Decision 2006

I do agree that the "system" is broken in almost every way possible. I did vote but I agree with much of what Tom has stated. My motivation to vote is to do what our Founding Father's had originally intended for a "democratic" government. For one branch to "check" the other. A republican president needs a democratic congress and vice versa. An oversimplification, however, in a nation that is so devided and polarized, "gridlock" is not a bad alternative. At the end of the day, if nothing is accomplished in the legislature, the voters will force change. On the other hand, what comes to be legislation will have to be a compromise between the two ideologies. Public service in the manner for which it was intended does not exist anymore. By and large we have to choose between candidates who have personal wealths well into the millions and have very little perspective from where most of the country sits. The motivation for these individuals is not to serve the public but rather to take their private sector success to the public sector. Another "notch" on the resume to include lots of "perks" and a legacy of some sort. It almost does not matter who the candidate is but rather where the "power" needs to shift and who needs to "check" who. Change can only occur with better voter turn out which has been pathetic for a long time and I can certainly understand why.

Paul
 
I agree cecil,
We pretty much knew who our new Gov was going to be. And his oponint was just a card filler I think. And from what I heard on the sunday morning debates none stood for what I needed them to do for me. Actually this may end being a thing that puts me under. I know its time for change but I just wish that the 35000 calls and votes that a bunch of us did to spitzer were really heard he looked really concerned at first and our person that met with him had high hopes then he decided it was part of the waste he needs to get rid of and will probly go after us as soon as he takes office. It was either take on big INS and do whats right for the worker, or take on the inj worker and do what he thinks will get rid of waste .We believe he WILL be hurting the worker SAD SAD but maybe change bad in one way will make up for something in a good way.

JON
 
I was amazed that 65% of Sunni's voted in Iraq's recent national elections. This despite death threats. I hope we beat that in this country. I voted because I love to complain
 
Souc10 said:
My motivation to vote is to do what our Founding Father's had originally intended for a "democratic" government.

I usually don't get involved too deep into politics, just state my opinion and exercise my right (and obligation) to vote. I've always wondered though, what the words "democratic Government" means. Our founding Fathers were vehemently against any type of democratic Government. The words aren't even in the Constitution and a democratic Government couldn't possibly had lasted 200 plus years. That why they formed a "republic" Government. (yes, there is a differance) I think we should do away with Democrats and Republicans and just have "Representatives".
 
Merlin:

I used the term "democratic" in quotations as it was intended to be somewhat facetious. Indeed the original government was a republic and I agree that the two party system needs to be abolished.

Paul
 
I've always wondered though, what the words "democratic Government" means. Our founding Fathers were vehemently against any type of democratic Government. The words aren't even in the Constitution and a democratic Government couldn't possibly had lasted 200 plus years.

The use of the word "democratic", is a form of the word democracy.

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/democracy

Perhaps an unfortunate name for party affliation. Some use "liberal", conservative", moderate, independant....lefttist....right wing.et al.
If the Whigs were to return....wonder where they would fit in?



I do agree that the "system" is broken in almost every way possible. I did vote but I agree with much of what Tom has stated. My motivation to vote is to do what our Founding Father's had originally intended for a "democratic" government. For one branch to "check" the other. A republican president needs a democratic congress and vice versa. An oversimplification, however, in a nation that is so devided and polarized, "gridlock" is not a bad alternative. At the end of the day, if nothing is accomplished in the legislature, the voters will force change. On the other hand, what comes to be legislation will have to be a compromise between the two ideologies. Public service in the manner for which it was intended does not exist anymore. By and large we have to choose between candidates who have personal wealths well into the millions and have very little perspective from where most of the country sits. The motivation for these individuals is not to serve the public but rather to take their private sector success to the public sector. Another "notch" on the resume to include lots of "perks" and a legacy of some sort. It almost does not matter who the candidate is but rather where the "power" needs to shift and who needs to "check" who. Change can only occur with better voter turn out which has been pathetic for a long time and I can certainly understand why.

Paul

Well written post!
 
Merlin":1e2ptluh said:
Souc10, we are in total agreement.
I also agree.

In my opinion the worst thing that has ever happened in U.S. politics was when several years ago the Supreme Court ruled that due to free speech candidates could not be held legally responsible for anything they said while campaigning. That gave them license to lie in any way the wanted.
 
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/democracy[/url]

Perhaps an unfortunate name for party affliation. Some use "liberal", conservative", moderate, independant....lefttist....right wing.et al.
If the Whigs were to return....wonder where they would fit in?



Good question. Yep, I've read the modern definitions of democracy. The general consensus is, this is our founding Fathers thoughts of democracy and made sure the word wasn't in the constitution, and I am "assuming" that they left it out to be sure people didn't think we were living in a democracy instead of a republic. Sometimes it gets very confusing to me. Just when I think I have if figured out, someone comes up with something that changes my mind.

"Democracy: A government of the masses. Authority derived through mass meeting or any form of ‘direct' expression. Results in mobocracy. Attitude towards laws is that the will of the majority shall regulate, whether it is based upon deliberation or governed by passion, prejudice or impulse, without restraint or regard to consequences. Results in demagogism, license, agitation, discontent, anarchy."

Republic - "A constitutionally limited government of the representative type, created by a written Constitution--adopted by the people and changeable (from its original meaning) by them only by its amendment--with its powers divided between three separate Branches: Executive, Legislative and Judicial. Here the term "the people" means, of course, the electorate. Its purpose is to control The Majority strictly, as well as all others among the people, primarily to protect The Individual’s God-given, unalienable rights and therefore for the protection of the rights of The Minority, of all minorities, and the liberties of people in general."

James Madison: In a pure democracy, "there is nothing to check the inducement to sacrifice the weaker party or the obnoxious individual." At the 1787 Constitutional Convention, Edmund Randolph said, " ... that in tracing these evils to their origin every man had found it in the turbulence and follies of democracy." John Adams said, "Remember, democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts, and murders itself. There was never a democracy yet that did not commit suicide." Chief Justice John Marshall observed, "Between a balanced republic and a democracy, the difference is like that between order and chaos." In a word or two, the founders knew that a democracy would lead to the same kind of tyranny the colonies suffered under King George III.

The framers gave us a Constitution that is replete with undemocratic mechanisms. One that has come in for recent criticism and calls for its elimination is the Electoral College. In their wisdom, the framers gave us the Electoral College so that in presidential elections large, heavily populated states couldn't democratically run roughshod over small, sparsely populated states.
 
Tom wrote,

If your candidate wins, and later, you find out that he was party to some sort of scandal that caused the suffering of people, I would merely ask that you take your share of the blame, because it was your "exercising your right" which ultimately contributed to the process of cause and effect that allowed such a scandal to take place.

“suffering” Who is suffering? What is the definition of this suffering? And why are they suffering? And who must suffer to keep them from suffering? It’s great to be infinitely ideological and surreal when one isn’t required to have any answers on how to make things right, or have any expectations of taking responsibility for their actions once they attempt to make things right.

After all is said and done, the people WE voted into office must be held accountable for their actions. Bush needs to tell us why he turned Iraq into another Vietnam. (I know what I’m talking about) The opposing party needs to explain why they were Hellbent on sabotaging Bush’s agenda at every opportunity.

A litmus test is an excellent way to measure the pH of a substance. But it should stop there. I am very capable of picking and choosing what I believe in and what I don’t. The American public is being used by the special interest groups that have proven time and again that we can be manipulated. What is wrong in believing that if our Creator gave us the intelligence and desire to use research to improve the quality of life, why not use that technology? If gay people want to get married, so what? But they must conform to the same laws as heterosexuals. Let them go through a nasty divorce. They may rethink their decision.

What is wrong in believing that when a country is committed to fighting a war, the end result must be that the opposition is annihilated. No pussy footing.

I voted, and I make no excuses. I accept the will of the majority, regardless of my private feelings.

I respect you Tom. But I don’t always agree with you.

Larry
 
Larry:

Now this is a post I can understand, agree with and wholeheartedly stand behind. Well said, well done..
congrats.gif
. Not only that, but it applies to Canada as well as the US and probably every government in the WORLD today :!:

Accountablility and Responsibility are two of my favourite mantra's for all those who hold office of some sort that affects their family/community/nation.

Alas, until personal greed, desire for fame and fortune and a yearning to somehow be remembered in the history books is removed from the mix, I am afraid we will have a hard time finding a majority of Good Honest Trustworthy men and women to give of themselves selflessly to serving their nations to balance those who seek fame and self import above the common good.
 
Rudi":2ha8jw7g said:
Alas, until personal greed, desire for fame and fortune and a yearning to somehow be remembered in the history books is removed from the mix, I am afraid we will have a hard time finding a majority of Good Honest Trustworthy men and women to give of themselves selflessly to serving their nations to balance those who seek fame and self import above the common good.

This was done at the birth of the USA but seems to have become quite rare. I was given a book The Course of Mexican History by the grateful widow of the author. The father of Mexico was captured by the Spanish and executed although he was a priest and the second in command was also captured and executed. The third in command was a disaster. His first official act was to have himself declared the Emperor of Mexico. He was eventually tried for treason. He was sentenced to death but allowed to leave the country and not be executed as long as he stayed out of the country. We were very lucky in the men who attended the birth of this nation. It has been done and could be in the future. My father ran for office but loss the primary by 14 votes on the recount. His comment: I would have made a better congressman but he (the guy who won) will do ok for OK.

He still thought that way years later.

There are good men and good women out there but they are discourage.

Richard

Mario Coumo was offered more money than Mickey Mantle to play ball for the NY Yankees but chose to go to Fordam Law School. I may not agree with his political philosophy but I have nothing bad to say about his character.
 
Larry...

First off.....idealogically, on an issue-by-issue count, I'm probably in agreement with you on 99% of things...............

The issues I can stomach......it's people who are multifaceted and duplicitous in nature, and cannot be trusted, therefore to be who they say they are. I find this to be particularly true of politicians.......

Yes. From a certain point of view, I suppose I do hide behind a wall of ideology and abstracts.... Perhaps this makes me sound a bit surreal.....

You see that, however is a spiritual matter.....I do believe that one's actions, and one's motivation must be accounted for. This also includes the chain of consequences, through the laws of cause and effect, that come from one's actions, and motivations.....

Eastern religions call this Karma.......

So, if I vote for Bob, thinking he is a good man, Bob wins, and later, Bob is found guilty of sexually abusing congressional paiges.....well, then I am just as guilty as Bob......via the laws of cause and effect....... I go to hell right along with Bob......

I believe this to be true of every man, not just me, by the way........

I find that the current 2 party system makes it too easy for a candidate to conceal his true nature. He could be a real monster, and let's face it, once in a while, we elect one.

Now, as far as suffering goes......who is suffering?? Everyone!!! In one way or another everyone is suffering. Members of our government, even at the lowest levels, are in a position to reduce suffering, or increase it.....(even the lowly clerk at the DMV could make your day go well, or poorly, depending on her choice, can't she??) .........

Reducing suffering everywhere they see it SHOULD be the #1 priority of all good men, and I'll admit that a lot of people do put a great deal of thought into the problem, albeit unknowingly.......

I don't always agree with you, either, Larry.....and isn't that just perfectly marvelous?? Otherwise we'd have very little to talk about..... :shock:
 
Well Eugene,

There's fodder for quite a few threads there, isn't there???

The fuel issue is one that, so far, no one is taking very seriously, although it may mean the survival of our "freedoms" as a race as we know them, as I've warned time and again.

The Bush administration has covered the largest amount of ground on these issues.....in that, there has been the greatest amount of progress working towards alternative fuels under Bush, than any previous administration.

While from my perspective, it is much too little, and much too late, I have to consider the possibility that anyone else might do worse......

The fact that on the mountain above me, they are now constructing massive wind towers tells me that at least the proper incentives are in place, and evidently working.

Are we going to meet the Kyoto Protocols.....well, no....and, predictably, the rest of the world hates us for it.....does it matter??......no, because Kyoto is a joke, and a bad one at that...... It is as if $100 were needed to save a dying child, and Kyoto is offering $0.25, while the US is offering $0.10.......there truly is not much difference......

The fact that the auto industry is now concerned about the environmental impact of the products they make is a good sign......because any "real" tackling of the fossil fuel issue needs to come from the private sector....the fact that they expect the government to help solve the problem for them, however, is regrettable, and is the same claptrap we've been hearing from them for the last 40 years.......
 
400. Boy, we are almost in 100% agreement.

My initial take, first read, was that the traditional US auto industry manufacturers was heading back to Congress to ask for another bailout. Funny thing. The builders of foreign named autos, built in the US, appear to be making money.

Alternative energy incentives are in place. Throughout the midwest wind turbines are going up at a pretty good clip. Almost as fast as the wind turbines are going up, state and local governments are looking for ways to extract revenue.

Guthrie County, Iowa recently passed an law exempting the equipment and buildings used to generate electricity from wind from property tax. If I have everyting correct, the land would still be taxed. If I read the article correctly, Guthrie County Supervisors enacted the law to reduce or eliminate efforts by the State of Iowa to capture additional revenue from wind powered electric plants.

Kind of an aside. I was watching an alternative energy program on TV. The program sponsor stated that he/his organization kept records on every gallon of biodiesel fuel and ethanol produced. They pay the federal government 16 cents a gallon tax.

Eugene
 
Well.....

Of course, in the ultimate, alternative energy producers will need to be taxed on the profit they make.....it's only fair....however, a good incentive to change the bulk of our energy use from fossil fuels to alternative energy sources, might be to tax fossil fuel usage more heavily.....

Why not?? We tax alcohol and tobacco because they are bad for us.... Fossil Fuels are just as bad for us.....possibly far worse, in the long run.... I pay twice what the citizens of Virginia pay for a pack of cigarettes, and I know that they are taxed plenty heavy in Virginia to begin with. I don't really get angry over it, because I understand the nature of the tax.....

There is a sad side to all of this, of course, because the US is sitting on coal reserves, of all 3 types, to carry us well into the 22nd century. We are the elephant, sitting before a mountain of peanuts, and expected not to eat any.... In a way, we are an elephant who has become allergic to peanuts....... :D

Getting our electric power sources weaned off of fossil fuels would be substantially more beneficial than attacking the motor fuel issue.....This, however, does not mean that we should ignore that matter in the meanwhile..... It just seems that we have the technology and the incentives to work on the electric power issues right now, while we're working on the motor fuel problem for the future...
 
Rather than try and come up with some "new" reason to vote, I chose to look back to the wise counsel of our founders.
This from Noah Webster is quite relevant even to this day.

When you become entitled to exercise the right of voting for public officers, let it be impressed on your mind that God commands you to choose for rulers, "just men who will rule in the fear of God." The preservation of government depends on the faithful discharge of this duty; if the citizens neglect their duty and place unprincipled men in office, the government will soon be corrupted; laws will be made, not for the public good so much as for selfish or local purposes; corrupt or incompetent men will be appointed to execute the laws; the public revenues will be sqandered on unworthy men; and the rights of the citizens will be violated or disregarded. If a republican government fails to secure public prosperity and happiness, it must be because the citizens neglect the divine commands, and elect bad men to make and administer the laws.

[Noah Webster, History of the United States (New Haven: Durrie & Peck, 1832), pp. 336-337, ¦49.]

Peter
 
Peter Person":3sk7cn95 said:
When you become entitled to exercise the right of voting for public officers, let it be impressed on your mind that God commands you to choose for rulers, "just men who will rule in the fear of God."

Peter,

Of course....but therein lies the rub.....

of course....."just men who will rule in the fear of God." doesn't mean....."simply men who will rule in the fear of God"....does it......it means "men who are just as in righteous of thought, word, and deed.

Find me one of these, on whom you would bet your immortal soul.....seriously......and literally......and I might be motivated........
 
Peter Person":i4vvgwz2 said:
Rather than try and come up with some "new" reason to vote, I chose to look back to the wise counsel of our founders.
This from Noah Webster is quite relevant even to this day.

When you become entitled to exercise the right of voting for public officers, let it be impressed on your mind that God commands you to choose for rulers, "just men who will rule in the fear of God." The preservation of government depends on the faithful discharge of this duty; if the citizens neglect their duty and place unprincipled men in office, the government will soon be corrupted; laws will be made, not for the public good so much as for selfish or local purposes; corrupt or incompetent men will be appointed to execute the laws; the public revenues will be sqandered on unworthy men; and the rights of the citizens will be violated or disregarded. If a republican government fails to secure public prosperity and happiness, it must be because the citizens neglect the divine commands, and elect bad men to make and administer the laws.

[Noah Webster, History of the United States (New Haven: Durrie & Peck, 1832), pp. 336-337, ¦49.]

Peter

Peter:

These are truly wonderful words which describe why each and every citizen in both our countries must excercise their franchise and vote for every single elected public office. If we do not, then we do not do as we are obligated to do.

I also think that it should be mandatory that ALL public Officials have to take mandatory Civics courses every few years to reaquaint themselves with not only their own obligations as to excercising their own franchise, but what their obligations are in accordance with representing those who elect them. Recall initiatives are fine, but if one does not understand why they are being recalled, then all is for naught.

I am glad you posted Noah Webster's thoughts on this.. as it is a clear definition of our obligation as citizens of our community, our province/state and our nations..

:!: :D 8) :D
 
Back
Top