Dog Vaccinations

lyle11

501 Club
There is a belief by some today that dogs are over-vaccinated which leads to more health problems than the risk of getting the disease you are vaccinating to prevent. Humans typically get one vaccination that lasts for life. Why do dogs need one every year? Is it just a money-maker for veterinarians? Some studies show that vaccines for distemper, for example, protect the dog for 4 years or more. I’m not cheap when it comes to my dogs, but I don’t want to harm them by over-vaccinating.

You can get what is called a titer test that will tell you if the vaccine is still active and avoid an unnecessary shot, but at my vet it cost $100 per test and then it is just a snapshot in time and can’t tell you when or if the dog will need a booster in the future.

At this point I have elected to get the vaccines but less frequently. Like maybe every 2 years rather than annually. Kind of like a balance between the 2 schools of thought.

Has anybody ever got a titer test for their dog or looked into this?

Also, you’ll hear people say: dog food is for dogs and people food is for people. But, others say many commercial dog foods have more carbs than dogs need which leads to disease like cancer being farvmore common today than 20+ years ago. We had a German Shepherd when I was a kid back in the 60s-70s that lived to 17 years old that never ate dog food it’s entire life. So, I give my dogs some people food but no sugared food, bready food or foods with salt or spices.

I don’t think there has been any definitive study on which way leads a healthier, longer life. I am just curious if any other dogs lovers have looked into this. I have kind of taken a balanced approach between the two ideas.
 
Not all human immunizations are for life, some are and some are not.

Dog and cat immunizations and the associated titer levels may not be well researched and hence the schedules are based on assumptions and educated guesses as well as the economic benefit to the vet. However, I expect most vets are going with recommendations of their professional organizations and state laws and not participating in any less than honorable money making scheme.

As the titer levels, over time, are researched more closely I expect the immunization schedule will change significantly but not to the level of all shots giving lifetime immunity. The human lifetime immunity is also being re-looked at and some of those lifetime shots may end up being repeated at some time.
 
Landreo, Thanks for the feedback. My main concern is doing harm from over vaccination but, like you said, it will probably change significantly as more research is done. I don’t believe the vast majority of vets are vaccinating just make money. I hope this is being studied and there is more definitive information so I can feel comfortable that I am doing the right thing for my dogs. There are some real extreme opinions out there on this subject.

I guess I must be overdue of some vaccinations because I’m 60 and other than a tetanus shot, I haven’t had a vaccination in over 50 years.
 
lyle11":r3fl48c9 said:
I guess I must be overdue of some vaccinations because I’m 60 and other than a tetanus shot, I haven’t had a vaccination in over 50 years.
Strongly suggest you visit your nearest medical clinic and get up dated on your mecdical shots.
 
If you haven't had a kid in the last 10 years, you may be amazed at how many vaccinations are available. Seems like the kids get a booster or a new vaccine every 2-3 years.
Check in your area, but here we only are legally required to vaccinate for rabies. Lots of others are available, but your vet will do what you ask to have done. They will be very glad to upsell more products though.
 
I checked with my wife and our 2 dogs and 5 cats get yearly shots. That does seem excessive although the rabies shot is required by law. I asked her to speak with the vet to extent that time. Have to see if the vet goes along with that plan.

Humans over 60 may benefit from a shingles shot, pneumonia ( also know as the old man's best friend since death by this method is relatively painless) , flu shot. I got all the deployment shots many times in the Army, should be good for a while. The military does check titers for new recruits to limit the number of shots, not to save the new soldiers, but to save money since the shots are expensive.
 
Eugene, I seriously had no idea there were these people vaccinations. My wife works in the emergency department of a hospital and has to get a flu shot. Not gonna get any shots but thanks for letting me know. I don’t even have a family doctor because I’ve had no need for it.
 
BTW, I took my dogs back to their original vet last week and he said that studies have found that the Distemper/Parvovirus 1 year vaccination is good for 3 years. Some vets offer 3 year Distemper/parvovirus vaccinations but it sounds like a waste of money if the 1 year protects them for 3 years. I’m not a vet and I’m not trying to tell anybody how to take care of their dogs, but it’s worth keeping on top of the latest findings. I’m not cheap when it comes to my dogs. I’m just trying to avoid unnecessary vaccinations that could harm them. Here we have leptospirosis that can be deadly and they need that vaccination annually so it depends on the vaccination.
 
If you have a local family medical facility that is affiliated with a large medical group, you should at least go in get a shot or two and get on their patient list.

I use a small family orientated medical facility that is part of a large medical group. The local medical facility is staffed by an MD and a nurse practitioner. If they cannot take care of my medical problem they will refer me to the well staffed medical center.

At 74 years of age, medical problems creep up on me. Tomorrow I go in for a referral for a cortisone shot in the right hip. Taking 3 pain pills a day.

Getting ready for a gall bladder surgery. Have pills for the nausea. No alcohol for two weeks, then another blood test.
 
There are a couple of other common diseases, besides the ones Landro listed, that you should get the shots for.

Came back to the USA after a long tour overseas, routine physical, had hepatitis. 1 blood test a month for 3 months before the disease cleared up.

The VA sent me for a series of vaccinations including getting a blood test for HIV. Told the Doc that I had been blood tested for 20 years in the military and no HIV. Doc told me that if I didn't get retested he would hound me until I did.

Monday, after getting an appointment for the cortisone injection, stopped by the surgeon's office who is going to do the gall bladder removal. Was told that I had to get a medical clearance from a MD before he would do the surgery. So, back to the local medical clinic for an appointment with the MD. Another physical, more blood tests.
 
Back
Top