GO SEARCH says the oracle at delphi......

  • Thread starter Thread starter Anonymous
  • Start date Start date
A

Anonymous

Guest
I have marvelled at this group many times for many reasons. There are so many people among us with so much knowledge, that posing a question here, regarding any topic, is very much like asking the fabled oracle at Delphi.

The answer comes, by concensus, usually, but it comes, and very quickly as a rule. The only time the answers are wrong, are when the information provided is incorrect, or errant. I have yet to see a time when we all sat about and said "We Don't Know."

Some newbies join the group just to ask their one question, and we never hear from them again. Others become family, it seems.

There is one problem with extreme knowledge. It begets pride.

Unfortunately, one of the things I have marvelled at as well, has been the occaisional posting of responses to newbies' questions with "We've talked about this at length, do a search" or "Didn't we just talk about this a few weeks ago?" Although I'm sure none of these comments are intended as such, they are statements of pure, rude pride.

If these people had been here, and were active members all along, I could understand your discontent, but these are people new to this forum, new to our ways, and new to our personalities, which vary greatly.

When you are a lurker in a forum, you learn from people, but you do not know how they will respond to your personality. Lurkers DO, however get an idea of the general feeling of the forum, and when they do join, and ask their question of "How do I remove the front pulley" for the 1000th time, and we bite off their heads, they are not likely to experience us at our best any time soon. Most newbies don't really know how to search. Most people in general will not look at more than 3 or 4 documents before giving up their search. Very few internet users know how to formulate a "good" search query at all. They use search engines, but they don't expect results. Kinda like tossing a coin and expecting it to land on it's edge.

Regardless of how many times we have been asked something, if we cannot be more helpful than "We've discussed this before. Go search for it", we are definitely issuing statements of pride, and that, my friends, one and all, is wrong, no matter how you toss the coin.

Perhaps, if you are sure of the newbies' answer in older posts, you could search for it yourself, and find the link for the thread that contains his answer. Perhaps you could re-issue the answer. Perhaps we should all keep notepad files of "frequently asked question answers" that we could cut and paste to these queries.

If we are so proud that we cannot take the time to help, we should then remain silent, for then we are being unworthy of this forum's reputation.

I commend Rudi, especially, but also EZ, Beaconlight, Jostev, Buzzardwing and others who make newcomers feel so welcome here. It is a wonderful feeling. I commend EJP and BigDog for answering every question, even if it's been asked every day for months on end. I just felt the need to mention this business, as it seems to be increasing rapidly lately.

Some years ago, I wrote server-sided programming in Perl5, stuff which at the time was referred to as CGI. Part of my standard "contract" when working for someone, was that I was able to create "freeware" from routines I had developed while working for them. I made these available on the WWW, and at one time, was receiving over 500 emails a day asking for technical support, from people who had no real business working with perl, or server-sided programming. Never once did I respond with "I've already discussed this, go do a search." Now, thanks to new technologies, those emails are down to about 20 a week, and I am better able to give detailed answers to be sure, but regrettably, I have forgotten more than I ever knew about Perl5, or Apache web servers, and have to respond with "I don't know" more often than I would like.

I know my posts are frequently "less concrete" than those of many of you. It is, however, my approach to solving problems.

Now that I've mentioned this, you can do a search for it whenever you like.... :twisted:
 
400 You have a very good point, to a point!
When I was just starting out on Cubs just less than a year ago I was fascinated by the "Search" feature and loved looking for things, and still do, when someone has said that there is a link somewhere, gives me a challenge to find the answer myself.
It is also inversly true that I have had some very direct help from many many members too great in number to cite even one, (no favouritisms here!) in answering my seemingly important to me questions, questions that perhaps have been asked a hundred times before.
I am guilty of being "Rude" in suggesting that someone do a search, the other day I did for someone asking about the front pulley pulling, I hope that the searcher has had a wonderful exciting challenge finding the threads that refer to pulleys and perhaps has tripped over other fascinating facts in his search.
We do have a "How To" section, if it is not already there, would it not be a good idea if someone who has had a lot of experience pulling pulleys wrote up on this subject along with multifarious others, if he has time. If not we will have to exist on the goodwill, friendship and cohesion of the group tied in with a good search facility.
I hope I am not treading on any toes, only answering, 400 if it soulds as if I am "having a pop" at you I am not, your comments are as valid as mine and the other x number of members on this the best board of the net.
Pat
 
Over the last month, I only see one thread where the initial response was to tell somebody to do a search for the answer. This does not count the several where a suggestion to search was included with an answer to the specific question or as a subesquent response farther down the thread. Considering that there have been posts on over 30 topics in the last 24 hours, that doesn't seem excessive. You could find this data yourself, but would have to do a search to find it.

When somebody has a question, it is not reasonable to expect everyone that contributed useful information in the past to be available and ready to repost the same information. If you want a complete answer, it is a virtual requirement to look back at the past responses. In some of the most common and complex problems, the answers have been collected into a single place. NOBODY is going to repeat all that because another person asked the same question. An excellent example is Lurker Carl's Carburetor fixes.

The most egregious example of asking the same question over was a while back when somebody asked how to remove the front pulley when there was still an active thread on the exact question. If the poster had simply looked down the first page, he would have found a topic title something like "How to remove the front pulley?" As I recall, the answers WERE repeated in that thread. None the less, willingness to help somebody with a question is always going to depend on the amount of effort the person with the question puts into getting an answer. Yes, if you want answers, there is some need to earn them.

It appears to me to be not so much a problem of hubris as it is "You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

I'll save you a search:
http://dictionary.reference.com/search?r=2&q=egregious
 
Gentlemen,

One thing we should always remember, gentlemen.
8)
 
Jim Becker":3btk1nd3 said:
None the less, willingness to help somebody with a question is always going to depend on the amount of effort the person with the question puts into getting an answer. Yes, if you want answers, there is some need to earn them.

It appears to me to be not so much a problem of hubris as it is "You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

I'll save you a search:
http://dictionary.reference.com/search?r=2&q=egregious

This is supposed to be amusing, in a way, in case you miss the point.

Your assumption of my lack of vocabulary is amusing to me. Nonetheless (one word, not three; I even checked your online dictionary for proof ...and yes, I'm teasing you), I think it bad form to use words which are not in common usage, unless there is no other word for the purpose; forcing people to stop reading, and seek definitions, hence, breaking their train of thought, and interrupting the whole experience of reading for adults. It is far past the time of vocabulary lessons for most of us.

All of your predictably supercilious pretentiousness aside, Jim (poking fun again, Jim); holding up a sign that reads, "water, somewhere here," is not the same as leading the horse to the water, :D or would you have the horse die of draught for his inability to read the sign? I suppose horses don't put forth enough effort when it comes to reading, really, do they? Well, no water for them, then.
 
Patbretagne":2u8ozw5b said:
I hope I am not treading on any toes, only answering, 400 if it soulds as if I am "having a pop" at you I am not, your comments are as valid as mine and the other x number of members on this the best board of the net.
Pat

Pat,

Not at all......Whenever I make a post, I am hoping, even begging, for some intelligent discussion on the topic. I am honored that you replied, as always.

Tom
 
Thanks, found an online dictionery that I browsed and found out a lot more, also I now know the meaning of a new word which I will NEVER use as a description for a CUB. I can think of at least one of my tractors that I might think about using it on, and certainly there are some badly designed tools that it certanly will come in handy for.:D
Pat
 
I have had many, many questions concerning many different issues in the last few years, but have very seldom asked. Thanks to the knowledgeable people on this forum that are also generous enough that they don't mind sharing their info, I can usually find my answers using the archives. After performing many of these searches I have found that I have had to read many messages to fully understand how to resolve the problem I had, and these other messages also made me think of other issues that contribute to my particular problem. In spite of myself, I stumble on new ideas and techniques. I guess what I am saying is that after somebody gets an answer on the forum it doen't hurt to do a search in addition to the forum answer. Because there are a lot of redundant questions on certain subjects, a particular answerer may not always give a comprehensive answer to the question. Is that Clear? :roll: A while back I was going to ask a question about the Gravely walk behind tractors, and I'll be darned if a post on this forum didn't lead me to obtaining the info I needed! 8) Larry
 
Worth while discussion topic.

I participate in several other brand tractor boards. At one time I answered questions on how to time the W series Allis Chalmers tractor engines. One individual asked about every third day for several weeks where the timing marks were located and how to time the magneto to the engine. I finally just quit answering the question. I just got tired of providing the same information.

One problem with the search function on this Cub board is that when you want a specific answer, you sometimes receive to many posts/responses.

Eugene


.
 
Many years ago, a prominent car rental company sought the answer to the ages-old question "How many times do I have to tell you..." They hired a research firm and came up with an answer: Six. Researchers concluded that you have to put your message out there in a variety of ways to capture the many different ways people seek information. The effectiveness of the message depended upon a number of factors, not the least of which was the audience members' individual learning styles.

In my experience as a web designer, people who come to a web site come with one purpose: to solve a problem. There are four types of people who use web sites, and how each of them solves a problem is drastically different. See if you recognize yourself in any of these.

Detectives - These folks are in it as much for the hunt as for the answers to their questions. They think linearly and want to progress from the general to the specific until they have cornered and captured their prey. They pay attention to headings, topics and link titles and create a mental map of how they got where they are in case they have to drop back and take another tact.

Heat-Seekers - The first thing a seeker looks for on a web site is the search form or link. They have a question to ask and can't wait to do it. If you have no search form or the search link is not obvious, you will quickly lose a seeker on your site. Another trait of seekers is tha they don't want to wade through irrelevant information to find their answer. They will typically only view the first page of search results and, if the links don't get right to the point, they're off to look somewhere else. (I'm definitely a heat-seeker)

Communicators - These folks aren't really looking for the answers to their questions on your web site. They are looking for a means to contact someone and ask their question. You can throw the answer at them on every page, but they simply won't see it because that's not what they're looking for. They only want to see a contact form, e-mail address or phone number.

Receptors - Finally, there are the folks who have come to your site expecting the solution to their problem to hit them in the face from the moment they arrive. Often, they know they have a problem, but may not know exactly what it is, thus, they lack the basic understanding to make any of the above methods work effectively. The only way to effectively reach receptors is to "push" every conceivable bit of information to them from the home page.

Here's an example. As many of you now know, I maintain the web site for a state agency in Ohio. One of our programs, the Golden Buckeye card, offers discounts to anyone over age 60 at participating merchants, as well as on prescription drugs. When you visit our site, GoldenBuckeye.com, there are several links to the Golden Buckeye card area - including one that is actually an image of the card.

Once there, there is a vast amount of information to answer the most frequently asked questions: Who is eligible? How do I get a new/replacement card? What do I do if I never receive my card? We even have a conspicuously placed FAQ link that answers all these questions. Our search engine even includes some pre-programmed quick-searches that help lead people to the answers to these queries. Then, on our Contact page, we have a large, high-contrast notice box that lists the most frequently asked questions with links directly to the answers.

Still, what do you think the most common question we get through our web site is? That's right: Who is eligible? How do I get a new/replacement card? What do I do if I never receive my card?

The bottom line is that people look for and process information differently. Often, the answer could be right in front of them, but they simply won't see or hear it because they aren't "tuned in" to that particular way of presenting information. So, you will always have folks posting for answers that have been posted and discussed ad nauseum because they are simply unable to find the answers they need. When you're in the business of giving info out online, patience is more than a virtue, it's a necessity.

Back to the example of the car rental company. They had a problem with clients not leaving the keys in the cars when they returned them. So they devised a system that reminded customers six times to leave the keys. The message was presented visually and verbally, both when the client picked up the car and dropped it off. As a result, they went from more than 60 percent of people forgetting to leave the keys to less than 10 percent. But, there were still those who would never get the message because they were unaware they needed to.
 
Hey Lildog,
Happy new year!
First and foremost thank you so very much for the copy of the George covered magazine.
I seem myself as a heat seeking detective according to youyr four categories.
A very good approach to public communications in the present-day fast input, need to know society.
It would be very interesting to hear how you style your website to deal with, and get the information to, those four sets of people.
Happy new year again,
Pat
 
Back
Top