geo thermo

john2189

501 Club
Anyone have geothermo water furnace? I need a new furnace and trying to decide to stick with fuel oil or geo thermo.

What is the installation cost of a water furnase ?
I live in ohio
 
I have had one for about 23 years. Installation is key to good performance. my first one (Water Furnace brand) was not installed properly, but did the job for nearly 20 years. When it began giving some problems, and it was going to be pretty expensive to repair, plus the closed loop system hadn't been done right I decided to go with a different company and start over. For initial installation costs, expect anywhere from 2 to 3 times that of a conventional furnace, but don't forget, you are also getting an air conditioning system too, and it will be just as efficient as the heating. for a lot of good info go to http://www.hydro-temp.com.
 
We have one, overall very favorable impressions, and I agree, install is everything. Very efficient, UNLESS you have an issue and it uses its auxillary heat, in which case you will use a ton of electricity. Things we learned, don't fluctuate your temps with the heat pump. With gas or oil it makes sense to program it to drop temps during the day and reheat when you're on your way home, same with lowering it overnight and having it warm up in the mornings and such.

With geo thermal your heater is more a heat maintainer. You don't want to increase the temps more than a degree or two degrees at a time. So if its at 65, and you want to get to 70, set it to 66 or 67 and wait, or else they will use the auxillary electricity to help heat the house faster. Once its at the temp you want it will hold that temp easily, but raising temps rapidly is not easy for the system.

With ours we've occasionally had electrical things to repair. Namely, connectors, relays, and capacitors. These are not hard to troubleshoot and install, so we keep these parts on hand, the connectors are supposed to be replaced from time to time. Basically all the parts cost about 1/3 of what your furnace guy will charge you, and then they charge you 80 bucks an hour, which you can do it free if you have any skills.

One thing I need to retrofit is valves to close off the flow of water to the pump and drains, so that they can flush the unit from time to time.

Another way to make your unit more efficient for you is that some units will help maintain the temps of your hot water. In which case if you have either heat or AC on your electric bills for the hotwater heater will be lowered with not much difference in the pumps running at all. Mine isn't plumbed for this since we seldom use air conditioning.
 
PBG brought up something I forgot to mention. They can provide all or part of your hot water, depending on configuration. I opted for the part, and the hot water is a byproduct and the amount depends on how much the compressor runs. It has a separate heat exchanger that water form the lower part of my hot water heater is circulated through, and removes some heat from the freon coming out of the compressor and dumps it into the water heater. In the summer time it will provide practically all of your hot water (depending on how much cooling it needs to do) for no additional charge, and in the winter time it provides part of the water heating for a lower charge than the normal electric cost. You can also get an option where it will also come on with a zone just for the hot water, but unless you use a lot of hot water, the results do not justify the expense. The hot water heating can be switched off anytime you want also.
 
Our daughter and son-in-law have one and love it. I know it has reduced their heating/cooling costs. :D :D

Depending on your age, you may want to run a cost analysis. As John said, new installations are not cheap. You should calculate how many years it would take to break even.
 
Thanks for the info.. I am 56 so I dont know if it would be worth it for me. I might end up staying with the fuel oil , its worked ok for the past 30 years Ive lived here.
 
john2189":16sc5q7p said:
Thanks for the info.. I am 56 so I dont know if it would be worth it for me. I might end up staying with the fuel oil , its worked ok for the past 30 years Ive lived here.
That is one way to look at it, another is one that comes to mind, since at about your age I developed severe health problems. You might think about getting things lined out so that as your ability to maintain it yourself deteriorates, and fuel prices increase, which the way things have been going they will, you are positioned already to ride it out better.

Please, do not anyone try to turn this into a political discussion, it is not, as populations increase, fuel gets scarce, etc. prices will go up, no matter who is in office.
 
Is natural gas available to, or at your residence? The cost of natural gas is most likely to remain low in comparison to other currently available heating fuels, discounting wood. Reasoning. Natural gas is readily available and hugh reserves have recently been found and tapped in several areas of the US, including the upper Midwest.

Spreed sheet the various options for your residence. Look at the payback period - over, say 20 years. Consider maintenance, inflation, and financing as some of the factors. One other issue to consider is the value added when the house is sold.
 
Back
Top