How Much CO2 Does Electic Use Produce?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Anonymous
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Anonymous

Guest
Yes, I'm on my atmospheric carbon soapbox again, but I promise to keep it short.

I ran accross this little "calculator" script thingy. It shows you how much CO2 and other pollutants your electric consumption adds to the carbon load of the environment. It's just a general estimate, based on state-by-state statistics, but some of the figures are pretty darn scarey. New England, and the Pacific
Northwest are about the cleanest states, as one would expect. Some of the Midwestern states are downright nasty. Anyway, here's the link:
http://www.cleanerandgreener.org/resources/pollutioncalculator.htm

And this is the reason that electric cars shouldn't even be considered as a replacement for gas or diesel powered vehicles. The generation of electricity by burning coal or Natural Gas is far dirtier business than the operation of motor vehicles, no matter how much they try and clean up the process.
 
Yoy are talking of the process to make the electric. Electric motors prodduce Ozone. If you are ever around large electric motors, you can smell it.
Dave <*)))><
 
Fortunately, there are political rumblings that may lead us to building non-poluting nuclear power plants after foolishly abandoning them about 30 years ago. They will be the only viable way to produce the hydrogen fuel that has so many people giddy today. The media has done a miserable job education people where hydrogen has to come from... the input of huge amounts of power to produce it.

In the long run it's foolish to depend on burning potential raw material for fuel as we have been doing.
 
David D. smith":1tcbijfg said:
Yoy are talking of the process to make the electric. Electric motors prodduce Ozone. If you are ever around large electric motors, you can smell it.
Dave <*)))><
O3 (Ozone) is not a particularly problematic pollutant. It's not very stable in the lower atmosphere, and in time, (2) O3 end up becoming (3) O2. Lightning produces most of the world's latent O3, and a small amount of it does reach the upper atmosphere, where it is cold enough to stabilize, and ends up becoming "the ozone layer". While not particularly pleasant to smell, toxic in large concentrations, and a greenhouse gas in its own right, it is not a "permanent" addition to the lower atmosphere the way methane and CO2 are.
 
George Willer":30aqa8vx said:
Fortunately, there are political rumblings that may lead us to building non-poluting nuclear power plants after foolishly abandoning them about 30 years ago. They will be the only viable way to produce the hydrogen fuel that has so many people giddy today. The media has done a miserable job education people where hydrogen has to come from... the input of huge amounts of power to produce it.

In the long run it's foolish to depend on burning potential raw material for fuel as we have been doing.

While saving the climate from "restructuring" seems to be something of a rubik's cube, you are precisely right George. The only viable solution for the time being is replacing coal burning plants with nuclear plants. The CO2 load from coal burning power plants is nearly twice that of total motor vehicle emissions in this country. That is the place to start, not by choking the engine manufacturer's designs to produce lower emissions. The only way to truly reduce vehicle emissions is to improve mileage, and we, as a society don't really want that. When we make more efficient cars, we buy SUV's and pickups instead.

The UN also has some half-brained idea that the world will be able to curb its energy usage by some 20% over the next century. This seems firstly wrong, and secondly immoral. Once the developing countries of the world truly become "developed", they are not going to use less energy, but rather, a whole lot more. We, too, don't show a downward path anytime soon. We make our appliances more efficient, true, but we have more of them than ever. I hope to see a day when every resident of tropical nations can enjoy the benefits of air conditioning, and modern cooking appliances. Denying these simplest of luxuries to anyone is an immoral proposition, and without doing so, the world will never decrease its energy useage.

The question, therefore, is to firstly stop burning coal as quickly as we can, and start running nuclear plants again immediately.
 
I am curious how cleaner and Greenr arrived at their figures. I didn't see any thign on the site expalining that. I am a little suspicous of sites that mysterioulsy arrive at numbers trying to support their own existance. per example, I am totaly electric, with a monthly bill of $98. it says I prodice30k pounds of O2 peer year.
 
John *.?-!.* cub owner":2prnwvaw said:
I am curious how cleaner and Greenr arrived at their figures. I didn't see any thign on the site expalining that. I am a little suspicous of sites that mysterioulsy arrive at numbers trying to support their own existance. per example, I am totaly electric, with a monthly bill of $98. it says I prodice30k pounds of O2 peer year.

There are links, under the calculator, that you can use to request the data that they use to determine this. I dare say that because of the component oxygen in CO2, it looks a lot worse than it really is. It is the true carbon contained in the CO2 that we really need be concerned with, as far as "undoing" damage. Arbitrarily, to make the math work out right, if you produced 44,000 lbs of CO2 annually, you are actually only contributing 12,000 lbs of carbon to the atmosphere, or 6 tons, which is about the national average for a 3-person family for electricity production/consumption. What this means is, that for you, John, in the state of Missouri, by component makeup of power generation facilities, those being hydro-electric, nuclear, wind, natgas, and coal, in your state, it takes 6.8 lbs of carbon to create $1 worth of electricity, be it from coal, natgas, oil, or whatnot, at your state's average rate/kwh.

If you were wanting to eliminate the damage done by your electricity consumption, you would need to plant enough trees to sustain 4 dry tons of new growth annually (about half an acre of fast-growing hardwood species), or bury 4 tons of charcoal into your soil every year.
 
:? :? :? I've got to get in on this. I don't know how many of you have had the pleasure of seeing or being in the middle of a wind farm but I can tell you it's not pretty. We have quite a few within a short distance from where I live. They have taken hundreds of acres, of what used to be pretty country, and turned it into an eye sore to produce less than 1 persent of the areas power. Kind of looks like War of the Worlds was filmed here. In addition, all grazing was prohibited in the area a few years ago to protect the Brown Backed Ground Squirrel and also because of the posibility of erosion caused by the cows. In the twenty years or so that I've been driving through that area and also helping a friend with his gatherings and brandings, I've never seen one bit of erosion caused by cattle nor have I ever seen a dead brown backed ground squirrel. As a matter of fact, the hills were all terraced from the cows which actually prevents erosion on steep slopes. Ever see a cow go stright up hill to get from point A to B. It will never happen. If you ride by now, you can see from the area of every tower pad that is on the ridge, eroded ditches coming down the hills as deep as 10-15 feet. The wind machines are also doing a job on the birds in the area, Just last week two Golden Eagles were found dead at the base of one of the towers. They're not too common in this area but are around. I've sent pictures of the area before and after wind machines to the BLM, pointing out the erosion, but to date have not received a responce. I guess the point to my story is, if man is going to live on Earth, no matter what direction we go there will always be damage to the environment. We just need to balance things a little better.
 
Brent,

I couldn't agree with you more. I don't see wind farms or solar farms as being a viable method of saving our collective backsides. They certainly are an eyesore.

The only acceptable way to integrate wind power into the landscape is not to create "wind farms", but rather put the towers up high enough that grazing and farming can go on as normal beneath them. Spacing the towers away from each other so as not to create an eyesore should be a prime consideration.

Regarding the ground squirrels, I don't see them being able to live in the ground of a wind farm. The vibration and noise transmitted to the ground through the towers will surely repel them.

The only viable choice for the near future of electricity is nuclear, I feel. Not a single person has ever been killed by a US commercial nuclear power plant, but more than 500 each year are killed in coal mining and processing accidents, in conjunction with semi-natural deaths resulting from mining-related illnesses (black lung) in the US.
 
400 lb'er, I am not nearly as articulate as you are on this subject, but I'd like to express my thoughts, anyway. While I haven't signed on to the "green peace" philosophy of humans being the enemy of nature, I feel that we humans can do a lot to minimize the destructive effect we have on the environment. It appears to me that most people have radical views on the subject, and there is no "happy medium" ideas concerning the conservation of our planet. We are demonized by not going along with the Kyoto Protocol, but if I understand it correctly, it didn't include China which, in my opinion, is, or soon will be, the major pollutor of our air and water. I have stood along the Bund in Shanghai on a "sunny" day and you couldn't the sun from the gray haze covering the sky. Waste flows freely into the waters. During one of my longer trips I had to be taken to the hospital for a bronchial tube infection. That was another experience, but I was treated very well.
I agree with you that nuclear power is the future if we ever hope to achieve independence from mideastern oil, and for many other good reasons. I have always thought that once nuclear power has been established as a viable energy source, scientists could then start developing this energy for other uses. Ultimately, I think it will be used to power buildings, or even the home and auto.
I try to save on power every way I can think of. I buy the flourescent lights for the house, lower the thermostat, although I'm burning wood now, and etc., etc., etc. But I like my big truck and will continue to use it, although a little more sparingly with the high gas prices.
What should be done is to have an open and honest debate on the issue as we are doing here, but on a much larger scale.
May God bless that little squirrel, but he has to make his way in this world just like we do. My $0.02 cents. Larry
 
Some how I am glad the Sabre tooth tigre and Tyrsaures Rex were not saved from extension. The Wolley Mamoth I waver on. Some days yes and some days no.

Bill
 
Guys:

I agree completely with George on this point and Larry and Brent....

Wow :!: Pretty interesting commentary. Too bad our politicians don't listen as well as they yak....

First, Nuclear is the only viable source of power that we have that can become safer and more viable for the environment. I have been bellowing on this subject for nigh on 30 years, ever since I first saw the original Candu reactor at Chalk River Ontario.

Canada and the US built the safest nuclear power plants in the world bar none. Between our two countries we have the technology and we have the will to ensure that we can provide clean, renewable power for generations AND protect the environment as well.

Britain, France and Germany also have very safe systems. These five countries have proved over the last 40 years that Nuclear is safe.

God.. these tree huggers (inaptly termed nickname..:-( )really need to get a attitude adjustment and and firmer grasp on the subjects at hand.

Wind power is a good and viable form of passive power generation in areas where it will not interfer with nature nor with man's agricultural activities. This is frequently not the case. Wind power by it's very definition must have props and turbines located on towers in very windy locales -- usually along historical migration paths for many of our feathered friends. IT makes sense... that is where the corridors are. Birds ain't stupid,, they go with the flow and the path of least resistance to enhance their ability to migrate successfully. Ooooops :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops: there is the rub :!: :idea: :roll: Turbines/props and birds = DEAD BIRDS.. quite clear to most people I think. FOD is also a term used for DEAD BIRDS that have been inhaled by jet turbines... it is a know side-effect of blades spinning at any speed in the wind... birds get killed and it is indiscriminant.. it will include endangered species...

anyways, enough of that...

Nuclear.. and I have been a proponent of these plants. I have also been a proponent of Due Diligence in disposal or recycling/reuse of used/spent nuclear rods.

Idea 1: Used/spent rods can be recycled. We know how to make small nuclear plants and we know how to use nuclear isotopes for medical and other uses. Why oh why can we not figure out how to pelletize the spent rods, encase them so they do not emite harmful radiation and plop em into a small nuclear power unit that will propel PTV's (Personal Transprotation Vehicles??? :idea: :idea: ) -- translation = cars :lol:

Idea 2: Why can we not, after we have recycled these spent rods, contain them safely in the best place on earth :?: :?: :?: Back in the ground :!: This would sure reduce the amount of nuclear power plants in subs that have been dumped in the Pacific by both the USSR and the US, Britain and France...

I come from an area where we have over 30 deep shaft hard rock gold mines... in what is now the city itself..... there are hundreds more deep shaft hard rock mines in Northern Ontario and Quebec still. These shafts have to be filled or re-inforced to stop/prevent cave-ins and sink holes....

Be a great place to put nuclear reclamation facilities now wouldn't it :?: :?: Hey, they test nukes underground.. should be able to figure this out -- it is probably a no brainer...

The only places where nuclear accidents are real sources of concern are essentially the old USSR and Warsaw pact plants, North Korean and Chinese and now Iranian plants... these cause me worry.. mostly because these countries ethics are different from ours and they tend to place less value on the one or even the many -- more value is placed on POWER but not the useful one -- the one that gets backed up by military might..

The other bugaboo I have about all this is the continuous cry about cars and how much our cars, pickups, minivans and our ride-on/pushem mowers and our tractors pollute. Buffalo pucks!... Ever get stuck behind a city bus :?: Sorry guys -- a tractor trailer with lousy maintenance, a dump truck, concrete truck... public utility vehicle????? These things spew out pure garbage...

And now the EPA in the US and Canada is spouting this nonesense that burning wood is polluting our environment and we should switch to gas/oil or electricity... what moron thought that one up???

If anything, burning wood only adds to the environment. Forest fires are healthy for the environment. Wood smoke is also good for the environment. Returns needed materials as in carbon to the ground.. 400lbs has already clearly spoken well on that subject...

Boy.... I can go on and on on stuff like this.. it irritates me that so many so-called highly educated people can come up with this brainless claptrap.. it is time maybe some clear headed people actually were invited to the party to help.

Oh, and even though Canada is a Kyoto signatory... we ain't doing a whole lot better than the US or any other country to clean it up... we all need to get on the wagon... but that is another topic...
 
Here in France I think it is something like 70% of Electricity is nuclear produced, so we can have electric cars without too much polution.
Nuke cars, yes, but the worry about that is the regular crash possibility breaking the cell open releasing radioactivity.
Here in Europe and Russia we have had more than one person killed with nuclear elec, di I even need to speak of Chernobil, thousands fairly immediately and millions into the future.
Burrying underground (nuke waste) you said yourself Rude, there are fissures cave ins etc, that is just the problem, the earth moves, there is always a possibility that our storage tunnel may be on that fault and be crached open releasing the radioactive.
BUT I agree nuke is the way forward for less atmospheric polution.
Fortunately Rudy you didn't mention that Cubs polute when we use them, we all know dump trucks, cars, busses etc all make clouds of polution on the road, but surely not a Cub!
Pat
 
Pat, I feel that little Cubs are good for the environment. If everybody owned one, the world would be a better place in which to live. 8) Larry
 
The point of all of this, originally, was to show you just how bad electric production is for the atmospheric carbon load. For those of you who don't follow this term, we have managed to put more CO2 into the atmosphere in the last 100 years, than there has been in the last 650,000 years, or essentially, since the great sumatran volcano nearly pushed man to extinction during his great migration out of Africa. (My apologies to you creationists out there.)

This very fact alone, even if mankind returned to pre-industrial pollution levels tomorrow, will affect the climate enough to cause significant changes over the next century. We are seeing them already. I encourage anyone who doubts this to do some research on the subject. I warn you, however, that the more you learn about the coming climate change, the more frightening it becomes, so it is not something for the weak of heart.

I have lived the last 20 years believing that climate change would be something that my distant progeny would have to deal with, and as long as we started the process of reducing and repairing, there would be plenty of time for posterity to finish the job. I assure you now, that this is not the case. While many of us who are speaking of this now will not be alive to see the worst of it, our very children will.

I get angry at the world view that it is the fault of industrialized economies like the US, China, and India, when the entirety of mankind contributes to the problem at all levels. I get angry with the "tree-huggers" who cannot see nuclear energy as a viable alternative, because of their irrational fears. I get angry at the EPA, who insist upon looking at motor vehicle emissions as the biggest problem, when it is perhaps the 3rd or 4th thing we should be concerned with. I get angry with the UN's unrealistic goal of reducing world energy consumption, which I feel is like simply asking cattle to graze less, and still put on weight. I get angry, too, at Canada, who chastises us in the US relentlessly about our use of fossil fuels, but is our largest supplier of oil and Natural gas, supplying us with quantities far beyond our own reserves.

The Kyoto protocol was not ratified by several nations, but most notably, the US, China, and India. China will surpass the US as the worlds biggest polluter sometime in the next 10 years, no doubt. Having 4 times the population of the US, it doesn't particularly surprise or distress me. The US and India probably could have signed Kyoto, as both of us will probably meet the goals specified, but both nations seem to have an aversion to the imposition of outside standards upon their economies.

The real problem, however, is that Kyoto is a joke, and a bad one at that. It was designed, albeit, to initiate some degree of worldwide cooperation on the matter of global climate change, but instead, has fractured the various factions. The reductions in emissions it called for to "pre-1990 standards" ensures that the world will continue to triple the atmospheric carbon load every century. It's real goals, then, have to be looked at as closing the barn door after the horse has run out.

A simplistic view is all that is needed to look at the whole situation and derive truthful conclusions from it.

The earth, Nature, God, or what have you, has seen fit to turn the most ancient remains of life upon the earth into a form of fuel. These fuels are fossil fuels, and they were buried far beneath the earth and ocean, where they should have stayed for eternity. Mankind's destiny, as a surface dweller, was to use the materials on the surface as he saw fit, and in doing so, would never have caused the planet any significant harm. We could have cut down most of the trees, planted what we liked, manipulated the animals as we saw fit, and burned all the wood we liked, and never, ever, would we have caused a significant change in the atmosphere.

Mankind likes to outsmart the gods, though, and we dug up the planet's dead things, and used them as fuel. All of this carbon.....the basis of life on earth, and the residue of the loss of life on earth, neatly buried where it could do no harm, now dug up and turned to CO2, and pumped into the atmosphere at phenomenal rates. Of course the myriad other pollutants that go along with this, but these are only temporary things that wash out with the rain, and, although they kill man, plant, and animal, are not significant in the epic sense that carbonization of the atmosphere is.

Heavy metals, acid rain, smog, Nitrous Oxide, yes all of these things are bad, but the only things we need be concerned with, for the sake of our children's future are CO2 and Methane. When dealing with the increase of either of these into the atmosphere, nothing else must weigh in the equation, excepting the reason we are burning fuel to begin with, and that has to do with the very nature of mankind, and is therefore a moot point.

Pat, I think if everyone used cubs as much as possible, considering the economy vs. work performed, that alone would not be an insignificant contribution.
 
400 lb'er, You plead our case very well, as I would expect. I agree with most of what I understood, and plead ignorance on what I am not familar with. But it all sounds reasonable. Except, how does a person, or how can a person; differentiate between gifts that our Creator gave us to use, and the bounty that we were destined to use to improve our lives?

You being from Pa. realize that we didn't have to dig for coal, it just lays on the surface. And who wouldn't follow that coal seam in order to cook with, and provide warmth for their families? Even poor old Jed Clampett found oil using a 10 ga. shotgun. :shock:

I try never to get angry about the inequaties of life. There was a time that I did, though. But as I watch Cspan and Foxnews and CNN, I have to remember that these people are talking heads, and let me include many of our political leaders, that are spewing, verbatim, the ideals or agenda of their owners, or satisfying the needs of special interest groups. Has anybody wondered how it is that all Democrats favor abortion, and all Republicans are pro life? They worship the God of the virgin cellulose and old blue jeans. (that may be an original thought)

Every so often while driving I'll take a shortcut and go through the old neighbor where I grew up. You don't see any kids playing outside like me and my brothers had done so many years ago. They're all inside. Playing their games, watching liberal TV, etc. Why should I mention that? It's because nowadays our society is providing every need and most desires of life. Until that bubble has been busted, why should people complain?

I didn't want to beat a dead horse, I've had to bury too many, already. And I don't know anything about CO2 levels, but I may read about it. But this debate is stimulating, I agree with Rudi. And it is good to hear from Rudi again. He is missed.

400 lb'er, you bring many items of interest to the table(and I'm not talking coldcuts). Although no one should expect to receive many concrete answers. This is the world we live in, for now.

Larry

If I have besmirched anyone in this message I apologize in advance. I was just teasing.
 
Pat:

I guess maybe I wasn't too clear... my mind works in a weird way... it is ex-Navy so I take for granted that others are already plugged into my thought processes... it is a historical fault.. :roll: :oops: :roll: I plead Mea Culpa, Nolo Contendre, Mea Culpa..

When I suggested sticking spent rods back into the ground, I had in my mind facilities similar in construction to NORAD/SAC facilities such as SAGE in North Bay Ontario and Cheyenne Mountain Montana. These would be concrete, re-inforced facilities with suitable technological safeguards and state of the art handling systems. No responsible human would suggest dumping and leaving it -- we already have enough of that foolishness...

No, this would take some brains.. I am not sure who in our respective governments would be up to that task...................

As for nuclear pelletized fuel cells, again, I was assuming that technological safeguards would be in place. If we can design air bags and such, if we can design space craft to exit our solar system, I am sure we can design a safe nuclear pellet driven vehicle... without the risk of somehow contaminating ourselves.

It is my fault, and the fault of many others who are pro-nuclear fuel who forget to explain clearly and fully their ideas. It then allows the nut-case tree huggers who are against anything and everything to put an inane spin on nuclear energy. It is safe and it is the only viable future for us all, so we best get with it and figure out a way to combine all the good points from the Canadian, US and European plants to build a truly dependable, economical and SAFE plant to be used around the world.

Slow Pokes are still a good idea too for small areas.

Fossil fuels are dumb.. Nuclear is smart. However, Chernobyl occured because of a few factors... the primary one being GREED -- party apparatchiks trying to skim a lot of rubles from projects such as that... another is ignorance -- in the race to keep up with NATO countries the former Warsaw Pact nations would rush into production anything they thought would bring them parity with NATO -- even if it meant using unproven and unsafe designs, flawed operation plans, next to no technical training and other factors such as that.

Chrenobyl happened because of the state of the USSR and it's system of government with all of it's flaws an foibles. Even after the fall of the Iron Curtain, the phoenix nations that arose out of the dissolution of the USSR, were still riddled with the policies and faults of the pervious regime. It was human error -- not the fault of nuclear power....


Tom.... I don't often disagree with what you state, but this time I gotta...

I get angry, too, at Canada, who chastises us in the US relentlessly about our use of fossil fuels, but is our largest supplier of oil and Natural gas, supplying us with quantities far beyond our own reserves.

Well, you know the US is the biggest consumer of petroleum based products in the world. The US invented Planned Obsolecence and Over Packaging.. The US drives the oil industry. China is becoming a big player, but the US drives it. It is US Auto makers that BUILD gas guzzlers and then try to market them to everybody in the world.

As far as you getting mad a Canada for supplying you oil.. hey... it is US Multi-nationals that NOW OWN all of our major Oil Exploration and Production companies, along with the Brits and the Dutch... The US controls how much goes where and how much WE have to pay for our OWN Oil.... and right now I am paying $3.96 per US gallon for gas refined from OIL that actuall comes from Saudi Arabia and Venezuela, because we cannot even get access to our OWN oil.....

And we don't want to get me started on Softwood Lumber Tarriffs, or Mad Cow or pork or wheat or any of the other issues we have. Remember.. we are only 38 million people, 1/10th of the population of the US...

The good thing about this is that we can have differences of opinion and still be friends and family.... not too many places like that in the world either.... so all in all I guess we gots a good deal.
 
Rudi,

I suppose that we are both doing a little bit of back-door flag waving here. :D

I couldn't agree more with you on the matter of softwood products tariffs, either. The US lumber industry is a career-criminal, unlike the more responsible Canadian lumber companies. The moral choice would be to buy Canadian softwoods, and allow our own forests to heal for a time. Lumber here has become incredibly expensive over the last few years, in no small part due to those very tariffs that hurt both of our economies. The reason they exist at all, is an unfortunate tendency of US lumber industries to lobby representatives, essentially bypassing the will of the people in all ways.

I don't know enough about our part in Mad Cow, pork or wheat (God spare us all from mad wheat :shock: ) in Canada to comment, but I promise you I will research the situation promptly.

With regards to oil, however, I cannot help but view Canada as "The mother who cooks only rich, fatty foods, yet beats her children for being fat." Yes, our gluttony for oil drives the world petroleum market, but then again, Canada has always been there to keep feeding us.

It is not that I am angry that Canada supplies us with the oil (I would much rather have the money flow North instead of East), it is that Canada does so, while at the same time, denouncing us as veritable criminals for using it.

Canadians have always been a more highly principled people than those in the US. It is to be expected of you to criticize us. It occurs to me, though, that when it comes to the matter of your economy, however, insomuch as oil revenues are concerned, your government seems to put a price on its principles.

The pipelines that exist and those that are being constructed now to provide natural gas to the central US are prime examples. They never would have come to fruition without the complete knowledge and acquiescence of your government. Now, with the "goldrush" of the oil sands driving yet another wave of Canadian petroleum investment, Canada's government is yet again offering its principles to the highest bidder, while reserving the right to "beat the fat child" as it suits them.

In the oncoming years, it will be the responsibility of Canada to deal with the coming "methyl hydrate" release that will come with the melting of the permafrost, and the warming of the Arctic Ocean. Within this Aeons-old frozen methane, is the possible ultimate extinction of mankind. Let us pray then, that Canada's government does not merely sell off this resource to the highest bidder, and then criticize them for the destruction of life on earth.

The government of the US has no "accelerant" to change, such as the ability to enter a "vote of no confidence", allowing us to peaceably topple a seated president and congress. Our leaders last for their terms, our congressmen for generations. This built-in longevity allows for the creation of lobbying systems which financially support the candidate's election costs, which are not small. Our laws demand that our media provide "equal time" to all candidates, but, in fact, if the candidates cannot pay "equal price" for the network broadcast time, the very definition of equal time is quite pliable. It is no small secret that the US version of democracy is a ghoulish nighmare from hell. It was born in good faith, upon good principles, but has grown up into a monster, and none of us knows what to do about that. The fact that it remains a democracy is its only saving grace.

With 50 years of peace between "industrialized" nations, it is difficult to find a corporation these days that is uniquely "American" in ownership or spirit. I'll admit the possible exception of Exxon/Mobile. Multi-national corporations have always been the way of the world, but at times of war, nationalization of enterprises has returned ownerships to it's constituent nations. We have had none of that in 3 generations, and god-willing, it will not come again. None of our motor companies are "American" anymore, some not even by a majority.

I'm afraid that the only crime you can accuse the people of the 21st Century US is "gluttonous consumerism", Rudi. Our days of corporate Imperialism are long over. If you demand proof of both of these things, our estimated 2007 trade deficit of $1 Trillion US should do nicely. That translates into a $3000/yr loss in standard of living for every single US citizen. I don't think anyone, least of all me, expects anyone to feel any sympathy for us whatsoever, it is our time of decline in the US, after a "boom century", a time which we choose to spend by surrounding ourselves with creature comforts at all costs. The fat child can take a beating.

And so, in the end, Rudi, I'm equally glad that we can disagree and still be friends. Canada and the US, no matter how much bantering we do, are siamese twins of a sort, tied together by economy, culture, and so much more. While we may not always find ourselves to be allies, we will never find ourselves to be enemies.

Thus, I sign this, most respectfully, your good-hearted, but (only in type) outspoken friend to the South,

Tom
 
I just read through these last posts, and it reminded me of a nuclear project I had to do last year. I had to defend why nuclear power is a good option for producing power. The only bad part that I found from nuclear was the waste. Couldnt we just send it into space? at least until we figure out how to use it. One other fact that I learned was the radiation given off by different sources around us. Coal plants gave off much more radiation than the nuclear plants. Just thought I would add to the discussion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top