Woodburning insert

59cub

Well-known member
Looking at inserts for the upcoming winter. Narrowed down between either Osburn or Pacific Energy, does anyone use either, or heard any good/bad things. Thanks for any help! 59.
 
Never used the inserts but do have an Osburn Wood stove. Great little unit with the exception of the baffel plate falling off (where it was welded to the top) and a real pain to weld back up. Would have another one though. good luck. Grump
 
I heated a house for many years with a Sierra insert. Excellent stove. I had to cut out the damper to get the pipe far enough up the stack. Keep the chimney clean. I had a chimney explosion once strong enough to move the stove a few inches.
 
I put in a Quadra-Fire 4100i last fall. We did it ourselves and it went fairly well. Didn't fall off the ladders, so that was a big plus!
I had narrowed it down between the Quadra-Fire and a Regency insert.

Missed out on the 30% energy tax credit by 2 1/2 months that went into effect January 1, 2009. :( :x

Peter
 
At mom's house we had a Black Bart insert for over twenty years. I helped dad install it back in the mid seventies. We had to pull it once to replace the blower motor (back then they stuck them in the back of the stove. I remember we had to cut out the damper in the fireplace. Made a rectangular sheet metal box to route the smoke out of the top of the stove up through the damper. We stuck the box up the chimney stuffed insulation around it then pulled the box back down and bolted it too the top of the stove with stove cement making the gasket. The top of the stove finally rusted and cracked. We had a leak we didn't know about in the chimney :( We relined the chimney with stainless 10 or 15 years ago and replaced the stove with a Grizzly insert. Insurance picked up a big chunk of it due to a chimney fire. At the time it was the only source of heat in that part of the house. The Grizzly is a nice little stove, glass door so you can see the fire. The blowers are hidden in the front of the unit. The Grizzly stove was a lot more efficient. But then I bet a lot has changed in stove technology since it had been installed :) I used to make sure mom had plenty of wood on the porch and in the house. She is 86 now and doesn't use it. She has some decorative wood and ceramic squirrels in it now.

Doug
 
I installed a Maine made Yotul insert last year and it works great. I have not heard of the other two brands.
 
56cub, you did not say if you were looking at a secondary burn or catalyst type stove. I was looking between a Napoleon and Pacific Energy free standing stove and was leaning towards the P.E. Aldeara stove as it has a cook top so I could make me up a big pot of chillie while waching the fire :{_}: Before I decided I just could not afford it at this time. I was going to go with a seconday burn system as with the catalyst you have to wait until it hits a certen temp before fliping a lever and using the catalyst. And the cats wear out and are expensive to replace.

Billy
 
Since I do not know info on any particular brand, I have delayed replying to this, but around 25 years ago my in-laws bought a house about 2600 sq. ft. with a fireplace. After the first winter's electric bills, he bought an insert for the fireplace. After that, he easily heated the entire poorly insulated house with the insert. The fire place happened to be located in the living room, directly inline with the long hall way, and the blowers would blow the warm air the entire length of the the hall and heat the other rooms.
 
John, Thats the way mine is set up. And some times I turn the central heat and air unit on FAN ONLY when I get the fire going and it gets too hot in the living room.
 
Thank you all for the replies, the hearth.com website sure did answer alot of questions. I decided on the Osburn, it was the best fit. I have been a little shy on over-firing it, however. They say it takes the whole first season to figure out how your stove in your situation is going to work. I can say that it does heat our first floor well. It is about 7 degrees cooler upstairs, though. I think that is perfect for sleeping, wife not so much. I never wish for cold weather, but I am anxious to see if it will keep up when it gets really chilly. Any reduction in the utility bill will be nice. Oh and it is a secondary burn type insert. Thanks again to all! :D
 
Back
Top