Please pardon the misspelled, left out words on this post. I’m in a hurry and If I don’t do this now, It will be two weeks before I’ll get back to it and I’m sure this subject will be put to rest by then.
I should have known if I put in words what my thoughts were I would be challenged. A wise person said to me one time; “believe nothing what you hear and half of what you seeâ€.
Perhaps nothing of what I wrote in this case.
First I want to say I’m not an anti-ethanol person. I’m very much for the type of renewable energy as Bio-Fuel stands for. Small business is the back bone of this country. Nothing but good has came out of small business. Look back and tell me who fed this country through out the past years…
The farmer!!!…now look what is happening to them. Why??? Yes I hope the price of corn goes up because of ethanol production but, I feel the middle man, big business and the oil companies will not let that happen.
I hope you prove me wrong!!!!
Second I made a mistake on the quote for the year of the price of ethanol. I should have said
2006 at $125.00 per barrel. This was a quick average year to date.
Larry I will discuss/debate your comments with the following research and the resources I have at hand. I’m sorry to say I will not be able to respond after tonight because I will be out of town for two weeks. The only P.C. I will have is a company notebook and I’m very cautious when using it for personal use, so I will take your negation in conviction…. So take it easy on me or I’ll send “400lbsonacubseatspring†after you!!! :wink:
Since Larry is in the Bio-Fuel business he may have a lot more information than me.
Larry in IN wrote:
I am curious as to where the $125.00 per bbl. number comes from?
Our planning number for cost of operation is less than a dollar per gal for operation and debt service. Depending on the price of corn and soy oil [other fats and oils too], any time fuel is retailing for about $2.00 or more
The information I have come from the following sources;
It takes a lot of energy to make ethanol. According to the Department of Energy, most studies put the ratio as low as 1:1/4 - meaning that for every one unit of energy spent, only 1/4 units of ethanol energy are created. Indeed, there are some camps who believe producing corn-based ethanol actually results in a net loss of energy.
This illustration represents total cost of product ready for market: Formula;
X= 125/(1/¼)[X= 41]
When I took an average of $125.00 per barrel for the product it was priced on the market for $3.05 a gallon per the Fuel Ethanol Terminal Market. ($125.00 ÷ 41 gallons per barrel= $3.0487 per gallon cost. According to the Department of Energy at their ratio it cost $2.29 per gallon to produce. $ 3.05 x .75 (75%) lost do to cost of making product = $2.29. The gain per gallon would be $.76. $3.05 x .25 (¼%) (Gain) = $.76
The price varies everyday as you see on the chart.
http://www.energy.ca.gov/gasoline/graphs/Ethanol18-Month.gif
When I wrote the quote:
Government Legislation past and present has been approved for Incentives to the production of alternative fuels
I wrote it for the following reasons:
June 17, 2006
The Ethanol Pipe Dream
The Wall Street Journal
We have nothing against corn-based ethanol per se, assuming it competes in the market on the same basis as other fuels. Ethanol's problem is that it is expensive to make and provides far fewer miles per gallon than gasoline. So its supporters have worked the political system to subsidize ethanol, and more recently to force Americans to buy it.
U.S. taxpayers today pay twice for ethanol: once in crop subsidies to corn farmers and again in a 51-cent subsidy for every gallon of ethanol. Without such a subsidy, ethanol simply wouldn't be cost competitive with gasoline. Then last year, Congress went further and passed a new ethanol mandate, requiring drivers to use at least 7.5 billion gallons annually by 2012.
The immediate consequence of this new mandate was higher gasoline prices this spring, since the ethanol industry was ill-equipped to meet the new demand. Ethanol must also be carried by truck or rail, rather than through pipelines, and it requires special blending facilities. All this has both raised prices and created gas shortages around the country. But rather than blame their new mandate for the higher prices, the Members of Congress blamed, of course, Big Oil.
Ah, but what about the other alleged virtues of ethanol? One favorite is that every gallon of ethanol will supplant a gallon of gasoline imported from tyrannical Mideast oil regimes. Thus, a la Brazil, ethanol can help the U.S. achieve the miracle of "energy independence."
Sorry. The most widely cited research on this subject comes from Cornell's David Pimental and Berkeley's Ted Patzek. They've found that it takes more than a gallon of fossil fuel to make one gallon of ethanol -- 29% more. That's because it takes enormous amounts of fossil-fuel energy to grow corn (using fertilizer and irrigation), to transport the crops and then to turn that corn into ethanol. The Saudis ought to love the stuff.
Potential legislation
CNET News.com
August 29, 2006 11:38 AM PDT
California's ethanol initiative:where the money goes
Last week we wrote a piece on an initiative in California that, if approved by voters this November, would place fees on oil drilling and use the funds to develop an ethanol and alternative energy economy.
Proponents of Proposition 87 say the initiative will raise about $4 billion over ten years. Oil companies oppose the initiative and have already started running ads in advance of the November vote.
In the initial report, we quoted Vinod Khosla, the venture capitalist who is a driving force behind the ballot, as stating that the money would get spent as follows: roughly 60 percent would go to entrepreneurs setting up businesses, such as ethanol filling stations; 30 percent would go to universities, and ten percent would go to running the program an miscellaneous tasks.
The Yes on 87 people wanted to slightly clarify the comments. It's similar but a little different. Here is how the initiative dictates where the money will go:
57.5 percent will go into the Gasoline and Diesel Use Reduction Account. This account will be used for loans, loan guarantees, credits and possibly other incentives for the following activities: buying cars running E85 (85 percent ethanol) or other gas-light cars.(businesses and individuals can apply for funds--school districts and mass transit authorities, however, will have first priority); setting up ethanol stations; setting up businesses that help build the ethanol infrastructure; setting up facilities for ethanol and clean fuel production; and research grants to private organizations.
26.75 percent will go to an account that will help fund university research.
9.75 will go to an account for accelerating the adoption or approval of clean technology. These are one-time start-up loans and grants.
2.5 percent goes to vocational training
3.5 percent goes to public education.
Rural Missouri news September, 2006 Page 5 Growing our own fuel paragraph 7 is in print;
“I am the first governor to recommend full funding for the Ethanol Incentive Fund in my budget. Since taking office I have directed $15.6 million to this fund.â€
The Truth About Cars | E85: Children of the Corn?
In fact, the production and distribution of E85 involves a strange mix of politics and economics which could well lead to a dead end. Following the money may make your head spin, but it's high time to separate E85 facts from the politically correct fug of obfuscation.
Obviously, there’s a nice little price bump involved. Grain middlemen seldom pay more than about $2 per bushel to buy corn; they can then get $2.50 to $3 for that same bushel on a futures contract. Ethanol plants are even willing to pay a little more, since they know they’ll sell every drop of fuel they produce. The upshot of all this agricultural to-ing and fro-ing: ethanol producers are stuck with a raw material cost that rarely drops below $2.50 a bushel, no matter how much corn is grown, stored or shipped……..
……..Thus, a gallon of ethanol requires roughly $.75 of corn. That may seem like a compelling cost structure for an alternative fuel– especially when compared to this week’s crude oil price of $1.40 per gallon. But E85’s ancillary costs are far higher. First, ethanol is more expensive to produce than gasoline (i.e. it takes more energy to make fuel from corn than oil, and energy ain’t cheap). Second, thanks to the phaseout of octane-enhancing MBTE gasoline additive, demand for ethanol far exceeds supply. Third, ethanol’s transportation costs are astronomical…….
……. Meanwhile, the people who’ll benefit most from E85 are the people who move the raw materials to the ethanol plants and the finished product to the consumer.
http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/?p=1870
A 10% blend of ethanol receives a federal tax credit of 5.1 cents per gallon, and these savings can be passed along to consumers at the pump - an instant tax credit for buying an American-made product.
http://www.ethanol.org/
Larry wrote:
By far most of the ethanol used in the US is locally produced. There is some noise about S. American influx, but it is being absorbed easily.
I tried to find the source I got this from. I think it was from the Wall Street Journal in July’06. The only thing I kept was the quote. Since I can’t find the source I will
retract the statement which was:
Most of the 4 billion gallons of ethanol produced in 2005 came from 13% of the U.S. corn crop (1.43 billion bushels of corn grain).
Cellulosic biomass to ethanol produces the difference. This represents a 17% increase from the 3.4 billion gallons produced in 2004. Ethanol is widely used as a fuel additive. The oxygen contained in ethanol improves gasoline combustibility. E10 (10% ethanol and 90% gasoline blend) is available from gas stations all over the United States E85 (85% ethanol and 15% gasoline blend) is available mainly in corn-producing states. E85 can be used as a substitute for gasoline in vehicles that have been modified to use this biofuel.
A commercial industry based on converting cellulosic biomass to ethanol does not yet exist in the United States, but in Brazil, however,
the technology is ready to be deployed in pilot or demonstration facilities in North America. Iogen Corporation, a biotechnology company in Canada, operates the largest demonstration facility, which annually produces about one million gallons of cellulosic ethanol from wheat straw.
And my last discuss/debate;
Larry wrote:
As to the modern flex-fuel vehicles, there is a sensor on board that detects the percentage [anywhere for 0 to 100%] of 'ol in the mix and sets the onboard computers to optimally burn that mix. All this happens 'on the fly'. That would have been hard to do before computers.
Maybe the sensor you’re talking about is the Oxygen sensor. The brief summery of what happens when ethanol is used in today’s auto is; that it burns leaner. The oxygen sensor(O2) looks at the lean mixture and returns the signal back to the Engine control module (ECU) and it compensates the fuel mixture to richer by keeping the fuel injectors open longer thus it will turn on the check engine light(CEL) if the O2 sensor show a lean condition for a period of time. You can reset the E.C.U. to ignore the O2 sensor to a certain parameter as long it stays in the OBD II guild line. The lean mixture reading still will be present and the injectors will still add fuel to compensate thus extra fuel usage--- less fuel mileage.
Note: If the ECU sees a lean mixture from the O2 sensor(s) it will richen the mixture by keeping the fuel injectors open longer. If ECU sees a rich mixture it will lean the mixture by keeping the fuel injectors closed longer.
Some extra info:
Can I tell which companies purchase imported
crude oil or gasoline?
While EIA cannot identify which companies are selling imported gasoline, EIA does collect data on which companies import crude oil and refined products. However, the fact that a given company imported crude oil or gasoline does not mean that those particular imports will end up being sold to motorists as that company’s brand of gasoline. The origin of the crude oil that a refinery processes is determined by market economics at a given time and may change from month-to-month or even day-to-day. Company-level import data can be found at:
http://www.eia.doe.gov/oil_gas/fwd/cli.html