Canadians

Rudi

501 Club
I received this in my email box a couple of times, but did not follow through and post.. shame on me. But I am proud of who and what we are as Canadians and proud of serving my country, and thought it would be useful to post. Just a different take I guess, but one that is pretty much on the mark in more than one way.

There is lots of talk of what we should or should not do in Iraq and Afghanistan.. but I liken these two countries to Germany, Italy and Japan in the first half of the previous century. Many of us are young enough to rememeber those days, and the decade or two that followed and what happened after.

History - tells you where you have been, where you are now and where you are headed. Withouth history, how can one know WHO they are???

Subject: British Newspaper Salutes Canada

This is a good read. It is funny how it took someone in England to put it into words...

Sunday Telegraph Article from today's UK wires:



Salute to a brave and modest nation
Kevin Myers, The Sunday Telegraph LONDON

Until the deaths of Canadian soldiers killed in Afghanistan, probably almost no one outside their home country had been aware that Canadian troops are deployed in the region. And as always, Canada will bury its dead, just as the rest of the world, as always will forget its sacrifice, just as it always forgets nearly everything Canada ever does.

It seems that Canada's historic mission is to come to the selfless aid both of its friends and of complete strangers, and then, once the crisis is over, to be well and truly ignored. Canada is the perpetual wallflower that stands on the edge of the hall, waiting for someone to come and ask her for a dance. A fire breaks out so she risks life and limb to rescue her fellow dance-goers, and suffers serious injuries. But when the hall is repaired and the dancing resumes, there is Canada, the wallflower still, while those she once helped glamorously cavort across the floor, blithely neglecting her yet again.

That is the price Canada pays for sharing the North American continent with the United States, and for being a selfless friend of Britain in two global conflicts. For much of the 20th century, Canada was torn in two different directions: It seemed to be a part of the old world, yet had an address in the new one, and that divided identity ensured that it never fully got the gratitude it deserved.

Yet its purely voluntary contribution to the cause of freedom in two world wars was perhaps the greatest of any democracy. Almost 10% of Canada 's entire population of seven million people served in the armed forces during the First World War, and nearly 60,000 died. The great Allied victories of 1918 were spearheaded by Canadian troops, perhaps the most capable soldiers in the entire British order of battle.

Canada was repaid for its enormous sacrifice by downright neglect, its unique contribution to victory being absorbed into the popular Memory as somehow or other the work of the "British." The Second World War provided a re-run. The Canadian navy began the war with a half dozen vessels, and ended up policing nearly half of the Atlantic against U-boat attack. More than 120 Canadian warships participated in the Normandy landings, during which 15,000 Canadian soldiers went ashore on D-Day alone.Canada finished the war with the third-largest navy and the fourth-largest air force in the world.

The world thanked Canada with the same sublime indifference as it had the previous time. Canadian participation in the war was acknowledged in film only if it was necessary to give an American actor a part in a campaign in which the United States had clearly not participated - a touching scrupulousness which, of course, Hollywood has since abandoned, as it has any notion of a separate Canadian identity.

So it is a general rule that actors and filmmakers arriving in Hollywood keep their nationality - unless, that is, they are Canadian.

Thus Mary Pickford, Walter Huston, Donald Sutherland, Michael J. Fox, William Shatner, Norman Jewison, David Cronenberg, Alex Trebek, Art Linkletter and Dan Aykroyd have in the popular perception become American, and Christopher Plummer, British. It is as if, in the very act of becoming famous, a Canadian ceases to be Canadian, unless she is Margaret Atwood, who is as unshakably Canadian as a moose, or Celine Dion, for whom Canada has proved quite unable to find any takers.

Moreover, Canada is every bit as querulously alert to the achievements of its sons and daughters as the rest of the world is completely unaware of them. The Canadians proudly say of themselves - and are unheard by anyone else - that 1% of the world's population has provided 10% of the world's peacekeeping forces. Canadian soldiers in the past half century have been the greatest peacekeepers on Earth - in 39 missions on UN mandates, and six on non-UN peacekeeping duties, from Vietnam to East Timor, from Sinai to Bosnia.

Yet the only foreign engagement that has entered the popular on-Canadian imagination was the sorry affair in Somalia , in which out-of-control paratroopers murdered two Somali infiltrators. Their regiment was then disbanded in disgrace - a uniquely Canadian act of self-abasement for which, naturally, the Canadians received no international credit.

So who today in the United States knows about the stoic and selfless friendship its northern neighbour has given it in Afghanistan?

Rather like Cyrano de Bergerac, Canada repeatedly does honourable things for honourable motives, but instead of being thanked for it, it remains something of a figure of fun.

It is the Canadian way, for which Canadians should be proud, yet such honour comes at a high cost. This past year more grieving Canadian families knew that cost all too tragically well

Oh, btw this is not meant to be a fire-starter. Simply something I saw that pretty much describes how many of us feel, and how the world actually preceives us..

Oh, don't forget Iron Mike (Lester B.) Pearson - who almost single-handedly created the UN Peacekeeping Forces, and who was a driving force with his Opponent John Diefenbaker in helping to create the UN.
 
Let's also not forget the role of Canadian citizens in the US military. I served with two Canadian helicopter pilots in Vietnam, and two finer soldiers you couldn't have found. Both enlisted in the US Army and went through flight training because, at the time, Canada did not have any aviation units serving in Vietnam. I'm proud to have known and served with them.

I wasn't aware of Canada's role in the formation of the United Nations. It's too bad that, through no fault of Canada, that organization has become a corrupt, anti-American, anti-democratic joke.
 
Hello all....

In truth we are talking about all the subtleties and intricacies of a love/hate quadrangle between the principle parties of:
Canada
UK
US
France
All hopping in and out of bed with each other for a period of 250 years.....

The fruits of these unions have been Democracy, Empire, and the fall of both.

In the end, we are also talking about 2 distinct periods as well, pre WWII, and post WWII..... each having very distinctly different causes and conditions.....

All in all, Rudi, I'd say that the view you posted is probably justified, if a little glum. But, if we are to embrace such a view, then, well, there is nothing to prevent us here to your south, as your Big, Dancing, Glamourous Brother, to embrace the rumblings of isolationism that we are hearing these days, because, in all honesty, they sound pretty tempting at times.

There is so much to be dissatisfied about with the world today, both from without and within, no matter where you live. Looking at all of that from the right angle makes you feel compassion for your fellow man. Looking at it from the wrong angle makes you miserable.....

Sometimes, not looking at it at all for a day or two is required as a needed break....

Oh, and BTW...no one here in the US ever thought (not for one millisecond) that Alex Trebec was American........LOL

addendum......

Here's the Wikipedia WWI death total page....

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_I_casualties

What is most tragically noticeable about WWI, is that more civilians died than did soldiers, and, more soldiers died of accidents and disease, than did of military wounds......

4 million civilian people died within the borders of the Ottoman Empire..... While these were Muslims and Orthodox Catholics, this does not make them expendable.....as most of the world seemed to feel at the time.

And we have the nerve to complain about not getting our "laurels as we feel due" in the case of Canada, or whine that the rest of the world doesn't like us, in the case of the US ........sheesh.....

Namaste,

--Tom
 
"Canada is the perpetual wallflower that stands on the edge of the hall, waiting for someone to come and ask her for a dance. A fire breaks out so she risks life and limb to rescue her fellow dance-goers, and suffers serious injuries. But when the hall is repaired and the dancing resumes, there is Canada, the wallflower still, while those she once helped glamorously cavort across the floor, blithely neglecting her yet again."


Hmm, this sounds familiar, like when I was growing up in southern Maine. Portland was considered a "backward" town by those "from away," and as my family was in the tourist business, we heard that a lot.

Nowadays southern Maine is THE place to live. Portland is no longer backward, but a sickeningly trendy city, sought after by upwardly mobile professionals "from away" who are driving property values into the stratosphere.

I like the way it was before. Nowadays, turn on the news and everyone hates the US. Nobody hates Canada. Rudi, you're lucky. Canada is a great place to live (taxes notwithstanding), and a great neighbor (their views on LNG tankers notwithstanding). :D
 
I too served with Canadian members in the Navy. I can relate to the feelings of Canadians being forgotten in the BIG picture. We need to somehow get the message across that we all share in the battle of freedom. A lot of US citizens don't or can't get the picture of what actually is going on in this fine world. The UN was supposed to be a great great thing but as most projects that involve the govt.-- well it went south. They do a lot of good but the bad that they do seems to outweigh all. We as well as the Canadians need to somehow get the message to the common everyday folk. I talked to quite a few boat dealers and they did not believe that Canadians were members of the U.S. forces and basicly told me I was full of crap. So point taken is we (too many) in the lower half as well as our northern half don't have a clue as to what is going on or who is involved in doing it. I don't mean all of us , but too many of us don't have a clue. The news media screams every day about the U.S. losses but fail to tell about our allies and friends loses. Why?? :?: We constantly refuse to learn from history. Oh well , I guess I'm done for now. God Bless all. (Good guys that is) Be good and be safe. Grump
 
grumpy":2u7gunm6 said:
The news media screams every day about the U.S. losses but fail to tell about our allies and friends loses. Why?? :?:
I beleive I have seen reports of allied losses most of the time there have been any. The reason you don't hear about allied casualities every day is because most days there simply aren't any. Rarely is there a day without US casualties.
 
Jim Becker":2wxky39u said:
grumpy":2wxky39u said:
The news media screams every day about the U.S. losses but fail to tell about our allies and friends loses. Why?? :?:
I beleive I have seen reports of allied losses most of the time there have been any. The reason you don't hear about allied casualities every day is because most days there simply aren't any. Rarely is there a day without US casualties.

I really wish life was that antiseptic for the families of our soldiers. I really would like someone to tell it like it really is to families of the 45 Canadian Soldiers that have died in Afghanistan. Please tell that to the families of the first Canadian Soldiers who were killed by friendly fire outside of Khandahar in 2002. They forgive, they do not forget.. nor should they. As someone once said.. War is Hell :!:

That is exactly what the British journalist was trying to say.

I am not cranky simply proud of our people over there :!: I have served, I know the quality of our people over there. In fact, a member of my congregation whose wife and kids I see every Sunday has his tush on the line over there right now.. 6 months ago, her brother was med-evaced to Landstuhl after a firefight with rebels. He most likely will never serve again.. he will have to be retired medically. He was pretty badly shot up. Now she has to worry about her husband. Oh and please tell that to Mrs. Megeney. My heart goes out to those families whose sons, daughters, husbands and wives will not come home again....... May They Rest In Peace (+)

As to why there are more US causualties than Canadian casualties is because there are simply more of US combat forces in the area by a wide margin. probably to the order of 3 or 4 powers.... you have what :?: 150,000 soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan combined? We have 2,000 :roll: But the point is... we are there standing beside and assisting our friends and allies..... that is the POINT....

We are there in support of US policy in Afghanistan. We did not go seeking combat, but have come willingly to the aid of our US allies. It would be prudent to acknowldge that.. or maybe next time.. the wall flower won't go to the dance at all :roll:

Guys, I did not post this to somehow get something started. I posted it because it was an interesting perspective from the Brit standpoint on how Canada is perceived by the major powers. It was refreshingly blunt.. something that almost has never happened before. We were a major power as well... but we just don't make a big deal about it.... we are well, Canadian.... :? :roll:

It was also posted as a silent commentary to those who have died over there protecting North American soil and to somehow right the wrong of 9/11 where many Canadians died in the towers as well...

This isn't about who does more or who loses more. This was simply my way to say.. Salut! to those who have gone before and those who are serving now....

My US friends are proud of their Military Forces.. and they should be. I am proud of them too, and thankful that they put themselves in harms way to keep ALL of North America safe. I am just as proud of the Canadian Forces.. let it be at that ok... please :?: :?:

CdnSupportOurTroops.gif
CanadaWaving.gif
usa_flag_waving.gif
SupportOurTroops.jpg


and this will be that for this thread...
 
Rudi":317686bl said:
Jim Becker":317686bl said:
grumpy":317686bl said:
The news media screams every day about the U.S. losses but fail to tell about our allies and friends loses. Why?? :?:
I beleive I have seen reports of allied losses most of the time there have been any. The reason you don't hear about allied casualities every day is because most days there simply aren't any. Rarely is there a day without US casualties.

As to why there are more US causualties than Canadian casualties is because there are simply more of US combat forces in the area by a wide margin. probably to the order of 3 or 4 powers.... you have what :?: 150,000 soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan combined? We have 2,000 :roll:

Rudi,
You managed to illustrate my point while totally missing it.

I was simply responding to gumpy's question/comment about why we hear about US losses everyday but not others. 2,000 to 150,000 pretty well explains why there are US losses every day whether any allied country happens to have any or not.

To get down to actual Afghanistan numbers, the ones I have seen show a total of 543 fatalities, including 373 US, 52 UK, 45 Canada and the rest from 12 other countries.

In Iraq, the total is 3481, including 3223 US. Next on the list is UK with 134 then Italy with 33. Canada has had no fatalities in Iraq. This is due to the fact that Canada has never supported the Iraq war and has no troops in the country.

I do not intend to mimimize the loss to the families of the 45 Canadians that died in Afghanistan, but in the US we have lost as many every 2 1/2 weeks for 4 years.
 
Back
Top