Best oil/ filter
- Thread starter grasser
- Start date
Denny Clayton
501 Club
Do a search for oil. You'll find enough to keep you busy reading for a week or two or three. :shock: :lol:
Bill E Bob
501 Club
Bigdog":298lryir said:
Nicely done BD :!: Informative yet discreetly side stepping the oil controversy :wink:
tractordad
501 Club
I recommend new oil and a new filter, that it. This may sound a bit odd however, so many cubs get run forever without an oil change. The fact that you're changing it is a good thing. If you know what has been run in it in the past, continue to do so. If not, do what you believe is best. This topic has been beat to death numerous times. Again, that fact that the oil is actually being changed is the best thing you can do for your tractor. And if you're changing the oil, ALWAYS change the filter!
As an OE manufacture's rep in the truck part business for many years, I've seen a lot of filter testing and price should be the last thing to look at. If you are dedicated to tracking how many engine hours you run between oil changes and you just play around a bit with the tractor, the filter will not be that critical. However, if you work your tractor and tend to go a bit long between oil changes, the quality of the filter can have a huge effect of the amount of engine wear you have. Not that the quality of you oil does not come into play here, but some of these filters have half the amount of filter media that the oil runs though verses others which again can have a major affect on engine wear. From what I've seen in testing, I've decided to run Baldwin filters on all my equipment, including my cubs. The Baldwin filter for a cub is PT135
As an OE manufacture's rep in the truck part business for many years, I've seen a lot of filter testing and price should be the last thing to look at. If you are dedicated to tracking how many engine hours you run between oil changes and you just play around a bit with the tractor, the filter will not be that critical. However, if you work your tractor and tend to go a bit long between oil changes, the quality of the filter can have a huge effect of the amount of engine wear you have. Not that the quality of you oil does not come into play here, but some of these filters have half the amount of filter media that the oil runs though verses others which again can have a major affect on engine wear. From what I've seen in testing, I've decided to run Baldwin filters on all my equipment, including my cubs. The Baldwin filter for a cub is PT135
John *.?-!.* cub owner
501 Club
If you can find out what the previews owner used in it that is frequently the best until you eventually need to rebuild, and after that it is whatever you prefer. If it had had detergent type oil in it, you can pretty much go with what you want, but if one has always run non detergent oil, I personally am hesitant to go with the detergent type until the engine is torn down and cleaned out good.
John *.?-!.* cub owner":3bp0ziac said:
I'm curious as to why you say you're hesitant to switch up with the non-detergent to detergent oil? Does it have something to do with seals, bearing or just sludge? I know you said "I personally" and I don't know enough to even have my own opinion on it. Just curious is all. Thnaks!
Steve H":2zixoh0z said:
Yes using detergent in a previously NON-detergent engine can cause leaks to worsen, sludge to fall into crankcase and cause oil starvation (block up oil pick-up or filter ) etc... So its better to use what has been used or check and see if any sludge has built up before running detergent oils... And this isn't even getting into the zinc content of the different oils (I'll let people above my pay grade tackle that one)
Mike in Louisiana
501 Club
Not all filters come with new gasket. Be sure to check
Interesting point about changing from non detergent to detergent oil.
I have no ability to rate a particular brand of oil or filter, but what I can tell you is that I've had much better luck with the thick fiber IH gasket than the rubber ones that I've gotten with some aftermarket filters. Since I don" t often work my Cub hard, I'm worried that it doesn't get hot enough long enough to cook off all of the condensation that builds up in the crankcase, so I change my oil pretty often.
Ed
I have no ability to rate a particular brand of oil or filter, but what I can tell you is that I've had much better luck with the thick fiber IH gasket than the rubber ones that I've gotten with some aftermarket filters. Since I don" t often work my Cub hard, I'm worried that it doesn't get hot enough long enough to cook off all of the condensation that builds up in the crankcase, so I change my oil pretty often.
Ed
John *.?-!.* cub owner
501 Club
A cub uses a bypass filter as opposed to a full flow filter, which means that only part of the oil goes through it, so I doubt that the maker or even quality makes a great amount of difference.