cash for clunkers

I have two problems with this government program, in addition to it's short-sighted effects on the economy and automobile industry.

1. A brand spanking new vehicle costs well over what than I'm willing to pay for an item that loses a significant percentage of it's value as soon as I sign on the dotted line.

2. My "clunker" is worth considerably more to me than Uncle Sam is willing to pay for it.

I'd rather see that chunk of my tax dollars come back to my pocket without having to endure a car salesman holding me hostage for the better part of a day to purchase something I don't need.
 
When first announced, I had planned on up dating my 78 Cadillac to something my wife and daughter in-law would drive.

Found out that cars 25 years old and less are eligible. Over 25 years old - doesn't qualify.

Second issue is that you can only buy a new automobile, not a low milage used vehicle.

My third issue is that I am and will not go into or take on a debt for an automobile.

My guess is that most people driving automobiles worth less than $4500- can not afford a new vehicle. Or are like me, just out and out to frugil/cheap/gonna let someone else take the drive off the lot depreciation.
 
According to interviews on local news, a lot of people are coming into dealers and not qualifying, but due to dealer incentives, they are buying anyway. guess it is working to get more people deeper in debt.
 
Wall Street Journal had an article on the program. The article was semi-positive in nature. More people in the showrooms and some people buying.

Shortly after the plan was announced there were articles in online newspapers estimating that the program would not turn out as planned. Fewer total new vehicles sold than the government plans.

Wow, what an idea. Using tax money as an incentive to buy a new car. And two of the car companies, out of the several US based car companies, are US government owned.
 
This is the most stupid thing to ever have come out of Washington. This kind of Congressional mentality is what got our country into this mess in the first place. Spend what you don't have and damn the recession!
 
I totally agree with what everyone is saying here. Government has its place, but using my money to help people to buy cars….wow…. maybe I’m missing something about this.

As a joke from a financial site I visit when I get time this was written. Seriously, this is probably happening.


Am I the only one who jumped for joy when this passed? As a recent college graduate driving a 1996 Ford Explorer with 235,000 miles, yes it’s paid for, but I spend 200 a month on gas. Now I will be able to get 4500 off a brand new Honda civic coupe. Not every program will help everyone, but this one IS going to help me and instead of anyone complaining about it, please just go to work so your tax dollars can get me my new Honda Civic!!!!

Its after 6:00 am and I’m still inside….I better get going and try to make some money so this kid can buy his Honda.
 
Early this moring news stated that about 25,000 cars had been sold under this program through late Wednesday and nearly $96 million had been spent. Then this evening all of the $1 billion allocated had been spent.

Another late evening news program says Congress is concerned about running out of money for the program. And Congress is addressing the issue - taking up a plan to put more tax payer money into the program.

Guess we will have to see how and what transpired.
 
At the max of $4500 per transaction, that should equate to more than 222,222 vehicles sold over the last, what two weeks? Wonder if the gov't will release what the sales breakdown is between foreign, domestic and the new government owned companies. If only 25,000 vehicles have been sold under the program, it should be a blinding illustration of how wasteful our gov't is with our taxes.
 
As of this morning there is a backlog of 25,000 deals yet to go through, so talk is a suspending the program to get the paper work caught back up.

As a taxpayer I already own a protion of AIG as well as other assests on Wall Street and as far as I can see it has or never will be of any benefit to me, but I am paying anyway.

As a citizen of Lenawee County (ranked 63 out of the 80 counties @ 19% unemployment, that statistic is for the people that have not given up looking for work, in reality it is well over 25%) Michigan with arguably the worst unemployment in the nation, this program does impact me as well as others where it counts, on Main street.

The factories and suppliers are starting to call people back to work around here, will it stay? I hope so. All seven American car dealers in the county are on the program and are selling cars

I was very depressing that 326 properties went up for tax sale on Monday, with another 300 plus going on the block in November. I have lived here all my life and I have never seen so my abandoned homes as people leave everything to go somewhere eles. The house at the end of the road was abandoned overnight this spring, I drove by in the evening waved at the guy the next morning they are moved out lock stock and barrel with the keys in the mail box.

Living in Michigan and Lenawee County has not been fun for the last seven years, I hope this program helps us out,as the government programs prior to this have done nothing for me.

May be my next to last 2 cents

Mark
 
this is indeed an interesting goverment deal...a friend of mine works as a mechanic at a dealership...they are required to drain engine oil out of motor and pour a special oil with eggshells in it...and you guess it...start it up until it blows up...he says he is having a blast....first one lasted maybe 40 seconds
Robert (with the inside scoop for once) Miller
 
I like how well our floks in Washington planned, analyzed and implemented the program. And they want to run our health care system!
 
According to the noon TV news there were only 88,5?? vehicles sold under the Cash for Clunker program so far, to date. The plan calls for up to 250,000 clunkers to be turned in. 88K equals roughly 1/3 of the planned clunkers.
 
Could it be possible the government hopes to stimulate auto sales enough so GM and Chrysler can pay off some of the bailouts they got???
Mike
 
CubitisNH":3b8vlyta said:
Could it be possible the government hopes to stimulate auto sales enough so GM and Chrysler can pay off some of the bailouts they got???
Good luck on that one. According to a financial talk show last weekend. Take a guess how many new cars are going to be sold now that everyone who could replaced a vehicle under this program did?

England's government nationalized English automakers - didn't work. Germany tried the cash for clunker program - didn't work as well as planned. Could it be that Congress is following the lead of other nations?
 
Back
Top