Any apple growers here?

KYMike

Well-known member
Well, turns out the red clay soil of Kentucky isn't worth a hoot for growing apples. But apples are what I want to grow and I could use your help.

How far down do apple trees root and how much room do they need? I'm attempting to grow the semi-dwarf variety and when I first planted them I dug a 12" hole about three feet deep with a post digger and threw in composted manure. The trees were about four feet tall when I planted them a year and a half ago and there has been very little growth.

Should I unplug these trees and start over? What should I use for soil amendments?

Thanks for your help.
 
Mike
I wouldn't give up on them yet. How did they do for water? Sometimes composted manure can be so old all the good has leached out and all it does is keep the area loose. Did you fertilize? I would give them a second year to catch on.
I would have started with 2 or 3 foot diamater holes from how you describe the soil. It is too late now for that. I feel a second transplant would be too much of a shock.

Bill
 
The soil here is black clay and I can't claim a whole lot of success with fruit trees either. But here are a couple things I have learned about transplanting any tree or bush.
1) The hole should be dug no deeper than the root ball but a whole lot wider. A foot deep and 3 feet across would have probably been a better size hole in your case.
2) A lot of roots are lost in transplanting, adding root stimulator at planting and during the first year helps them get going.
3) Transplants never do much the first year. Survival is success.
At this point, you need to keep it fertilized and watered as needed and you should start to see some growth.

Here is a detailed account of a transplanting job I did several years ago. It has a few specifics that applied to that job.
http://home1.gte.net/res0gehp/crepe-myrtle/Crepe-Myrtle-2003.htm
 
Jim Becker":3kpp7ej7 said:
The soil here is black clay and I can't claim a whole lot of success with fruit trees either. But here are a couple things I have learned about transplanting any tree or bush.
1) The hole should be dug no deeper than the root ball but a whole lot wider. A foot deep and 3 feet across would have probably been a better size hole in your case.
2) A lot of roots are lost in transplanting, adding root stimulator at planting and during the first year helps them get going.
3) Transplants never do much the first year. Survival is success.
At this point, you need to keep it fertilized and watered as needed and you should start to see some growth.

Here is a detailed account of a transplanting job I did several years ago. It has a few specifics that applied to that job.
http://home1.gte.net/res0gehp/crepe-myrtle/Crepe-Myrtle-2003.htm

Watering around here is never a problem since it rains weekly (most of the time).

I have not fertilized it, though. What kind would you suggest and when should it be applied?
 
My wife would use spray on like Miracle Grow. I would use 5 10 5 but not go crazy with it. If it rains as much as you indicate the might be a leaching of nutrients are you where there is a lot run off? Conversely is there any pooling or excess water? To the best of my knowledge Apples don't like it swampy.

bill
 
beaconlight":2rcb53wz said:
My wife would use spray on like Miracle Grow. I would use 5 10 5 but not go crazy with it. If it rains as much as you indicate the might be a leaching of nutrients are you where there is a lot run off? Conversely is there any pooling or excess water? To the best of my knowledge Apples don't like it swampy.

bill

Miracle grow sounds promising. No runoff or swamping. They are located in a good spot, just not really taking off like other plants I have. I think I'll just leave them be for now and plan for planting a few more trees this spring.

I love apples. I love how they look and I love how they taste. The many varieties are wonderful and the smell of apple blossom is second only to orange blossom.

Thanks for your input!
 
TAMU '78":1u8wzom7 said:
Mike,

Here are two links, one from KY on fetilization and another from OH on general apple growing:
http://www.uky.edu/Ag/Horticulture/fertilityguides.pdf
http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-fact/1000/1401.html

You may also want to contact your local County Extension Agent (normally in or near the county seat) for recommendations specific to your local area. The advice is free and based upon unbiased research.

Good luck.

Bill

Excellent links. I didn't realize we should fertalize in february here.

Thanks!
 
KYMike":343y81mt said:
Watering around here is never a problem since it rains weekly (most of the time).

I have not fertilized it, though. What kind would you suggest and when should it be applied?
Usually with new transplants you have to be careful about summer dry spells, even fairly short ones. You are probably past that concern now.

I think the starter solutions are usually high on the middle number. Again, at this point you are probably more or less past that. Your best recomendations on fertilizer are, as others said, from your local extension service. After startup, fertilizer amounts are usually based on trunk diameter at X distance from the ground.
 
We have to lime our soil here for our apple trees to grow and also
we use a 17-17-17 fertilizer for our apple trees plus spraying about four times in the summer.I have about 40 apple trees and about 30 wild apple trees that I play with . Graffing is fun to learn , I have 9 differance apples on one tree and 5 on another.
 
Mac from NS":1ox90j3c said:
We have to lime our soil here for our apple trees to grow and also
we use a 17-17-17 fertilizer for our apple trees plus spraying about four times in the summer.I have about 40 apple trees and about 30 wild apple trees that I play with . Graffing is fun to learn , I have 9 differance apples on one tree and 5 on another.

What do you spray them with?
 
I use one put out by ( Wilson ) FRUIT PLUS. Kills insects and controls diseases. There is a web site here on the bottle.

http://WWW.wilson.nu-gro.com

They also have a dormant spray for over wintering insects.
Don't spray when they are in blossum or it will hill your bees.
 
Hi Mike

The PH of the soil is very important. If it is not in the right range the tree or plant cannot use any of the fertiliser in the ground as it cannot asorb it into the roots. Different plants and trees need different PH so you have to find out what a apple tree needs and have the soil tested.

Tom brought up the facts of adding charcoal to the soil too. It helps bacteria in the soil that help break down fertiliser so the tree can use it.

My brother has a different way of looking at the whole thing. He said
You have to feed the soil so it can feed the plants (or trees)

When I plant my roses or trees I take a five gallon bucket cut a bunch of willow branches put them in it and fill it with water. I then use this willow tea the water with. The willow branches put a enzime in the water that makes the roots grow and has worked very well for me.

Billy
 
Hi Mike,

I throw in my 2 cents here, as I also play around with apples in the backyard.

Apples do not like wet feet. Clay is usually associated with wet, acidic conditions. So, right off the bat you are at a disadvantage. But, if you can pick spots on your property that sit a little higher you may be able to have some success with your apples. I have the typical gray, northeast clay in a very cold Zone 5, but the apples I planted in select locations are doing fine. You could also get crazy with drainage systems. If you are planting an orchard, you could experiment with a trap-rock and tile drainage plan that would shed water from the orchard. That would create drier, less acididc soils, that warm up earlier in spring. It would also create an orchard with soils that would be easier to amend.

One other suggestion, that I think Jim Becker mentioned, is to dig a wider hole, but not so deep. If you plant the root ball (or dry root stock) in the hole too deep, the graft union will be below the soil line, and you may lose some of the semi-dwarf qualities of your tree because the grafted portion of the tree will now send roots into the soil and impart its own traits into the growing tree.

There is a great mail order nursery in NY State called St. Lawrence Nurseries. They must have 100 different types of apples for sale. Everything they sell is specialized to growing in northern areas, but I think they would do fine in KY especially if you live in the mountains. I asked the owner if he would recommend a variety that would do well in wet clayey soils and he said any of the Russian varieties seem to tolerate those conditions better than most. That's what I grow and they are doing fine. Here is a link:

http://www.sln.potsdam.ny.us/

Good luck.
Blair in Savoy, MA
 
Mike:

We are in Zone 5. Cold yup.. and apples like it - and I think they like it a lot... much like those who can appreciate a good Alexander Keith'e IPA right Mac :?: :?:

Mac and I live in a world famous prime apple growing area. From the Annapolis Valley in Nova Scotia throughout southeastern New Brunswick, we are world renowned for the apples we grow and the different varieties that have been developed here. The Apple Blossom Festival each spring is an portent of summer and Apples just around the corner.

Em and I experiment with apples along with peaches, pears, cherries, plums and hopefully kiwis (which do well here also). We have transplanted a Snow Apple tree (it was grown from an old apple tossed out of a car window onto the ground beside our house in the old field next door. It was a victim of tree caterpillars, and we would have to treat it yearly.. after about 3 or 4 years of this, whilst the high-hoe was here, I had it dug up and moved to our backyard. Emilie gave it a severe haircut, and the next year it actually bore a couple of apples. Since then it has borne better apples, but they are not the eating type as they are a bit on the too tart side and a little soft when ripe.. but are good for pies and sauce.

Anyways, the point is. When we dug up this tree and as we do for all of our fruit trees, we usually make the hole for the root ball about 16" - 24" deep and put in about 6 inches of nice potting soil/loam mixed with peat moss. We add Bone Meal as an amendment to help the roots establish. then in-fill around the tree keeping the knot/graft just above ground level.

Water regularly, but not too much. Use some Miracle Grow or Jobe's Fruit Tree Spikes or any other good Fruit tree fertilizer that is available in your area, and meets the needs of your soil. Good idea to test your soil. There are Soil Testing Kits available for that and we have tested our soil with kits successfully. Having it done by the Agriculture Dept is also an option, but here it is costly.

Also, don't forget. There is also the graft process. Apples can be grafted onto just about any hardy fruit tree root stock..

This spring our friend Roger Bourgeois from Belliveau Orchards will be along to help me with my Gall or Black Knot problem on my 2 Damnson plums trees, help teach me how to properly prune for best natural (not forced) production on my pears, cherries and peach trees as well as re-graft a few other varieties on to my apple trees. Growing fruit trees is very rewarding, and can be a relaxing as well as a tasty hobby.

Apples and other fruit trees are not easy to grow. They do take serious maintenance, however that maintenance is not all that difficult. Malthion and a couple of other pesticides and fungicides are available that should be sprayed on a regular regimen. With a hand sprayer this can be monotonous and painful, but with a tag along 12 volt sprayer, it is much easier. I had one for my Craftsman, and I now use it with me JD 111 Lawn tractor. Very useful. Do read the directions though.

I hope you get some better results.
 
Thanks for all the great suggestions and links.

Previously I bought from a nursery named Southmeadow who dealt with old english apples. I lived in So. California then and believe it or not those 3 year old trees (Cox Orange pippen and Ashmead's Kernel) flourished at that locale. When I moved to Germany for work my father planted them in his garden and they took off again!

I tried to order a few trees from them three years ago but they have a nasty habit of not answering their email or the phone. Must be volunteers now running the place. Their catalog is very informative.

Thanks again-
 
Mike:

Where in Germany did you live? Curious. My family is from the Wurzburg Heidingsfeld area, family is still there and we enjoyed our visit the last time about 20 years ago. Need to go back. Also, Em and I lived in the Lahr area at the CFB back in the mid 80's. Our eldest daughter Sabrina was born in the Universitaats Klinik in Freiburg am Briesgau :!: Em had a crash course in German as she was 2 or 3 weeks in the hospital with no one capable of English or French... she was quite adept at the language very quickly..
hehe.gif
 
I lived in a small town called Im Kirschgarten which is near Wackenheim (known for their spargel). I worked at the 563rd Ordance Company in Weisbaden as a civilian contractor on the DIVADS project through my company (Ford Aerospace).

It was interesting, to say the least. Currency exchange rate at the time was 3.5/1 so I lived very cheap. Took a half year to get to know the Germans but after that they did everything for me. I miss the people and the place very much.

Hope you do make it back there soon.
 
If you have cider trees nearby (within a couple of miles), look for species that are immune to rust. Also some of the older species of apples happen to be immune and taste good too. Coumty extension might be of help here.

Richard
 
Hi, KYMIKE I was just looking at your post since it is raining here in the northwest & I can't work in my garden. I had a friend here who grew apples & cherries for a living. He was getting older & was looking for an easier way to plant trees. He used a post hole auger with a 24" auger & planted the tree as he usually did but several years later they weren't doing so good. He dug one of them up and found that the roots had just grown in circles and hadn't grown into the native soil much. He found out that the auger compacted the soil so hard that roots wouldn't grow through this hard soil, so he would take a shovel and dig the hole more square and leave the sides more rough and it worked good. I"M wondering if this could be some of your problem, you might check one of them. Also as someone else said trees sometimes take several years to start growing from the shock to there systems from different growing conditions. GOOD LUCK
 
Back
Top