Crate engine advice

Bob McCarty

Moderator
Staff member
Background: I have an 88 Chevy 2500 with 175,000 miles on it. Coolant leak has been diagnosed as blown head gasket or cracked head. This is my work truck, as we also have a 2002 Chevy Duramax (which is usually pulling the horse trailer). If I just have the head pulled it will be $500 to $1000+/- depending on what they find. The engine is also burning oil, although not badly. The mechanic (whom I have used for a long time) suggested that if I plan on keeping the truck for a minimum of 3 years, engine replacement would be preferable to head repair. In the last few years, front end and brake work has been done, tires are good, so those areas shouldn't be a problem anytime soon. The rebuilt engine (from Jasper) installed will be around $5000. I would still like to have a "beater", my wife thinks we can get by with one truck. I'm leaning towards keeping it, but may not be thinking about some negatives. Comments and suggestions are appreciated.

Thanks, Bob
 
I'll just say it is really nice to have a spare truck around. I might not go buy another one but I will keep the one I have even if I have to spend money on repairs.
 
Consider what the truck is worth as it sits today and what it will be worth after you spend $5000 on it. Can you trade in the truck and $5000 and get something better?
 
I haven't got any negatives. I have one more vehicle than drivers. Seems I always have a vehicle in the shop for repairs.

Got a 91 Dodge Dakota with 200K miles. Everything has been repaired or replaced since the family has owned the truck, 10 or 12 years. Excellent body. Priced a new Chrysler rebuilt motor, installed, some where between $4500- and $5000-. Plan is to use the truck until I need to replace the motor, then do so.

Few years ago I blew the motor in another pickup. Thought I would just go buy another pickup until I started pricing used pickups. They wanted $5K for a pickup with close to 200K miles. I had a factory rebuilt engine installed in the old pickup with a new radiator, check the drive train, steerings, brakes. Wound up with a completely rebuilt truck with the same old body for the same money folks wanted for a worn out truck.
 
Another way to look at is, you know the mechanicals of your truck now that you have replaced so much on it. If you take the $5000.00 and the value of your truck would it buy you a nice, newer truck? Keep in mind that buying that nice, newer truck could have hidden defects. You already know what you have. You could be buying someone elses troubles with a nice, newer truck. I am facing the same problem with Rosie's Tahoe, so this will be an interesting thread for me also.
 
Bob - how comfortable would you feel with the truck if you replaced the defective head / head gasket? What other major components may need replacing soon? Timing chain etc. You are talking a major difference in investment from $500 - $1000 to the $5000 for a rebuilt engine.
 
BD, I guess because it is burning oil and gas mileage has dropped, I'm not sure how long it would be until another major problem would occur.

Bob
 
Bob,

Jasper builds a fine engine, and I believe they have 3-year warranties. I think at least $1,500 of your $5,000 cost is for the installation, so for $3,500 you're getting one of the best rebuilt engines around. You could save a thousand or so getting a less-expensive rebuilt engine but then you'd lose the good warranty.

Considering what good trucks cost these days, I don't think you can go wrong with the rebuild.

As a matter of fact, if it were me and I was going to commit to the engine, I'd consider the condition of the tranny at the same time...save you a bunch of installation cost!

Corky
 
bob . you might take a look at powertrain products.com .i havent used their motor,but i think there a little less price wise than jasper. seems to have pretty good war. (4 year).iam also looking to replace my 4.7 liter in my 2002 dodge.
 
Well to be the devils advocate, take a long hard look at your truck. IF you do replace the motor, whats the condition of the rest of the drive train. Transmission, axle , body, and electrical ect. Right now with the economy, there are some smoking deals out there on trucks.

I wasn't in the market for a new truck, but my cousin was selling her house and buying another with property. To make the requirments for her new home loan, she had to reduce her debt to credit ratio. Meaning she had to either sell or payoff some of the items she had loans out on. She payed off her horse trailer, and decided to sell her tow rig since her new truck could handle her trailer. I wound up buying a 2000 F250 diesel. It's log book was filled with all of the services done to the truck since new, and runs like a champ. I wound up making a partial trade with my old truck to her so she has a beater farm truck. So it all worked out great for all in the end.

It might be better to repair it, and sell it outright. And look for a good used truck.

Later

Hank
 
Bob, one thing you have not mentioned, is how much the truck is used, and if it is 2 or 4wd. all of those things also figure in. If it is only used a couple thousand miles a year. If you drive it a lot, and/or it is 4wd that you use on the farm, etc. I would give the crate engine serious consideration. As has been mentioned though, you still have the transmission, universal joints, rear end, springs, etc. to consider, not to mention rust inside the fenders that you may not be seeing yet, though in your area that may not be a problem. As to mileage, don't just say I only use it a little, check your last inspection slip, oil log, or whatever you have to verify it's use, not just something off the top of your head. Most people do not realize the miles they drive the "beater".
 
Are you going to have replace one of the "good" vehicles in the next couple of years? Additional cost of insurance on a newer pickup? Licensing fees, local and state sales tax on purchasing a newer pickup? Personal property tax?

"Beater". Depends on what the pickup is used for. If during usage the pickup takes a beating - do you want to apply that type of damage to a newer pickup?

Big question. Are you going to be able to live with "mom" with your decision?
 
If this is a 350 i have a friend who bought a crate enginre new from chevy if i didn't misunderstand him it was around $2,600.

Jim
 
Jim Reid":2mzunwpo said:
If this is a 350 i have a friend who bought a crate enginre new from chevy if i didn't misunderstand him it was around $2,600.Jim
The estimated price was installed. In my case the estimated price included labor and some guesses as what other engine external components needed to be or should be replaced.
 
Update: After looking at the Powertrain website, it seemed like some of the local prices might be a little high on parts. I talked to a couple of tractor buddies who recommended a shop they use. I stopped by, their price for a new engine installed is $3500-3800. Even if they find a few add-ons when they get the engine out, I'll still be way ahead. This shop is a two man, in an out of the way location. It looked like you could eat off the floor. Based on the recommendation of two friends, I feel comfortable going there. The difference in cost "could" finance another Cub. :D I'll post an update when it's finished next month. Thanks for all the good advice.

Bob
 
Bob: What about a good used motor from a wreck or some other situation. I drive Saabs (I've heard all the Saab Story jokes thank you) and there's a Saab "graveyard" about an hour from me. I have bought wheels and tires, trannys and countless other parts for a fraction of the cost from a dealer. They stand behind their poducts and I've never had a problem. I've often gone there to find them dismantling a car with less than 10,000 miles that was totaled by the insurance company. Craig
 
Back
Top