For the math experts

Brent

501 Club
:? :? :? Here's a real life math quiz for the math brainers on this site.

I'm going to by a new car and can either borrow the money from myself through my 401K at 8%, paying myself back the principal and interest or I can get a commercial loan at 6%. Question is: Do I make any money borrowing from myself at a 2% higer rate?

Here's an example:

Balance in 401k: $100,000

401K Earns: 7%

Loan amount: $20,000

Interest rate on 401K loan: 8%

Term of loan: 5yrs

Commercial loan: $20,000

Interest rate: 6%

Term of loan: 5yrs

To make it easy, assume interest is simple rather than compounded.
 
Brent, the difference is that the interest you pay is going back to you, not to someone else. You are "borrowing" your money and are compensating for loss of interest it would have gained by paying that interest back to your account.
 
Brent,

Most analysts that I have read online and in papers shy away from the borrowing from the 401k and their reasons are as follows.

1. On the average a 401k tends to beat out the interest rate that you pay back into the 401k.
2. Depending upon how the 401k is set up it is possible that if you change jobs or lose the job then you have to pay back the entire loan amount or pay the taxes on the amount left on the loan (check with the 401k provider or your HR person.)

The following is from Fidelity FAQs about Loans against a 401k.

<quote>
Will I pay taxes or penalties?
You will not pay taxes or penalties when you initiate a loan and make loan repayments as scheduled or if you pay off your loan early.

However, if you leave your employer, you may be required to repay your loan in full within a certain amount of time. If you do not repay your loan within the terms of the loan, it will be considered a withdrawal and you'll have to pay taxes on the outstanding loan balance. In addition, if you are under age 59 1/2 you may have to pay a 10% early withdrawal penalty. You may also be subject to other penalties, depending upon your plan's provisions.
</quote>

Regards,
Chad
 
Easy. Take the commercial loan. 7% interest (in your pocket/401K) is more than the 6% you would pay for the commercial loan. Second it doesn't make much cence to borrow your own money at 8% when you can borrow the same $ amount at 6%.

Most computers have financial spread sheets where you can run the numbers.

Eugene
 
401K. $100,000 @ 7% interest. Pays/earns $40,255.17 in 5 years.
$80,000 @ 7% interest. Pays/earns $32,204.13 in 5 years.

Commercial loans. $20,000.- For 6 years.
8% = interest of $4331.67
6% = interest of $3199.36
 
Never remove money from your 401k unless you're retired and drawing it as income. Too many pitfalls. Either save the money and pay cash or take a loan.

The answer to the math quiz is to purchase a late model used vehicle. It will be about 1/3 to 1/2 the price of a new one.
 
Dat is much more smarts den I'da evar have :!: :)
But I like the part "save in advance for thing to come" (I had to with 4 kids & 1 income).
Think of the small interest you made while saving it, plus the difference of the interest loan being considered :wink:
Dat der is red neck language from po folk.
 
Bigdog":1swcvce9 said:
Brent, the difference is that the interest you pay is going back to you, not to someone else. You are "borrowing" your money and are compensating for loss of interest it would have gained by paying that interest back to your account.

:wink: :wink: Bigdog is right. Without going into all the calculations, the gurus that manage the plan say I would come out ahead of the game borrowing from myself. The fact that the plan is earning 7% and you're paying yourself back at a higer rate, in my case 8.25%, I would actually realize a small gain at the end of five years. Since I am retired, it would be a good deal for me. Draw back is the monthly payments are higher than for a commercial loan.
 
Make sure you are actually paying yourself the interest and not to the fund management company. Many 401k plans only return the withdrawl amount to your 401k and the fund manager collects the interest paid as the fee for lending you money.

Are you borrowing from a 401k or an annunity? Borrowing from an annunity has different ramifications than a 401k.
 
Lurker Carl":ijjbnm7w said:
Make sure you are actually paying yourself the interest and not to the fund management company. Many 401k plans only return the withdrawl amount to your 401k and the fund manager collects the interest paid as the fee for lending you money.

Are you borrowing from a 401k or an annunity? Borrowing from an annunity has different ramifications than a 401k.

I'm borrowing from a 401K. I've borrowed money from myself one other time and the interest is paid to me not to the plan manager. Another advantage is the the title will be in my name and there won't be a lein holder.
 
Thought I'd bring this subject up again.

401(K) is pretax money. If you take a loan out of the 401(K) you pay the loan back with after tax money. When you withdraw the funds at retirement you will pay taxes on withdrawn funds. Meaning you pay income taxes twice on the loaned 401(K) money. Dolan-source of that tidbit.

Borrowing funds from your IRA is a bit more complicated than just the interest/compound interest on the borrowed funds.

Several months after this post was initiated car manufacturere were offering no interest, 60 month loans on certain vehicle models.
 
Eugene":2l2n2g6j said:
Several months after this post was initiated car manufacturere were offering no interest, 60 month loans on certain vehicle models.
The "no interest" loans almost always have an alternative choice of some amount of "cash back" (discount). If you take the "no interest" loan, you are prepaying the interest by passing up the discount. Normally, the best deal is still to save your money and pay cash.
 
Many years ago I fell in love with a car I didn't have the money to pay for. I was talked into financing a car for the only time in my life. From that day forward for 3 whole months I had to make $41 monthly payments for something I already had. :( That bothered me enough I've never done it again. Save the money first. If you can't afford it, wait till you can... You can't afford the interest either. :?
 
George and Jim:

100% agree with you. Pay cash for a several year old used vehicle.

Reason I brought up the subject again. I was watching Oprah and there was a lady on discussing finances. Someone asked her a question on borrowing from a retirement account. Her answer was that it was very bad due to the taxation issue.

I have a small amount of money in an IRA. I have been reading up on IRA's and how not to get ripped off. The borrowing from the IRA was not discussed in any of the reading material.

15% tax bracket. A loan from an IRA gets really expensive. Paying the income tax twice plus the interest on the loan.
 
Take the bank loan. Like mentioned earlier, if you loose your job for "and reason" the loan is due at that time. Don't take the chance. Life is too uncertain. Loss of job due to sickness, accident, down sizing, or just a butthead boss being a jerk, don't take the chance.

I agree with Jim, save up and pay cash. Just start setting aside a car fund. Pay a monthly payment into a simple savings account and when you have enough buy the car/truck. After you buy the car/truck start the process all over again until there is enough to buy the next car that will be needed.

You can always start off with a say $8,000 to $10,000 dollar vehicle and the save some more and use the first vehicle and the money saved again to upgrade to a better vehicle.
 
Back
Top