Ebay 1st time user question (Bad)

Maybe it's because I'm old and stodgy but I wasn't sure what an imac was. I looked it up and found they're a computer selling for well over $1000. If I bought one for $25 and it worked right out of the box I can't imagine complaining about the seller.

Are you SURE you think the seller in an auction owes you warranty protection? :twisted: :roll:
 
GW wrote:
Maybe it's because I'm old and stodgy but I wasn't sure what an imac was.
Well GW, you may be old and stodgy, but you have a point. My thoughts on the matter was about what if the seller had paid the shipping charges and sent another unit to replace the one that started working overnight? So, I guess it's not a black and white issue. I probably sell more than I buy on Ebay, but it's been a mostly good experience for me. I do believe that the seller has to give a positive feedback as soon as the item is paid for. The buyer has done all that he can do. Sure, that places a burden on the seller. But isn't that the way it should be? I know that sellers may say as an excuse for delaying the feedback that unreasonable buyers have had too high of expectations and given negative feedback, and certainly that will happen occasionally. But the system must have checks and balances for it to work.
I think I've always agreed with Rudi on just about anything, but I believe that buying on Ebay is much more than "caveat emptor". The buyer is not impotent is achieving a fair transaction.
It's been good to me, and I've found that people all over are fairminded. Come to think of it, though, the people I deal with are mostly farmers and collectors and people like us. So you would be dealing with people with certain values, IMHO.
Larry
 
RustyFarmall":2fsifciy said:
Feedback cannot be honestly left until the transaction is complete. As a seller, I do not feel that the transaction is complete until I know that the customer is satisfied and happy. The only way I can possibly know if the customer is happy is by reading the feedback that he or she leaves for me. Therefore, in order for any feedback to be totally honest, the buyer must leave it first.

I couldn't agree LESS. I am a buyer and a seller on eBay. When I am a buyer, at the point that payment has been made and the seller notified, my half of the transaction is COMPLETE. Buyer feedback should be given at this time. Giving or getting feedback is NOT part of the transaction. Too many sellers (and you may not be one of them) wait to see what kind of feedback they get from the buyer, in order to rebut or retaliate if it's not good. This is not the intended purpose of feedback.
 
I used to feel the same way, and always left positive feedback the moment the item was paid for, but it took only one instance of a buyer leaving negative feedback, for no reason other than the fact that he left negative on every transaction, for me to change my policy on feedback.
 
RustyFarmall":z2zyyzi2 said:
I used to feel the same way, and always left positive feedback the moment the item was paid for, but it took only one instance of a buyer leaving negative feedback, for no reason other than the fact that he left negative on every transaction, for me to change my policy on feedback.

Can a seller refuse to sell to an unrated or trouble-prone or questionable buyer?

Prompt receipt of money should invoke immediate positive feedback. You would have received negative feedback for the buyer regardless of your policy. The seller can respond to a buyer's negative feedback, exposing the other side of the story. It's easy pick out the scoundrels when reading feedback comments, eBay has their share of high-maintanence customers.

If a seller does not give feedback for the payment, I don't give feedback for the auction. I should get feedback concerning my part of the agreement when it occurs, not after the sellers decides if I'm happy or not with the product or shipping or whatever.
 
I was looking at excavators today on Ebay and there was one for sale with the first paragraph toasting a previous snipper who backed out afterwards because his wife wouldn't give him the money. It was toasty roasty.
 
Don McCombs":2jx4ekt5 said:
RustyFarmall":2jx4ekt5 said:
Feedback cannot be honestly left until the transaction is complete. As a seller, I do not feel that the transaction is complete until I know that the customer is satisfied and happy. The only way I can possibly know if the customer is happy is by reading the feedback that he or she leaves for me. Therefore, in order for any feedback to be totally honest, the buyer must leave it first.

I couldn't agree LESS. I am a buyer and a seller on eBay. When I am a buyer, at the point that payment has been made and the seller notified, my half of the transaction is COMPLETE. Buyer feedback should be given at this time. Giving or getting feedback is NOT part of the transaction. Too many sellers (and you may not be one of them) wait to see what kind of feedback they get from the buyer, in order to rebut or retaliate if it's not good. This is not the intended purpose of feedback.
Don, I don't agree with you from the buyer's side. Yes, when the buyer sends payment his responsibility has ended, but his involvement has NOT until he receives the merchandise in good condition. The seller's responsibility ends when he ships the merchandise, packaged PROPERLY and PROMPTLY. At that point he can and should leave his feedback based on the buyer's timely communication and payment. Once the buyer receives the package, promptly and in good condition, then appropriate feedback is in order. I've seen and heard of many complaints because of timing and condition. The condition factor of the package can be the fault of the shipping medium and then the buyer has his "beef with them. If it's poorly packaged and protected then he still has an issue with the seller.
 
Lurker Carl, Yes you can block a buyer and you can refuse to sell to someone with lets say less than 20 feedbacks. I have always left feedback as soon as the buyer pays. It has only burned me once. Guy complained that books were not worth what he paid so I refunded him all his $$ including shipping and he still left me really bad feedback and sent nasty e-mails also. I then had a chance to add on my rebuttal that folks just need to look at his history. most folks look at negatives and decide whether to deal with you or not. I love life, it's just a few people that screw it up :wink: :wink: Grump
 
Denny,

I kinda think we're saying the same thing, but in a different way. The bottom line is that the seller provides feedback first, then the buyer. Not the other way around. :D
 
I don't quite get it being this was my 1st time buying, I was sending and receiving e mails from the seller of the Mac and it was all smooth until the last e mail where I asked for a 100% refund after that I got no reply so I sent another e mail and it came back as undeliverable any way to make a short story of this he then gave me a positive feed back even tho he knew I was not happy withh the Mac I in turn did not give him any feed back because my thoughts were negative and I had read alot of his responses that he gave to negative feed back and he slamed these people with in your face rude comments, so with that I decided that no feed back is best for me. In the future I will read feed back to decide if that person is the type of person I want to do busines with, I think I can at least get an idea what this person business maners are like from his responses.
 
If the seller has already left the feedback for you, you can then go ahead and leave negative for him, and he cannot retaliate because he can only leave feedback once, and he has already done that. If indeed the transaction was less than desirable, you need to leave negative for him. You need to do your part to alert future buyers that this seller is not a good seller, and should be avoided.
 
Lurker Carl":2mpafwt0 said:
RustyFarmall":2mpafwt0 said:
I used to feel the same way, and always left positive feedback the moment the item was paid for, but it took only one instance of a buyer leaving negative feedback, for no reason other than the fact that he left negative on every transaction, for me to change my policy on feedback.

Can a seller refuse to sell to an unrated or trouble-prone or questionable buyer?

Yes he can I have my account set up not to sell to buyers that have - feedback
David
 
Rusty wrote,
and he cannot retaliate because he can only leave feedback once
The seller has an opportunity to reply to a feedback, either pos or neg. It just doesn't count in the feedback totals.
What I understood Jackman to say, is that, historically, the seller would retort to a buyers neg feedback in an abusive way. After reading the comments he would rather not be publicly vilified in a similar manner.
I can understand that, but it appears that the seller structures his replies in such a manner for that very reason.
Larry
 
RustyFarmall":2j8jrxap said:
You can also add a troublesome buyer to your blocked bidder list, and he or she will not be able to bid or buy from you.

That's what I would do in this case. Warranty on a $25 computer that works right out of the box? :P
 
Back
Top