Ethanol..... in the gas!

Buzzard Wing

501 Club
I just read an interesting bit about ethanol and boats. I have also heard that it can cause problems with some two stroke engines.

What I know is that ethanol WILL absorb water, including water vapor. What that means to a Cub owner is that instead of going to the bottom of the fuel bowl it will now be in the fuel. It will also 'melt' some rubber fuel lines.

The boats that had so much trouble had fiberglass fuel tanks, the ethanol blend turned them to a nasty jelly that really caused problems with the engine.

I wonder if it may be worthwhile to start using an Isopropol (sp ) additive?? What is commonly sold as fuel deicer.

Larry
 
Hey Larry...I've been hearin' that the GAS CARTEL have been using about 10% ethanol in their gas now for several months AND, it IS starting to cause some problems to boat owners with older fiberglass gas tanks! :cry:

As if we're not ALREADY OVER AN OIL BARREL with the GAS PRICES...NOW we gotta pay nearly $3.50 a gallon for marine fuel AND have fuel tank problems TOO :!: :!: :!: :shock:

AND...the LATEST Gulf Of Mexico oil drilling FIND can deliver MORE than a BILLION barrels of oil for us...BUT, we USE MORE than that a YEAR...AND, it's 5 MILES DOWN and won't be on the market for ANOTHER 4 YEARS!!! :oops: "HEY MARGRET...CLEAN UP IN ISLE THREE" :evil:
 
A friend has a flex fuel pickup. He gets 18 mpg on straight gasoline and 11 mpg on E85. I favor flex fuel vehicles provided the federal and state and local governments give a tax break sufficient to compensate for the fewer BTU's in alcohol. This would be one way to snub Iran.

But ethenol should not be used in engines and tanks not designed for it. Read Cub and most others.
 
If I remember right, an old trick years ago by mechanics used to be to dribble some water into your carburator while the engine was running and that was supposed to knock any carbon deposite loose in the cylinders. The small amounts absorbed in the fuel you're talking about shouldn't hurt, but possibly help these cub engines. Just a thought :wink:


What I know is that ethanol WILL absorb water, including water vapor. What that means to a Cub owner is that instead of going to the bottom of the fuel bowl it will now be in the fuel
Then there's the problem with the local gas companies adding water to fuel to make more volumn, a trick up their sleeve maybe?

Rick
 
You're freaking out about nothing.

It's true that ethanol will absorb small amounts of water, but it holds it in suspension, where it passes harmlessly through the engine, turning into steam on the "bang" stroke.

How do you think dry gas (isopropyl alcohol) "dries" up your gas tank? It doesn't magically make the water go away; it absorbs the water and holds it in suspension. Water doesn't mix with gasoline, but it readily mixes with alcohols. Remember the old adage, "Oil and water don't mix?"

The problem with moisture in a gas tank is that it pools into big glob of water, and it's when these big globs of water get sucked into the fuel pump that the trouble starts.

What you SHOULD be freaking out about is the fact that the government is touting ethanol as the "Great White Hope" of breaking our dependence on foreign oil and lowering the price of gasoline. It's a lie.

Fact: Ethanol is more expensive to produce, both financially and in use of fossil fuels, than gasoline, and it contains less energy than gasoline. You use more of a more expensive fuel.

Fact: Even if we put every acre of tillable land in the US into corn with the express purpose of producing ethanol, we can't hope to put a dent in the amount of oil we use. Now, what do we eat? Hope you like boiled corn mash, because that's all we'll have.
 
I wonder if it may be worthwhile to start using an Isopropol (sp ) additive?? What is commonly sold as fuel deicer.

I think the ethanol will do the same as the isopropyl, that is absorb water and allow it to pass through the engine. When a fuel tank is not completely full, the water vapor in the air will condense in the tank. Gas and water don't mix so the water settles to the bottom causing rust and freezing in winter. Alcohol and water will mix and the alcohol also acts like anti-freeze. Bottom line, if the gas contains ethanol, I don't think the deicer will be necessary or helpful.

As a side line, what will ethanol do to rubber tipped Kohler needles some people put into the carb? I think the stock needle is steel.
 
Regarding the comment about dribbling water into the carburetor of a running engine, it can be done. I am not convinced that the procedure has any value. But that and water in the fuel are two different matters entirely. Dribbling water into the air intake does not alter the air-fuel mix ratio that the carburetor produces, thus a combustible mixture is in the cylinder. But water in the fuel means that water is going through the carbutetor jet, thus the air-fuel mix ratio will be incorrect. If too much so, the engine will not run. Ethanol should preclude the need for gas line antifreeze. I would avoid ethanol fuel blends if at all possible UNLESS the vehicle manufacturer designed the vehicle for such blends. The latest issue of Consumer Reports has an article on ethanol fuel blends. Isopropyl is an excellent fuel additive, if it is needed. Isopropyl is less likely to cause damage to fuel system components. The fuel antifreeze commonly sold may be methanol- BAD BAD BAD-, or isopropyl. Use only 100% isopropyl. Rubbing alcohol already has all the water added that the alcohol can absorb.
 
Matt Kirsch":3ope0ku9 said:
You're freaking out about nothing.

It's true that ethanol will absorb small amounts of water, but it holds it in suspension, where it passes harmlessly through the engine, turning into steam on the "bang" stroke.

How do you think dry gas (isopropyl alcohol) "dries" up your gas tank? It doesn't magically make the water go away; it absorbs the water and holds it in suspension. Water doesn't mix with gasoline, but it readily mixes with alcohols. Remember the old adage, "Oil and water don't mix?"

The problem with moisture in a gas tank is that it pools into big glob of water, and it's when these big globs of water get sucked into the fuel pump that the trouble starts.

Right On.

It's seems "Ethanol" means the 10% variety to some people and the E85 to others. They are two different things. We have had 10% here for years. There has been no increase in problems in new cars, old cars, tractors, or mowers. I have a hard time finding anything but Premium that doesn't have ethanol. I have run 10% in the Cubs for 3-4 years.
A common complaint around here is that "damn corn gas" when you ask why they hate it they can't give you a reason or complain it ruined their engine. After pressing more you find their car with 200,000 miles died after using "corn" for a year. Definate proof that "corn" is bad in their eyes!
I am in the auto business and have friends running repair garages. They report a possible increase in electric fuel pump replacements but find that when they question the customers it is more related to people running their tanks below 1/4 rather than the type of fuel. Consistantly running a low tank overheats the electric pump even with recirculating pumps. They do not see a noticable increase in rubber related failures or plugged filters.
Some also work on small engines and have not seen problems there.
They do say they are starting to get suspicious of possible problems with 2 stroke snow mobiles. They don't have definate data but advise their customers not to use 10% in 2 strokes just to be safe. They all run 10% in their own vehicles.
E85 is not going to work in a vehicle not designed for it. They have seen people try it, (probably due to the Ethanol confusion I mentioned) it is good for spark plug sales when people try it.
 
In all this talk of water in the gas......

Anybody if heard of emergency war power. It was used on WWII fighters to escape the enemy. It was water injection. It cooled the combustion temps down thus increasing volumetric effeciency. It reportantly wasn't good on the engines though. Made alot of power but for a short time.
 
In the competition pulling they have water injection into their engines, I think some figures are like 20% increase. That might just be in the pullers that run with jet turnbines though!
 
The WWII planes used water injection to control detonation, "spark knock". Ignition timing could be advanced and compression ratios could be higher as a result.
 
Those WWII planes that used water injection to boost output, were turbocharged engines. Water was used to prevent detonation, thus allowing increased boost pressure for higher HP. It wasn't the water that was harmful to the engine, but the dangerous boost pressure.

Another consideration with any alcohol fuel is the lean fuel mixture it can cause. Because alcohol has only a little more than 1/2 the energy per gallon, of what gasoline has, (plus it's oxygen bearing) a larger carb. jet size is required. At 10%, it may not be a problem, but some Cubs are running on the lean side already. A bigger jet = increased consumption.

Alcohol fuel can actually have several benefits (especially if you're after power) It's oxygen bearing (that's where the power comes from) and it's cooler burning. It can also be a nightmare, more corrosive, difficult to tune & the exhaust really burns the eyes.
 
Not that I am trying to say the sky is falling, but now when the tractor don't start or run there is something new that may be causing it.

What I am trying to figure out is how to deal with this new blend and not have trouble. I don't have any choice about what goes in the 5 gallon can or in the Cub, but I am a bit leery of the problems water can cause. A car is different because we usually only put the gas in the 'sealed' system and drive it. Tractors and small engines usually have less time between fill ups, less likely to have a full tank, are filled from a jerry jug, AND ARE VENTED. So the fuel is more likely to be contaminated, exposed to air (and moisture/humidity) and be 'improperly' stored for a longer period of time.

I even learned a new word... hygroscopic

The thing that will be a problem for Cub owners is 'phase separation', where the water/ethanol will fall to the bottom of the tank.

Here is what Chevron says at:
http://www.chevron.com/products/PRODSER ... ne/pg2.asp

Especially interesting is what they have to say about water:

"The situation is different for gasoline oxygenated with 10 vol % ethanol. The gasoline-alcohol blend can dissolve more water (6000–7000 ppm at 21°C/70°F). When this blend is cooled, both the water and some of the ethanol become insoluble. Contacting the blend with more water also draws ethanol from the blend. The result, in both cases, is two layers of liquid: an upper ethanol-deficient gasoline layer and a lower ethanol-rich (up to 75% ethanol) water layer. The process is called phase separation and it occurs because ethanol is completely soluble in water but only marginally soluble in hydrocarbons. After phase separation, the gasoline layer will have a lower octane number and may knock in an engine. The fuel also is less volatile. The engine will not run on the water/ethanol layer. As the concentration of ethanol is decreased, the aromatics content of the gasoline is decreased, and as temperature is decreased, less water is required to cause a phase separation.

The potential for phase separation requires that gasoline oxygenated with ethanol not be exposed to water during its distribution or use in a vehicle. Because of this requirement, gasoline oxygenated with ethanol is not transported in pipelines, which sometimes contain water. Rather, the ethanol is added to tanker trucks at the terminal immediately before delivery to the service station. Housekeeping at the service station is very important to prevent water contamination. This water sensitivity also means that extra care should be taken when gasoline oxygenated with ethanol is used as a fuel for boat engines. Ethanol blends are hygroscopic (absorb moister from the air) and in time can phase separate during storage if the tank is vented to the atmosphere and is subject to breathing as a result of temperature changes. "

Larry
 
Back
Top