Engineering oversites or should i say mistakes?

BigBill

501 Club
Have you ever wondered why the rear brakes never wearout on your american car or truck or SUV with disc brakes in the front?

Have you ever thought that maybe there not working properly?

One example;

I had 127,000 miles on my chevy suburban V20 4x4 that had the 10,000lb trailer towing capacity and i never replaced the rear brake shoes the whole time not even once. While i replaced the front disc brakes many times.

Ever wonder why your vechicle is warping rotors sometimes? It seems to me that the front brakes are doing all the work while the rears only function with the emergency brake.

I believe there's something wrong with the design that has to do with the valving in the brake system. Too much pressure is being sent to the front disc brakes.

Maybe now that were comming out with rear disc brakes more it will solve the engineering oversite with drum brakes on disc brake systems.

If this was designed right we wouldn't need the anti-lock brakes. It just gets silly they try to fix the problem with another problem over and over. Who oversees these designers?
 
Bill, there are multiple reasons for the things you mentioned, in addition to what you posted.

The new brake shoes are longer lasting, and since the most weight is on the front they do most of the work.

One short coming of the front rotors is that they are made thinner, for both weight savings and economics, which does make them warp faster, especially if you have a heavy foot on the brakes. another cause of warping is over tightening of the wheel lugs. There are torque specs for the lugs for a reason, but I have seen numerous tire shops grab an impact and tighten lugs to the point they cannot be removed even with a 4 way lug wrench.

The antilock rear brakes which are now standard on most vehicles apply less braking on the rear wheels unless it is really needed.
 
The front to rear balance of brakes is calibrated to try to keep rear wheels from locking up first. This is to help keep the vehicle facing forward when they do skid. With the front weight bias built into most vehicles plus the weight transfer of braking, a high percentage of the braking work has to be done by the front. The design of the front brakes is constrained by suspension design, wheel size and cooling requirements among other factors. After all the other parameters are set, lifetime of the pads is going to be determined mostly by the thickness and composition of the lining material, both constrained by other design factors. Maximum lifetime of the brakes pretty well falls out from the other factors.

Life expectance of the rear brakes could be brought more in line with the fronts by building them with thinner linings. I'm not sure I would consider that an improvement.

I put 69K on my '91 1/2 ton before I sold it and the original brakes had plenty of wear remaining. My Cavalier (front drive, heavy front weight bias) has about 90K of almost entirely city/suburban driving and is on its third set of front pads. I may have changed the reas once as well. If you have been through "many" sets of front brakes in 127K miles, you probably need to look for some other problem.
 
As a husband dad grandfather and numerous other titles i have TRIED IN VAIN to explain how to stop without undue stress on the front brakes most people wait until they get to where they are going to slow down or apply the brakes i let off the accelarator a good distance before applying the brakes and let my speed decrease before braking i have driven numerous vehicles with front drum and disk brakes well over 100,000 miles before replacing lining or pads i'm not an expert but it works for me.light pressure on the pedal is much easier than heavy pressure.
Jim
 
I found that on my 1995 K 1500 that the rear breakes would be constantly out of adjusment causing the brake pedal to go soft. And that I never backed up with enough force to allow the rear adjusters to work properly. Also you need to torque the front wheels to 80FT pounds to keep the front roters from warping.
Now that I have the HD 2500 with the 4 wheel disk brakes I will not have to worry about the soft brake pedal
 
Jim Reid":3k7kn1cn said:
As a husband dad grandfather and numerous other titles i have TRIED IN VAIN to explain how to stop without undue stress on the front brakes most people wait until they get to where they are going to slow down or apply the brakes i let off the accelarator a good distance before applying the brakes and let my speed decrease before braking i have driven numerous vehicles with front drum and disk brakes well over 100,000 miles before replacing lining or pads i'm not an expert but it works for me.light pressure on the pedal is much easier than heavy pressure.
Jim

Jim - I have noticed that too. I don't know what they are teaching (if anything) to students in driver's education classes any more but every new driver I have ridden with, especially since my kids were in high school, drives like that. They all wait until the last minute to apply the brakes and then it's like a panic stop. With all the automatic transmissions nowadays, engine braking isn't a normal thing any more but it certainly helps to get off the accelerator and let friction and wind resistance help slow you down and I know it saves brakes. I have one truck with about 115K miles on it that is only on it's second set of pads and still has the original rear brakes and they look good. 12 years ain't bad!
 
Easy on the gas pedal, easy on the brake pedal, anticipate traffic ahead. Front brakes last me at least 100K miles, usually needing replacement when the calipers bind and cause uneven wear among the pads.

Rear brakes seldom need replacing unless the lining are soaked with grease or brake fluid. And the rear brakes will work if you keep them adjusted, don't depend on the self-adjusters to do the job.

I agree with SteveB and the rotor warpage, uneven or over torqueing the lug nuts will destroy rotors fast. So will overheating them, don't drive like you stole it.
 
It would be interesting if someone could compute the amount of extra and unnecessary fuel required to wear out a set of brake calipers??? I'll bet it's a lot! All the wear on the brakes is from throwing away energy gained from high priced fuel, except for that needed to climb/decend grades. :(

One would think, with all the complaints about high fuel costs, that on level ground, folks would automatically nearly avoid using brakes at all???
 
George Willer":33g32jcv said:
It would be interesting if someone could compute the amount of extra and unnecessary fuel required to wear out a set of brake calipers??? I'll bet it's a lot! All the wear on the brakes is from throwing away energy gained from high priced fuel, except for that needed to climb/decend grades. :(

One would think, with all the complaints about high fuel costs, that on level ground, folks would automatically nearly avoid using brakes at all???

There was a story on AOL a while ago about "hypermilers" who do just that, George. They do some illegal things...like gliding through stop signs and such...but most of their tactics are interesting. They let the vehicle slow down up a grade by easing up on the gas and then make up the time on the downhill side of the grade. They DON'T use cruise control on the highway. They use the lightest weight oil recommended. Using these and other techniques, they regularly achieve 35-40 mpg in an SUV and close to 80 in compact cars! Course, it may take them 20 minutes longer to get where they are going, but at least they are saving money!

I would think that they also use less of their brakes, too...

Mike in La Crosse, WI
 
George Willer":1o37hiqm said:
It would be interesting if someone could compute the amount of extra and unnecessary fuel required to wear out a set of brake calipers??? I'll bet it's a lot! All the wear on the brakes is from throwing away energy gained from high priced fuel, except for that needed to climb/decend grades. :(

One would think, with all the complaints about high fuel costs, that on level ground, folks would automatically nearly avoid using brakes at all???

That is a lot of energy, to be sure! It might open up some eyes to calculate a set of brakes into gallons of gasoline. People use both the brake and accelerator like on-off switches!

Folks are up in arms about the price of fuel but not reflecting in their driving habits. On I-95, they think that interstate number is the minimum speed but I-895 isn't quite that fast.
 
Somewhere......can't remember where I read it........but a study was done on this subject. Brake usage was converted to a heat factor and numerous "stops" were performed from the same speed and same distance used each time. The only thing changed was the breaking point.
The jist of the study from what I remember was that it took an equal amount of energy to stop the vehicle each time. However, by opting to stop the vehicle late in the fixed distance.....more fuel was consumed in maintaining speed late in the distance.....and that same amount of energy was applied over a shorter time(distance) yeilded a higher heat value, and heat was the consuming agent of the brake pad material. Carbon and ceramic were a couple of the materials used and compared. As far as those results......I think I nodded off at that point....like you guy probably will by now! LOL 8) 8) 8) Yaawwwwnn.
 
Regenerative brakes are slowly but surely starting to make their way into automobiles now too - mostly on hybrids for now. Golf carts have had them for years. Instead of turning the brake force into heat, it turns it into electrical energy to recharge batteries.
 
Bigdog":1kq9jjvt said:
I don't know what they are teaching (if anything) to students in driver's education classes any more...
In my observation, here's what they're teaching:

1. You are the only one on the road...do what ever elevates your self-esteem.
2. When on a multi-lane road...drive in the left lane at all costs.
3. The speed limit is whatever the sign says...plus 20.
4. Drive as close as you possibly can to the car in front of you...if you can see that old geezer's eyes in the mirror, you can tell what he's going to do next.
5. Fully reclining the seat makes you look cool.
6. The cell phone goes in your left hand, your drink goes in your right hand, your cigarette goes in whatever's left.

You can add your own, based on your observations. :D
 
7. When listening to music...turn the bass all the way up to the point where it rattles windows. Other people will enjoy it as well.......even at service stations! :evil: :evil:
 
BRAKES?--what is that?--HHHMMMM!!!---Didn't know cars had any such thing, never seen anybody stop at red lights or stop signs around here! ---I hardly use them except when pullin' the big trailer!--don't need to if you drive with common sense!---I downshift a lot after slowing down long before reaching my stoppin point, pisses off the guy behind me!--but who cares! thanks; sonny
 
Driver's ed teaches people how to pass the driver's test in your particular state. Anything else you gotta figure out on your own, I'm thinking most are using Race Car video games.

Those hypermilers are some strange folks! They give excellent insight on where energy is wasted and how some compulsions should not be played out behind the wheel. A guy at work has a relative who is part of a hypermiling group, he rode with that guy one time. Got out of the car and kissed the ground when that trip finished.
 
I guess I'm doing good with my trucks.

2001 Chevy Silverado, 138,000 miles with the original brake pads. 4 wheel disc brake system.

2003 GMC Sanoma, 108,000 miles with the original brake pads and shoes.
 
Carl, Maybe all extra heat generated by unnecessary braking by teenagers is the real cause of global warming. Would you email Al Gore and get his opinion?
:D :D

Bob
 
I read some of the hypermiler sites, and just realized I have been using some of their driving tactics for years, though very cautiously when in heavy traffic. I normally accelerate slowly and smoothly, and coast into stops. I also let my speed fall off some 5 or 10mph) on hills, then slowly pick it up again going down the other side. also, My new truck, which I bought equipped for pulling a trailer gets lousy mileag5, but by dropping my speed form 75 to 60 I can get about a 15 to 20% increase in mileage. I do use the cruise to let my foot and leg rest, but only on level ground. In hills I turn it off.
 
Back
Top