Garage Floor Drain Question

lyle11

501 Club
This is a long shot but I thought maybe someone encountered this and had a cheaper solution. I have a garage floor drain that has what is called a Vitrified Clay Bell in the floor. It is 13” diameter and there is a ledge about 2 1/2” below the surface. It had a cast iron grate on feet that sits on this ledge so it’s just below floor level. After 39 years of salt from cars and water the cast iron grate rusted away and finally collapsed.

The good news is, there is a place online located only about 50 miles from my house that makes replacements that are better than original. The bad news is it costs $198.

This is not directly in the line where cars drive, I have seen heavy duty Class B rated PVC grates that would do the job for a lot less money but not the right size which is 12”-13”. If it’s too deep I figure I can saw it to off the proper depth. I keep getting kicked out to the login screen when I try to add a photo but, this doesn’t connect to a pipe. It just covers a hole in the floor


Just throwing this out there in case someone has any ideas. I haven’t found anything but before I spend over $200 with tax I figured it can’t hurt to ask.
Thanks
 
I would go with a metal grate. Reason. I think it would last much longer than a plastic one.

Another option, if you have wood on hand. If you have to purchase the 2X lumber, go with the metal grate.
 
You could have one made up at a fab shop from stainless or plain steel plate. If you give them the correct dimensions, it should fit perfectly.
 
Im a tightwad so I’m sure I’d fabricate my own out of something I’d find laying around my shop. I do have welders and torches though and a pretty good assortment of steel odds and ends. A little flat stock heated and bent into a circle and a little expanded mesh and I’d be done
 
Thanks for the suggestions. I was hoping to find an off the shelf PVC drain that would work but so far everything I find is too big (14”) or too small (10”). Needs to be 12”-13”. I don’t have the skills or tools to fabricate my own metal cover. It’s not just a round disk. It has to either be 21/2” thick or have at least 4 and preferably 6 feet to sit on the ledge in the vitrified clay bell.

It could have been much worse because the hole in the floor after it collapsed under the weight of my wife’s car tire (she heard something but didn’t know what it was) was hidden under vinyl garage flooring with the seam in the vinyl sheets over the drain hole. I was out of town and got home 20 minutes before my wife very likely stepped in it.
 
I know there is a green plastic one made that fits in a piece of 12" double wall corregated plastic pipe.

Sorry, but I never measured one, and dont have one handy!

They used to cost around 20 or 30 bucks.

They are 2 to 3" thick, and probably have a rating to be driven across
 
lyle11":1gll64gj said:
Have a garage floor drain that has what is called a Vitrified Clay Bell in the floor. It is 13” diameter and there is a ledge about 2 1/2” below the surface.
Bob McCarty":1gll64gj said:
I live in a dry climate, but I'd get some treated lumber and and make one on the bandsaw and drill press.
I think any local wood worker/carpenter could knock one in is about 1/2 hour.

Pressure treated 2x4, no knots. Cut down to 2 1/2" wide. Use the 1" cut off as 1/4" spacers. Two bolts to hold together.
 
SamsFarm":k2mzy47t said:
I know there is a green plastic one made that fits in a piece of 12" double wall corregated plastic pipe.

Sorry, but I never measured one, and dont have one handy!

They used to cost around 20 or 30 bucks.

They are 2 to 3" thick, and probably have a rating to be driven across

I found the green plastic drain for a 12” pipe in Class B (support a car tire running over it at low speed) and it’s about 14” across. Too big. These drains are made to fit to a pipe so I’m pretty sure what I need isn’t manufactured.
 
Eugene":2glzaazf said:
lyle11":2glzaazf said:
Have a garage floor drain that has what is called a Vitrified Clay Bell in the floor. It is 13” diameter and there is a ledge about 2 1/2” below the surface.
Bob McCarty":2glzaazf said:
I live in a dry climate, but I'd get some treated lumber and and make one on the bandsaw and drill press.
I think any local wood worker/carpenter could knock one in is about 1/2 hour.

Pressure treated 2x4, no knots. Cut down to 2 1/2" wide. Use the 1" cut off as 1/4" spacers. Two bolts to hold together.

I could make this. I can fabricate wood projects, but I’m not set up for metal projects like this. Not sure how long it would last with a lot of road salt and moisture here but it might be several years.

I have no current plans to sell this house. But, the garage floor is heavily pitted from 39 years of road salt. I could see a future owner installing a new concrete floor which will need a new drain. My next door neighbor has owned the house since it was built. She never parks in the garage. It’s too full of stuff. Her floor looks like new.

Thanks
 
It might be possible to buy a plastic drain smaller than what you need, stuff the drain full of newspaper and then set the new drain in concrete to fill the gap. After the concrete has cured remove the grate and pull the newspaper out. Basically create a concrete reduction bushing
 
I’m going to have to start paying Eugene a consulting fee. He gave me the best advice on breaking up my concrete steps with the feathers and wedges. Now he had a good idea using treated lumber. I had a part of a treated 2 x 6 sitting around from a past project. I don’t have a bandsaw but I have a miter saw. I was able to cut it up and create a sturdy and functional grate. Fortunately there’s a fairly wide ledge for the boards to sit on. The clay insert walls aren’t straight up and down. They slant inward so it would have taken more time than I was willing to spend to get it to fit perfectly but it’s solidly in place.

The floor is heavily pitted and I cover it with two vinyl garage floor mats. The seam is right down the middle of the grate so you rarely see it anyway. The water just seeps through the gap in the seam of the vinyl. It’s no work of art but it will do for this purpose.

If the floor was in real good shape, I wouldn’t need to vinyl mats to cover it, so I probably would’ve opted to buy the steel one for $198.

BD1CFAC9-40D1-4C7A-AD62-47A6BA22578A.jpeg
 
lyle11":etcscln4 said:
I’m going to have to start paying Eugene a consulting fee. He gave me the best advice on breaking up my concrete steps with the feathers and wedges. Now he had a good idea using treated lumber. I had a part of a treated 2 x 6 sitting around from a past project.
Lyle: My consulting fee bill is in the mail. Prefered customer discount of 10% if paid in within 30 days.

Frequently use the feathers and wedges. Broke up the sidewalk in front of the fixer upper house and part of a 30' x 30' drive of the back of the fixer upper.

The grate will keep someone from breaking an ankle. Looks good. Easily replace if/when needed.
 
Back
Top