- Maggie Thatcher was a good one, even our own Kim Campbell couldn't screw it up as bad as say Nixon did.... some day even POTUS may be female... ooooh radical !

Fifth point - Catholic... well 90% of Germany who declare their faith are catholic... you have Evangelical Catholics which are Lutherans and you have Roman Catholics... which are just a branch of the catholic (universal) Church..

Quick trivia facts:

catholics are :

1. Evangelical
2. Roman (Pope is the Bishop of Rome -- equal to the other Bishops such as the Bishop of Constantinople, the Bishop of Damascus, the Bishop os Cyrenica and a couple others I cannot remember off-hand)
3. Orthodox (includes, Greek, Ukrainian and Russian branches)
4. Anglican and in the US - Episcopalians (that way they get to be Church of England without using the Anglican term.... post 1776 change of term)

are all catholics. Calling all catholics Roman is incorrect.

Protestants are a mis-nomer when discussing Evangelicals. Luther protested the abuses in the Church, he did not invent Protestantism.. if one is to get the credit for that, then it should most likely devolve to Zwingli and Calvin (both Swiss catholics who disagreed with Rome btw)...

And for clarity, this is not to foment any argument on faith, this is just clarification of definitions.. period. Faith is good, faith is personal, faith belongs to each one individually, no matter what that faith is... be it in Creationism, Evolution, or any other form...

Rudi,

To someone of primarlily German Heritage, and raised Lutheran, the differences are more black and white.

catholic, with a small c is a term for universal church. Catholic with a Big C is used exclusively in reference to Roman, Eastern, Greek, Russian, or Ethiopian Catholic Churches. Basically any church that came before the reformation.

Yes, I agree that Luther did not aim to begin protestantism, but between him, and Henry VIII, they did start the reformation on national levels. Calvin was a contemporary of Luther. He had very little to do, however with the reformation in Germany, but more greatly influenced France, Belgium, and Holland. The German reformation is a purely Lutheran matter, just as the English reformation is a purely Henrician matter.

Despite having ruled the Holy Roman Empire in the name of Roman Catholicism for a century and a half 400 years before, my family fled to Pennsylvania in the 1690's during the first wave of German emmigration to the colonies that would become the US, fleeing religious persecution by the Catholic (Big C) Church. Enough of my ancestors have been burned at the stake that I have some lingering distaste at the thoughts of Lutherans being called Catholics, although, in all honesty, I am not really a Lutheran anymore.

Likewise, to the 3 Generations born in the German Democratic Republic, they very much considered their identity to be East German. I realize that it was a political partition, but it was an Iron clad one, at that, with industries being divided, and the East German Economy being "Sovietized". It has taken many years for the East Germans to consider themselves Germans again. Only a handfull of the very oldest citizens remember what it was like to be a unified nation, and then, the memories are not good. Any German in the world will tell you that re-unification was a dream of all Germans, but not necessarily a good one.

Let me relate a little story to you about the Carl Zeiss Works, in Jena (part of East German Prussia):

Immediately following the soviet occupation of Prussia, the Zeiss-Ikon camera works, and the Carl Zeiss optical works, at that time, the most advanced in the world, were packed up onto railroad cars, and shipped to Kiev Ukraine. After 2 years of unsuccessfully being able to reassemble the production lines, they were returned to Jena, to be reassembled by the surviving employees of Carl Zeiss. 4 Years later, cameras began coming off the production lines, but the Soviet-supervised production failed to keep quality control at pre-war levels, and the products soon gained international renown for being mechanically inept. The Soviets, having learned the method for making coated lenses from Carl Zeiss Scientists, began producing coated lenses based on Zeiss technology at the optical works in Kiev, where they became immediately accepted worldwide for their quality, while the true owners of this technology, in East Germany, continued to produce inferior products through the 1980's.


A sister company in West Germany, Zeiss Ikon Stuttgart also produced cameras and lenses, but while the quality was supreme in the world, through the 1950's and 60's, it was often lagging in technological breakthroughs, due to limited finances.

My point here being, that you can say that nuclear power plants were designed by the soviets, but, as with most high-technology, it came to the soviets onboard trains heading out of Germany during the occupation, just as we took missile scientists like Werner Von Braun, whom my father worked with extensively at Redstone Arsenal in Alabama. The soviets may have decided when it was "safe enough for production", but the designs came from Germany (dare I say East?) to be sure.

By whatever label you wish to call it, East Germany WAS East Germany, although not sovereign, and subject to heavy soviet influence, it certainly was not West Germany during those years.

I would never imply that a woman head of state was inferior, Rudi. I was simply implying that a different viewpoint would have to be taken by the first female chancellor of the German State.

So, in case my previous statement had misled anyone, let me clarify it:
Angela Merkel, by being the first female Chancellor of the German state, is also the first Roman Catholic Chancellor of the German State since the Chancellory was created in the 1880's by Wilhelm I, the first Chancellor being Otto Von Bismarck, A Prussian Lutheran. Ms. Merkel is also the first Chancellor of the German State to be born in what WAS the German Democratic Republic, during the late cold war, as opposed to having been born in the Pre-War German State, or the Federal German Republic, as her recent predecessors have. These three firsts should give her a unique, and by no means do I imply by that any negativity whatsoever, outlook upon her own nation, and the matter of international relations.

I hope this clarifies things somewhat.
 
As an addendum to previous post:

It occurs to me that perhaps recent concillatory measures between the Evangelical Lutheran Church and the Roman Catholic Church have blurred the line between the two, somewhat. I am aware of the growing cooperation between the two, just as Rome has been making Concilliatory gestures towards Byzantine Catholicism.

This, however, does not lend credence to calling Evangelical Lutheran churches Evangelical Catholic, as the phrase in the Lutheran Creed : "Holy catholic Church" is spelled with the small c, and is, on occaision, for those congregations who are weak of heart, replaced with the phrase "Holy Church of God" As long as catholic retains it's lowercase spelling, there are no crucifixes, and "Luther's small Catechism" is still used, I will continue to recognize the difference, for the memory of the thousands who died for that very (albeit small by today's standards) difference.

As for Luther, he aimed at having the Mass read in German, as he felt the peasants who were his congregation had a poor concept of their faith. He wanted to read both scripture and gospel in German as well. His goal was to do this within the arms of the mother church. Of course, this was not possible, as the latin Mass was read until the 1960's. After being excommunicated, he tried to reconcile with Rome, however, his peasant followers didn't want it. They started the peasant uprisings that spread throughout Northern Germany, particularly in the Prussian state. Rome began a program of hunting down the heretics at hand that lasted for 3 centuries, until the Prussian nobility accepted the reformation themselves, and put an end to this particular chapter of the tyranny of Rome.

Most of the Roman Catholic world now looks upon Lutherans as "Catholic Lite" -- half the calories, all of the taste. It remains, however, in German-American areas like the valley I live in, a simple faith for simple people.
 
Tom:

Ohhh boy... I guess I inadvertantly opened a can of worms... yes.. there is a twist there and it is related to the split cross in Worms that is blood red...

Anyways... this topic I shall continue to discourse with you if you wish, but it will be private as this is not the forum for this continued discussion.

I did not mean to attempt to foment any long debate on this, but just clarify some stuff.. and there are differences.. (see email)....

I understand clearly what you meant in your original post, and I did not mean to correct or anything, just clarify a few thoughts... I find you posts interesting and of use...

So, I shall put this one to bed publicly and continue this extremely interesting topic in private.


Prost :!:
 
I have pondered on this a bit.. and have come to a conclusion...

!. Discussion of any topic is a valuable and viable tool in a free democratic environment.
2. Discussion of any topic is a right and a priviledge for those of us blessed to live in a democratic environment.
3. Sometimes in the course of enjoying our hobbies, we share ideas, thoughts and beliefs. This is a good thing. However, sometimes we can get carried away and all of a sudden what was an innocent topic, can become heated and hurtful - - I do not want that to happen at all.

To that end, I chose to continue my very stimulating and interesting discussion with Tom in a more private venue. And to ensure that the topic cannot slip accidentally into something no one wants to see occur, I have chosen to LOCK this thread.

I do hope locking it does not offend anyone. If I have, then I immediately plead Mea Culpa and beg your forgiveness.....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top