1959 Chevy crash test

Here is my conclusion , the guy that decided to crash the 59 Belair is an idiot :( ....... whats next an Model T Vs a F-150 maybe :? .......


Actually it does show the nice safety aspects of the newer cars but still to wreck a vintage car to prove it was not needed at all, its a stupid test......
 
There is an old saying that comes to mind whenever I see anything from the IIHS.
Figures Don't Lie; But Liars Can Figure
In this case, the first thought that came to mind was to wonder how much time they spent studying both cars to determine how much to offset the collision so they could maximize the damage to the '59 model. They chose a '59 model because that is the year IIHS was formed. They are trying to get people to give them credit for all the improvements.

By the way, IIHS is an insurance industry association. You all helped pay for this demonstration.
 
Carl:

I saw that on the news on the boob toob the other night. Kinda interesting.. but what shocked me was the destruction of a classic car. Although it wasn't my favourite year for the Bel-Air -- that honour would be the 57 rag top model's ..... :D. It still is a shame to destroy a classic just to honk ones horn :roll: :wink: :lol: . I did notice the stats though... and they are well interesting to say the least.
AB748DCA7384D2B7AD104A21F9D31.jpg

And yeah, I liked the dice :big smile:
 
I seriously doubt the took a good BelAir and crashed it. probably found a junker with salvageable body , painted and puttied it, then towed it down the test track.
They state in the site that the Chevy Bel Air weighed 3600 pounds. I would have figured to to be much heavier than that. My Ford Ranger weighs 4500.
 
Chev BelAir weights 3800 lbs. 2008 Malibu weight not listed.

There is something wrong with the test. The 2009 Malibu actually drives the heavier Chev Bel Air backwards. The Malibu just turns sideways.

I watched the crash test a number of times. I was looking for the driveshaft to drop below the frame of the Belair - didn't happen. If the engine and transmission were in place, the bend in the drive line would take place in the U joint immediately behind the transmision.

Think I will watch the video again and see if the BelAir's rear wheels get shoved back before it's body.

Edit. Nope rear wheels don't stop going forward until the body stops.
 
Any reasonable soul would expect product as complex as an automobile would show dramatic improvements over a half century. IIHS took considerably liberties to make this demonstration even more dramatic.

[youtube]5CU-k0XmLUk[/youtube]
There is a considerable plumb of rust coming from the Belair, powder and paint make them what they ain't.



[youtube]d309QCuve7c[/youtube]
The Malibu is considerably narrower than the Belair, making for an unequal offset. The offset was 50% of the Malibu's front end colliding into much less than 50% of the Belair. Physics prevailed.


IIHS picked GM over Ford and Chrysler for one specific reason - frame design. 1959 was the second year for the light 'X' style frame instead of the heavier perimeter frame used before and after this particular short-lived frame design. The Malibu struck considerably left of center into the Belair, essentially missing both the engine and left frame rail. This Belair was equipped with the narrow inline 6 with a manual transmission rather than the wider V8 and Powerglide powertrain. Only sheet metal and the left front wheel/suspension was absorbing the Malibu's impact before reaching the firewall and tearing open the passenger compartment. GM models constructed with perimeter frames would have better withstood the Malibu's impact.

They could have flung a 1909 Chevy sedan into the Belair back in 1959 to show the same remarkable engineering and construction improvements that over that 50 year period. And again fifty years from today, I'm sure.
 
Carl, in the first link of your post there are 3 boxes with information that pop up just after the Insurance Institutes banner. I tried several times to stop the video so i could read them, but it always jumped past them, can you see what they said?
 
I just googled 59 Chevy Bel Air Weight and found this Popular Mechanics Apr 1959. Surprisingly there is a 59 Plymouth Belvedere and a Ford Galaxy 500 as comparison to the Bel Air -- seems a fair match. Interestingly there are a bunch of comments we can all relate to. Even in the good ole days... workmanship seemed to be a problem along with gas mileage. Even in 1959 this was a concern :? :shock: :!: Interesting article... :D Ranking - Chev, Plymouth and then Ford in that order... hmmmm :roll: :wink: :arrow: :?:
 
John *.?-!.* cub owner":30owkvgm said:
Carl, in the first link of your post there are 3 boxes with information that pop up just after the Insurance Institutes banner. I tried several times to stop the video so i could read them, but it always jumped past them, can you see what they said?

There are actually four to read. The first blinks through too fast to get a good read, a quick summary for all the boxes:

Before we get to the crash, I want to clear up a few things . . .

1. The car is completely intact, nothing is missing, the engine and all components are still in it, the frame has not been compromised.

2. Combined speed of 80 mph, both cars are traveling at 40 mph.

3. The driver of the Belair would have died from this collision even if seat belts were worn.



Here is a good explaination of the crash. The frame breaking could be a result of decades of stress and rust that the Malibu was never exposed to. The billowing cloud of rust from the Belair certainly indicates structural integrity was compromised. I'd be interested to see how two Crown Vics, one brand new and the other exposed to years of service as a NYC police car and taxicab, perform against each other.
[youtube]2IDfP7gPskA[/youtube]
 
Maybe I will go out and put my 1967 Camaro up against one of my Cubs in the barnyard and study the results. I haven't posted a video for a couple of days.
 
I had a 78 El Camino. The frame rusted out. Originally there wasn't enough frame left to hold up the bumper. I wired the bumper to the still solid body with #9 wire. Used it that way for a couple of years as a farm vehicle. Finally had to give up on the car after the A/C quit, then the radio quit, then a radiator hose burst and the rear of the pickup bed was about 3" off the ground.
 
Back
Top