Like any major investment... you really need to decide what you want the compressor to do. Sand blast, painting, running air tools... and do you just want to be able to run one tool at a time or more than one. Also what kind of cycle time do you want... the larger the tank the longer between cycles.
One of the most overlooked places to buy a compressor is a commercial compressor shop. THey usually have some really good deals on high end compressors/commercial compressors such as those used in automotive shops, paint shops, fabrication plants etc.... A 100 gallon lay down is a nice sized tank, and even a 60 - 100 gallon upright will fit in smaller places. You might be surprised at what you can save. On top of that, a commercial compressor usually runs on 220 which will reduce your electric bill. I have had my DeVillBliss for over 22 years now and it was the best buy I ever made. Make sure you get the electrics with it.
Your small 2hp compressor is good for inflating tires I guess and could be used also for some small air tools, but the cycle times are going to be murder. A 20-30 gallon tank is going to be better, but not a whole lot. The cycle times when running say an air sander will be much higher than a 100 gallon tank, with an air ratchet or impact wrench same thing. The more often the compressor runs the harder on the individual components. Think about what you want to accomplish then investigate which type would be best for you.