Hey Ron and Stacey,
Sorry you're having t-case troubles on the jeep. I did a google on New Process 242 (the brand and model you have), and came up with this:
"One common operating problem with the 242 transfer case is that it will stick in 4wd even if the lever is moved to 2wd. Internally, moving the lever loads a spring which then applies force to move the selector fork. If the gears are loaded with torque, the spring will not have enough energy to move the sleeve off the gears. Once torque is removed from the gears, the spring will then move the fork and slide the sleeve of the gears.
Momentarily lifting your foot off the gas will often unload the gears enough to allow the spring pressure to move the fork. On some high mileage units, a wear groove will form on the sleeve or gear causing it to stick longer and may require a couple of changes from loaded to unloaded to get the sleeve to release form the gear."
This sounds like it could be your problem, but this is just a guess. Here's the link:
http://ezinearticles.com/?Jeep-Select-T ... &id=281045 And a link for rebuild kits:
http://www.drivetrain.com/transfercases ... odel%20242
I've never cracked one of these puppies, and I'm having some issues myself with my 88 Wag that has a old NP 208 swapped in. A Jeep buddy of mine told me that I couldn't go wrong getting in touch with Steve Runyan at STR Transmissions in Woodstock....look him up and give him a call. Ron, since you've already got it pulled out, you can take it to STR and they'll rebuild it on the bench I'm told. At least that's my plan...I'm not smart enough (or brave enough!

) to bust into something with so many gears!
Let us know how it goes!
Corky