hydralic oil vs motor oil

Mr Joshua

Well-known member
At my work we are designing a new product and i was asked by the engineer what the difference was between hydralic fluid and motor oil.

My guess is something to do with the detergents or compressibility.

if anyone can help it would be greatly appreciated
thanks
josh
 
Non-detergent motor oil was often used for tractor hydraulics until the 1960s, it is a good hydraulic fluid. I think modern motor oils have additives that are unnecessary or detrimental for hydraulics and seals, particularly those additives which tend to entrain air.
 
Modern motor oil sure has changed in the last few years some of the wear additives were removed. The oil is so bad right now wear wise you can't put it in the modern motorcycles anymore with the wet clutches they will burn out.

I think that modern motor oil is more spongy over hydraulic oil when it gets hotter it may get worse and suck up some of the hydraulic power. Hydraulic oil is thinner and probably flows easier. In a pinch when you need a little hydraulic oil I use ATF for my snowplow.(food for thought)

All hydraulic oils aren't the same too some have anti wear additives. I worked with one of the top metalurgist in the country and he always was testing hydraulic oil samples for the hydraulic elevators we ride everyday. He was a metal CSI guy too he found one problem were the bronze metal for the gears wasn't mixed correctly before it was poured into the molds. If you think our food is inspected you should see the elevator world. Its very safe.
 
Josh, I did a little searching and found a plausible explanation on a web site called "Bob is the Oil Guy". Here it is:

The most significant characteristic that differs between a "motor" oil and a "hydraulic" oil are the emulsifiers. In most hydraulic applications, we want for the water to fall to the bottom, not get mixed where, at high pressures, it will increase erosion. Motor oil is changed to get rind of the emulsified water (and other "crud"). If it is used in hydraulic applications, I'd change it at the engine change interval, or maybe every other. A good AW fluid, not overheated, kept dry and clean, would probably last the life of a mobile machine.

Hope that helps. :D
 
Wow. Some hydraulic system designers/manufacturers specify the exact hydraulic oil to use. Specific to the point that any hydraulic oil not meeting their specifications voids the warranty.

Some hydraulic oil characteristics: cost, lubricating quality, low specific gravity, oil film strength, compressability, flamablity, rust inhibitors, foam suppressants, viscosity index improvers, chemical reaction, high temperature operation, low temperature operation, oxide resisitance. OK - got the point.

Once you engineer figures out the machine's hydraulic system and it's characteristics, he/she should consult with the firm that supplies oil to your company.
 
Back
Top