Which Impact Wrench to Buy

Bill Hudson

501 Club
Folks,

Got to do a lot of wrenching today and in the process severly brusied (or broke) a rib. No need for the gorey details but I don't need to be doing that again. That means I need a 1/2 inch impact wrench with a lot of torque. I really want a Snap-On, however, having said that, common sense must prevail. What should I be considering for my purchase? Your help is appreciated.

(Yes, I understand that this is akin to asking what kind of oil to use. I'm willing to take the risk. :) :) )

Bill
 
Bill, not sure if they are still carrying it, but Sam's Club used to carry a kit made by Cambell Hausfeld (SP?) that I bought about 5-6 yrs ago. It came with a 1/2" impact wrench, 3/8" rachet, chisel, die grinder, and attachements all packaged in a case.

I spent less than $100 for the kit and it is still serving it's purpose. Snap-On is "Top Notch" but a little too pricey for me.

Not sure if you have a Sam's Club near you and such, but I could check our local store here within the week and see if they are still carrying that item?
 
Bill
I use an electric Dewalt 1/2" drive that works very well for me. I think It was at 160.00 or something nearby. I would check Amazon. 250lbs
Model 239 .

Something to consider.

Jim :D
 
Top of the line Snap-on will run about 375 but it will out perform anything I have ever used, has about 700 ft lbs in reverse! I have a Sioux and a top of the line Craftsman here at home, both have done everything I think a 1/2 should do. Ingersol Rand also makes good ones. In most cases the more expensive they are the more torque you get, you just need to figure out how much power do you really need.
Check out your local Cornwell Tools dealer, he may have a used one.
 
I've had a Craftsman for about two years. It has been more than adequate (including snapping off bolts) for anything I've done on a Cub. I hope nobody posts any new Boudreaux jokes, laughing hurts with a cracked rib. Take care.

Bob
 
Bill:

Chicago Pneumatic, Ingersoll-Rand, Campbell Hausfield are all pretty darn good choices and good value for the buck on impact wrenches. I have a Campbell Hausfield 1/2" and it has served me very well for almost 8 years now. I am impressed with it. The other day I picked up a 3/8" Butterfly Impact Wrench from Princess Auto.. and I am wondering why I never bought one before.. I am really impressed with that one as well. All of my air tools that I get at Princess have been extremely good to me and in many ways rival the professional high end stuff that I bought years ago for my cabinet shop when I was not Independantly Poor and Not Required To Work For a Living :wink: :lol:

Sure beats getting your knuckles rapped.. Snap-On is great stuff, unfortunately for most of it, it is just out of my league. As for Craftsman, too expensive for what it is these days, it isn't what it used to be.
 
Harbor freight is not a top quality company, but I have had some of their impact wrenches for many years. This set for probably 30 years

92208.gif


http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/d ... mber=92208
Only 230 foot pounds, but good for disassembly if not real tight.

About 5 years ago I bought one of these.

02623.gif


http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/d ... umber=2623

623 foot pounds of torque. also been well pleased with it, but you have to be careful of breaking bolts with it if turned up all they way. Don't forget to also get some air tool oil.
 
That Central Pneumatic Earthquake is one strong wrench.

We got a couple of them in the shop. Harbor Freight has a sale on them every now and then. We got ours for $69.00. I also have a Snap On and the Earthquake is actually stronger.
 
Bill,

I agree with all of the recommendations above, and think you can do great with any of the choices listed. But for our Cubs, I don't think you'll need a 1/2" drive bulldog of a wrench on 95 % of the bolts that hold these neat little tractors together. Quite the contrary. After 50+ years of holding together, a much lighter impact wrench may actually do better...try a 3/8" drive...I got one from Home Depot and it has yet to break off a bolt head yet. Just my 2 cents. :D

Corky
 
I think that the most bang for the buck is the Ingersol Rand, model 231. It can usually be found in the neighborhood of $120, has great torque and holds up very well. A testament for it, it's the wrench all NASCAR teams use for tire changes. Theirs are modified, of course, but that's what they start with. I've used these for many years, and have always thought them among the best.
 
Back
Top