GM 2.4L Ecotec troubles

Urbish

501 Club
I have a 2012 Chevrolet Equinox with the 2.4L Ecotec 4 cylinder engine. Two weeks ago, the timing chain jumped a couple of teeth at 83k miles (lone P0016 diagnostic code). I first replaced the crank and cam position sensors to no avail, then went ahead and replaced the timing chain. I did lots of research before starting while trying to diagnose. What I have learned is very concerning and despite dropping a large chunk of money and time on this car over the past couple of weeks, I'm going to get rid of it ASAP.

This engine has direct fuel injection and has a high pressure fuel pump driven directly off the intake cam. When the seal goes bad, fuel mixes with the oil and dilutes it. This then leads to premature timing chain and guide wear. It also leads to piston ring failure and scuffing of the cylinder bores. With the extra blow-by, an excessive amount of water accumulates at the end of the PCV in the intake plenum. There is a small well in the plenum where the PCV discharges to. If parked outside in cold weather, the water freezes, the PCV plugs with ice, and the crankcase pressure blows out the rear main seal of the engine.

In my case, the timing chain guides and tensioner were fine, but the chain had stretched ~3/8". When I took the intake plenum off the car to start diagnosing, I poured 1/3-1/2 cup of water out of it. Luckily it gets parked in an attached garage overnight and generally stays above freezing; so the seal is intact for now.

If you have a GM product with the 2.4L Ecotec, listen for excessive noise at the passenger side of the engine while it is running. It is an interference engine and will bend/break valves if the timing chain breaks or jumps more than a few teeth.

Also take off your intake plenum and see if any water runs out of the PCV hole. A lot of people are rerouting their PCV to a catch can/bottle so that they don't blow out the rear main. It appears that there is no long-term fix to these issues. I've seen many reports where a dealer-installed replacement engine exhibited the same issues at low mileage.
 
I have around 5 Toyotas currently and all but one has over 280,000 miles with no significant problems. However, many years ago we had a Toyota van that had a sludge problem early in the history of Toyota identifying it as a design error. It was out of warranty but, with some mild persuasion, Toyota did replace the engine and the van did well until it was totaled in an accident. The forum talkers seem to believe there is a extended warranty to cover this ecotec problem so it may be worth looking into if true. Unfortunately, it sounds like there still is no good fix.
 
Landreo":1g7ef324 said:
The forum talkers seem to believe there is a extended warranty to cover this ecotec problem so it may be worth looking into if true. Unfortunately, it sounds like there still is no good fix.

They only extended the powertrain warranty for the 2010-2011 model years. :?
 
Jim,
Sorry to hear about your troubles.
I have a 2012 Malibu with the 2.4L EcoTec Flex Fuel engine. I've got 115,000 on it and show an average of 26.5mpg. Usually goes up to 28-30 in the spring and fall when I don't have the AC on and running summer fuel.
Had not heard about any of the issues you're describing so I'm going to read up on the Malibu forums.
2002 Astro AWD 4.3L V6 with 251,000
2006 Silverado 4x4 Crew 4.8L V8 with 198,000

Peter
 
Peter,
I have owned this Equinox for three years and had been very happy with it up until this point; decent fuel economy and comfortable ride. I did not expect this type of mass engine problem from a GM product. I wasn't able to do any research prior to buying it, but would have opted for the V6 had I known better. We bought it in a hurry after a (presumably texting) school bus driver shortened our 2009 Toyota Matrix.

Jim
 

Attachments

  • 20150310_090233.jpg
    20150310_090233.jpg
    152.7 KB · Views: 12,380
  • 20150310_111721.jpg
    20150310_111721.jpg
    145.9 KB · Views: 12,380
Back
Top